Noosa Council Watch

An independent, unofficial record of Noosa Shire Council. About this site

Noosa Council court cases

Council goes to court constantly, and almost always out of sight. Nearly every decision to fight, settle or fold is taken in a closed session, and council publishes no list of the matters it is running. This is one, assembled from the record council does publish.

95matters on record, 1993–2026
30with a written judgment
5–6won–lost where the result is clear-cut
33appeals taken to closed session since 2014

How this was built. Three sources, none of them inside a closed session. Council must name each appeal on an agenda every time it takes a decision about it — usually the decision to shut the doors — so those headings, pulled back out of council's own published agendas, give a docket council never compiled. Reported judgments come from Queensland Judgments and the Information Commissioner. Outcomes come from the open-session resolutions where council ratifies what it agreed to behind the door. Where we could not establish an outcome, the table says so rather than guessing.

How they end, and who makes the call

Every court matter in the register, sorted by how it finished and who decided that. This comes from what the record actually shows: a judgment, a resolution council read out in open session, or the court's own file. Where none of those exists, the matter is counted as such rather than guessed at.

How it endedMatters
A judge or tribunal decided it
28
A ruling along the way, not the end of the case
4
Council voted, result announced in open session
22
Handed to the CEO by council vote
1
Settled, no council vote found
12
The other side withdrew
9
Court order, terms not published
7
Still running
7
Not established
2

Most appeals never reach a judge. Of the 83 matters with a known ending, 35 were settled — 22 on a vote council announced in open session, 1 after council voted to hand the case to the CEO, and 12 with no vote to settle anywhere in the published record. Another 9 ended when the other side gave up. 28 were decided by a judge or tribunal, most of them long ago: settled appeals produce no judgment, so the older record is weighted towards the cases that went the distance.

"No council vote found" means council's eTrack register or the court file shows the appeal settled, but we have not found a resolution to settle it in the published agendas and minutes. It means we could not find a vote, not that none was taken: some of these went into closed session and the outcome was never minuted in the open.

Open, as far as the record shows

Matters with no resolution on the public record. Some are plainly live; others have simply gone quiet, and council never came back to an open session to say how they ended. The date each one was last named on an agenda is the honest measure of how current this is.

Every appeal we can trace

Planning & Environment Court appeals against council decisions, newest activity first. Before council counts the times the matter appeared on a published agenda, and how many of those went into closed session — a matter listed twice in a fortnight is the committee and then the ordinary meeting ratifying it. From April 2023 every listing is counted; from 2014 to 2023 only the closed-session items, read from the agendas and minutes, so an older appeal's count is its closed sessions alone. Blank means we found no listing at all. Where we hold no register entry for an appeal, the description is council's own agenda heading, verbatim — typos and all.

Reported judgments

Matters that produced written reasons, so anyone can read what the court actually said. 30 of them, 1993 to 2026.

Council wins when it is defending

Our reading

Of the 12 reported judgments with a clear-cut result, council is 5–6 with 1 split. Sorted by who started the fight, the pattern is sharper than the raw tally: in every one of those wins council was the respondent, defending a refusal or a notice it had already issued. In the two decided matters where council was the moving party — its declaration against 64 Gateway Drive, and its non-party disclosure application in the Noosa Airfield enforcement — it lost both. Its third proceeding as applicant, the 2022 Kin Kin Quarry breach litigation, produced a part win: an enforcement order on covered truck loads, and failure on the intensification and school-hours truck limits it also sought.

Two decided matters is a small number to hang a pattern on, and the sample is skewed by what gets written up: settled appeals produce no judgment and no reasons, and they are the large majority of council's caseload. But it is the only tally the public record supports, and it points the same way each time.

Who council pays to run these

Instructing solicitors named in the judgments, by the matters they appeared in, including judgments in cases the register files under their court number. Counsel are listed against each judgment above. This counts appearances, not fees — council does not break out legal spend by matter.

FirmMattersSpan
McCullough Robertson 8 2021–2026
Thynne + Macartney 5 2021–2024
Wakefield Sykes 5 2015–2020
HopgoodGanim 1 2006
Deacons 2 2002
King & Company 1 2002

The contracts behind them

Council's legal-services contracts as they appear in its published list of contracts worth $200,000 or more (Local Government Regulation s 237). Each is listed on a schedule of rates, paid at agreed rates for the work done, so the list gives no contract sum.

