Before the first item ¶
00:00:00 Mayor Wilkie: To the ordinary men, on the first day of the 22nd of January, take the meeting open at 10 a.m. Acknowledge that we're meeting on the lands of the traditional custodians, the Kabi Kabi people, Pay My Express, Elders, Past, Present, and Emerging, and reiterate their invitation for us to join them as joint custodians in respecting and caring for this beautiful place that we all love, and respecting and caring for each other. I'd also like to acknowledge today as National Day of Mourning for the victims of the Bondi Beach terrorist attack, and that is the reason that council is flying the Australian flag at half-mast today as our local governments are in the country. The Australian government has invited members of the public to observe one minute silence at 6.01 p.m. Queensland time on this National Day of Mourning to honour those impacted by the Bondi Beach terrorist attack. Speaker 1: I know that all councillors are in attendance, and that Councillor Wilson, who is attending online,
2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COUNTRY ¶
00:01:00 Mayor Wilkie: can you hear us, Councillor Wilson? Councillor Wilson: OK, thank you, everyone. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Wilson. We also welcome Director Richard MacGillivray, who's acting CEO and Larry Sengstock's captain. Welcome, you two. I'm for this confirmation of the minutes. Can I have a move and a seconder for the minutes of the ordinary meeting held on 18 December 2025? Happy to move. Councillor Morrison, thank you. Councillor Finzel, all in favour? Yes. Councillor Anderson, unanimous. I believe we have one petition for taping by Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Lorentson: I would like to submit this petition. Purpose of the petition is the undersigned have requested that Canoosa Council redesign the proposed new toilet structure near the big, big pelican to make it smaller, less obtrusive and maximise the existing grassed area.
3 ATTENDANCE & APOLOGIES ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
4 CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES ¶
00:02:00 I would like to present this to the CEO for his consideration and also response to the petitioner. Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: Just a question for staff, Chris. This toilet block is the one that's designed for all abilities for saving access? Correct. It's changing places. Right. All of it is this toilet block. Right. Thank you. All in favour? All in favour? Second. Councillor Wilson: Yes. Mayor Wilkie: That's it. Do we have a second? Second. Second, Councillor Phillips. My apologies. All in favour? That's unanimous. There are no presentations. Yes. We have some deputations. Two deputations. There's 15 members allocated for a deputation. First, our speakers, Willie Oswald, Jill Brownlee from Friends and Moose Botanic Gardens, and William Gill, would you like to come to the elector? Welcome.
00:03:00 Pat Spicer: Thank you. Speaker 3: Can everyone hear me? Okay. Thank you. Good morning, Chairman Wilkie, councillors, other ladies and gentlemen. Thanks for the opportunity for presenting this deputation from the Friends of Moose Botanic Gardens. Representing the Friends today are myself, the secretary, and I'm also one of the Friends of Moose Botanic Gardens. I'm also one of the Friends representatives on the stakeholder reference group for the Noosa Botanic Gardens master plan, and also Jill Brownlee, our long-standing president and also a life member of the Friends of Noosa. The Noosa Botanic Gardens was established over 35 years ago through the advocacy of a group of Lake MacDonald residents who had a vision and convinced the council at the time to turn what was a dumping ground and an eyesore into a botanic gardens. Not just a park. The collaboration and vision between council and residents 35 years ago ensured that we
7.1 Applicant: WILLY OSTWALD, FRIENDS OF NOOSA BOTANIC GARDENS Topic: MASTERPLAN FOR NOOSA BOTANIC GARDENS Speakers: WILLY OSTWALD, JILL BROWNLEE ¶
00:04:00 and future generations can enjoy this wonderful asset. How often have you heard of the botanic gardens being Moosa's hidden gem? The draft master plan is designed to guide the future of the botanic gardens over the next 25 years. The community feedback clearly endorses the revamped entrance zone and new access to the new arrivals area. The establishment of accessible pathways, including the garden promenade. The rejuvenated amphitheatre, including additional seating and shade to make the space more usable. And a new community shelter and information hub with kiosk and public amenities. These changes will allow more users to access the gardens and enjoy the 8 hectares of collections and gardens. The Friends have carefully considered the draft master plan and although we agree with many aspects, we believe there is a lack of focus on stewardship and development of the
00:05:00 plant collections. Without this, there is a real risk of turning Moosa Botanic Gardens into a beautiful park with plants, rather than a true botanic institution with purpose, scientific value and educational integrity for future generations to enjoy. Our primary concern is that the draft master plan has not addressed one of its key objectives. To be stewards of the botanical collection through respecting, enhancing, protecting and promoting the legacy of the existing and future collections. Currently the draft master plan is all about structural improvements to the gardens, with next to no planning for the actual gardens and future botanical collections. Which is the key reason why people visit a botanic gardens in the first place. International research data attests that a region's botanic garden is usually the first
00:06:00 or second destination for most tourists to an area. The Botanic Gardens of Australia and New Zealand, or Bagan's, is the organisation that most botanic gardens in Australia and New Zealand belong to, including Noosa Botanic Gardens. Bagan's believes that a modern botanic garden is the best place to be in Australia and New Zealand, and I quote, should set the direction and priorities of a botanic garden over the medium to long term and will have direct implications for the development of its living collections. Development and or implementation of a living collections plan should be a recommendation of any botanic gardens master plan. A living collection management plan for the gardens would include thematic planning and interpretation. Evaluation of the existing collections. Identification of gaps in the botanic gardens collections. A detailed management plan which covers criteria for assessing whether a plant is to be added
00:07:00 or removed from the gardens. Records management. Managing invasive species. Coping with climate change, et cetera. It would also provide a framework and plan for the future of the botanic gardens in respect to plantings and collections. Thereby assisting the botanical gardeners in the future. Thereby assisting in the detailed design stage of the master plan implementation. From the outset, the Friends have been advocating for, if not a curator, then at least a living collection management plan as part of the master plan for gardens. We requested that the brief to the consultant include this. At all the stakeholder reference group meetings, I raised our concerns regarding the plantings and collections. Our formal response to the draft master plan reiterated the importance of the plantings and collections management plan. The gardens has faced and is faced with several issues and challenges. All these bear out the importance of implementing a living collections management plan.
