Noosa Council Watch

An independent, unofficial record of Noosa Shire Council — what council decided, what they closed the doors on, and why it matters. About this site

Deputations and public questions to council, each opening on what council's minutes record of it.

2024-05-16 Public question Ordinary Meeting May 2024

Debra Walz - Fluoride

Heard at the meeting. Council's recording has these questions from 55:09; our transcript is below.

▶ Hear it — council's recording, from 55:09
The feed timestamps the whole public question block rather than each speaker, so this starts at the top of that block.

What the minutes record

Question 1

Can Council provide an update regarding progress with SEQWater in relation to removing fluoride from Noosa Shire's drinking water, including a cost analysis and estimate timeframe on the impact on Council's budget over the period of time to transition to fluoride free water?

Response from Director Development & Regulation, Richard MacGillivray

It’s important to highlight Noosa Council does not manage the treatment and distribution of potable water in Noosa. Treatment is undertaken by Seqwater and distribution by UnityWater. As the operators of the fluoride dosing process, it is appropriate for Seqwater to provide advice on these matters. The question received by Council from Ms Walz on 5 December 2023 was forwarded to Seqwater for advice on 7 December 2023. I can advise a response was finally received from Seqwater in April this year. In their response Seqwater confirm that the ‘Fluoridation of the water supply is a public health measure administered by the Queensland Government’. ‘Seqwater monitors fluoride concentrations in drinking water continuously and reports the result to Queensland Health regularly’. Their response also states that ‘to date, no Council that Seqwater supplies in South East Queensland has requested to cease fluoridation of potable water. Therefore, an economic cost analysis and works management timeframe is not available. Any such analysis would need to consider a range of factors given the Noosa Water Supply Zone is connected to the broader SEQ Water Grid. Noosa was connected to the grid in 2012 to bolster water security for the region, particularly in times of drought.’ Notwithstanding that no specific economic cost analysis has been provided by Seqwater, given the Noosa Water Supply is connected and receives water from the broader SEQ Water Grid, it is clear that the process would be complex and the cost to ratepayers to remove fluoride from the potable water supply would likely be significant. The matters raised in the petition received by Council is currently being reviewed and a response will be provided in due course.

Question 2

What is the molecular form of the fluoride compound that is used in Noosa Shire's water, including the origin of this compound, and is this compound chemically pure?

Response from Director Development & Regulation, Richard MacGillivray

The chemical processes and materials employed in the fluoridation of water across SEQ are significantly outside the scope of Council's remit, and it is advised that this enquiry can be best addressed directly with the water supplier, Seqwater.

This is council's own minuted record, in council's words. Nothing is reworded: the questions, headings and bullets are laid out as the printed minutes set them. Left out are the speaker's name (it heads this page), the minutes' page-header dates, and any “meeting adjourned” line the extract caught. Where an officer answered, the answer is minuted with the question and appears above.

Transcript of the recording

What this is. Transcript of council's recording, produced by automatic speech recognition and not checked line by line against the video. Names and figures are where this kind of transcript fails first. It is our transcript, not council's record. Recording © Noosa Shire Council. Council's own recording is linked above; where the two differ, the recording governs.

55:09 Deborah Walsh: In relation to removing fluoride from Noosa Shire's drinking water, including a cost analysis and estimate timeframe on the impact of council's budget over a period of time to transition to fluoride free water.

55:25 Speaker 2: Thank you Deborah. It's important to highlight that Noosa Council does not manage the treatment and distribution of potable water in Noosa. The treatment is undertaken by SEQ water and distributed by Unity Water. As the operators of the fluoride dosing process, it is appropriate for SEQ water to provide advice on these matters. The questions received from council from Ms Walsh on the 5th of December 2023 was forwarded on to SEQ water for advice on the 7th of December 2023. I can advise that a response was finally received from Sec Water in April of this year. In their response, Sec Water confirmed that the fluoridation of water supply is a public concern. It is a public health measure administered by the Queensland Government. Sec Water monitors the fluoride concentrations in drinking water continuously and reports on the results to Queensland Health Regulatory. The response also states that to date no council that SEQ water supplies in South East Queensland has requested to cease fluoridation of potable water. Therefore, an economic cost analysis and works management timeframe is not available. As such, analysis would need to consider a range of factors given the Noosa water supply zone is connected to the broader SEQ water grid.

56:48 Noosa was connected to the grid in 2020-2012 to bolster water security for the region, particularly in times of drought. Notwithstanding that no specific economic cost analysis has been provided by SEQ water, given the Noosa water supply is connected and receives water from the broader SEQ water grid, it is clear that the process would be complex and the cost to ratepayers to remove fluoride from the potable water supply would likely be significant. The matters raised in the petition received by council is currently being reviewed and a response will be provided to you in due course.

57:27 Deborah Walsh: The second question is in relation to the Say No to Fluoride petition accepted and tabled at the Ordinary Meeting in December last year. The question is, what is the molecular form of the fluoride compound that is used in the Noosa Shire's water, including the origin of the compound, and is this compound chemically pure?

57:53 Speaker 2: Great question. The chemical process and materials employed in the fluoridation of water across SEQ are significantly outside the scope of council's remit. And therefore it's advised that this inquiry can be rescheduled. And therefore a request will be made that it can be best addressed directly with the water supply, SEQ water. What I would like to do, I'm happy to reach out directly to seek your contact from SEQ Water, to assist you with this inquiry, and any other similar inquiries you might have of a similar nature, just to assist with getting some responses to your very technical questions.

Others who spoke that day

Elsewhere on this site

Every page here that links to this one, by section.