ListedContractFirm
2026-08 Provision of Legal Services for Planning Appeals CN26152 McCullough Robertson Lawyers
2026-08 Provision of Legal Services for Planning Appeals CN26153 Thynne & Macartney Lawyers
2024-06 Legal Services CN24839 McCullough Robertson Lawyers

We found no council resolution awarding any of the three: they appear only in the published list. A contract awarded by the CEO under delegation need not come to a meeting. All council contracts →

Council's planning work sat with Wakefield Sykes of Tewantin for most of the two decades after de-amalgamation — the same firm that had acted against the shire in the Kettering and Cameron appeals before it acted for it. From 2021 the work moved to the Brisbane firms, split between Thynne + Macartney and McCullough Robertson; every judgment so far in 2026 has had McCullough Robertson acting for council, and in August 2026 council put both firms on contracts for planning appeals. On the other side, one firm recurs more than any other: P&E Law has appeared against council in 8 of the reported matters.

Not in a courtroom

Three matters that belong on a legal register without being court cases: two councillor-conduct findings, and one in which council was the victim.

What this page cannot show you

Outcomes marked not established mean exactly that: council listed the appeal, and we have not found a published resolution or judgment saying how it ended. If you know how one of them finished, tell us.

On the agenda

The 8 most recent of 160 agenda items and minuted decisions about court cases since 2016, found by their titles. All of them →

  1. 20 Aug 2026 PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT APPEAL 1576 OF 2026 - SHORT STAY LETTING LOCAL LAW REVIEW DECISION - 8 WITTA CIRCUIT, NOOSA HEADS Ordinary Meeting, item 11.1.9 Local lawswatch
  2. 20 Aug 2026 MCU17/0559.05 - PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT APPEAL 1842 OF 2026 - FOR MINOR CHANGE TO A DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR A MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE FOR A DUPLEX DWELLING AT 2/16 GRANT STREET, NOOSA HEADS Ordinary Meeting, item 11.1.11 Grants & fundingDevelopmentwatch
  3. 20 Aug 2026 PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT APPEAL 1763 OF 2026 - SHORT STAY LETTING LOCAL LAW REVIEW DECISION - 5/7 PEZA COURT, NOOSA HEADS Ordinary Meeting, item 11.1.10 Local lawswatch
  4. 11 Aug 2026 MCU17/0559.05 - PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT APPEAL 1842 OF 2026 - FOR MINOR CHANGE TO A DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR A MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE FOR A DUPLEX DWELLING AT 2/16 GRANT STREET, NOOSA HEADS General Committee, item 7.2.6 Grants & fundingDevelopmentwatch
  5. 11 Aug 2026 PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT APPEAL 1763 OF 2026 - SHORT STAY LETTING LOCAL LAW REVIEW DECISION - 5/7 PEZA COURT, NOOSA HEADS General Committee, item 7.2.5 Local lawswatch
  6. 11 Aug 2026 PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT APPEAL 1576 OF 2026 - SHORT STAY LETTING LOCAL LAW REVIEW DECISION - 8 WITTA CIRCUIT, NOOSA HEADS General Committee, item 7.2.4 Local lawswatch
  7. 16 Jul 2026 CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR PUBLIC RELEASE - PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT APPEAL D927 OF 2025 - APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR BUILDING WORKS (DWELLING HOUSE) AND REFERRAL AGENCY PLANNING (BUILDING HEIGHT, GROSS FLOOR AREA, SETBACKS, AND CUT) AT 58 SEAVIEW TERRACE, SUNSHINE BEACH Ordinary Meeting, item 14.2 Closed doorswatch
  8. 21 May 2026 CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR PUBLIC RELEASE - PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT APPEAL 2611 OF 2024 - APPLICATION FOR A MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE FOR MULTIPLE DWELLINGS (4 X SMALL DWELLINGS) AND FOOD AND DRINK OUTLETS (2 X TENANCIES) AND OFFICE AT 2 BOTTLEBRUSH AVENUE, NOOSA HEADS (Referred from General Committee Meeting dated 12 May 2026 Item 9.3) Ordinary Meeting, item 12.1 Closed doorsDevelopmentwatch

Elsewhere on this site

Every page here that links to this one, by section.