00:08:00 It's worth me touching on some examples of these issues in a bit more detail. Noosa Botanic Gardens has had five different garden supervisors over the last six years. All of whom have different ideas on the plantings in the garden. This has resulted in a lack of clarity in the thematics of the garden. Gardens being planted up and then pulled out 12 months later, plus a lack of forward planning. Existing plant collections have become fragmented over this time, diminishing the garden's educational, conservation and curatorial value. There has been little focus placed on record keeping of the plants, which is a key requirement for any botanical garden. In the absence of council action, the Friends have taken the initiative and have spent many man hours over the last two years identifying, classifying and mapping the existing plants
00:09:00 in the garden. This information was provided to the consultants preparing the master plan. Several rare and endangered trees that were mistaken by council staff for more common varieties have been removed from the gardens over the last few years. These trees have been donated to the gardens and represented a significant conservation asset for the community that has now been lost. In some areas of the garden the plantings are replicated, overgrown, dying or simply placed in the wrong spot. This has resulted in overcrowding and deep shaded areas in the garden, resulting in poor growth in understory species, as well as poor growth in the development of the existing trees. The Noosa Botanic Gardens doesn't have its own budget and there is no maintenance or development program in place. Recently the bridal walk structure was removed and it has rotted so badly over recent years. This area can no longer be used for weddings and we understand that there is no budget for
00:10:00 its replacement. A living collection management plan would assist in overcoming many of these issues and provide a detailed plan to assist in the future development of the garden. It would also assist in identifying the future funding required to maintain the gardens. The Friends want to collaborate with Council to achieve a living collection management plan using the toolkit provided by the GANs as the starting point. We strongly recommend that, as a minimum, the draft master plan be amended to include the immediate appointment of a project working group to develop a living collection management plan for the GANs. The project working group should include representatives from Council, the Friends, and external horticulturists with botanic gardens experience. We are ultimately asking Council to value the Noosa Botanic Gardens as a botanic gardens
00:11:00 and not just another park. Speaker 2: I thought it was probably worthwhile just for those who may be not as familiar with what the Friends are all about, just to give you a little bit of a rundown. The Friends have been involved with the Noosa Botanic Gardens since 2013 and we currently have over 160 members and we've steadily increased our presence in social media and the like. One of our key objectives is to assist in the maintenance and management of Noosa Botanic Gardens. Our MOU with Council focuses on the collaborative relationship between Council and the Friends. All our activities serve as a positive, interactive link between the GANs, the community and Council. I think some statistics are worth mentioning. Last year we clocked up over 2,000 volunteer hours assisting with the removal of fallen
00:12:00 palm fronds, of which there are many of them, weeding, pruning, planting and mulching. On average, once a month, we get up to 2,000 volunteers per year. We conduct either garden walks or botanic-themed workshops in the gardens. In 2025, our propagation team not only propagated plants for the gardens but raised just over $25,000 at our three plant sales. Now that the Master Plan offers a way forward, we expect to collaborate with Council as to how best to invest the funds raised last year and accumulated over the last five years. So not to blow our trumpets, but in our feedback submissions, we hope to be able to provide you with more information. As Willie has mentioned, we've pointed out on page three of the draft plan, which states, all proposed works around the existing collection will be a matter for detailed design. We'll include the survey of existing collections and key species. We'd like just to reiterate, the Friends have spent the last two years doing just that,
00:13:00 so that is already available and won't need to be done. Unlike the proposed structural improvements under the Master Plan, the implementation of the living space will be in the next two years. We hope that the living collection management policy within the draft Master Plan could be achieved in the short term, you know, in the next 12 months, at minimum cost, but will provide huge benefits in protecting and planning the future of Noosavitani Gardens. So as a major stakeholder in the gardens, we ask that Council support the Friends' request for a living collection management plan to be included as part of the Master Plan. Thank you. Thank you, Jill. Thank you, Willie. Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: Next up we have Pat Spicer talking on the topic of community consultation. Spicer, welcome back. Pat Spicer: Thank you. Mayor and Councillors, thank you for the opportunity to speak on community consultation.
7.2 Applicant: PAT SPICER Topic: community consultation Speakers: pat spicer ¶
00:14:00 Effective community consultation requires more than notification. It requires a provision of clear, accessible information and meaningful, respectful and engaging engagement before decisions are made, so that community input can genuinely inform outcomes. Transparency is fundamental to this process. It requires proactive information, sharing rather than relying on requests, meetings that are open and inclusive, and supporting documents that are readily available, timely and understandable to the residents. We hope that the Noosavitani Gardens project will be successful in the future. Council's current consultation approach relies mainly on its website, limited publicity, selected letter drops, pop-up events, one-on-one engagement with staff, Facebook posts, and Your Say surveys.
00:15:00 While this approach may be efficient and cost-effective for Council, it creates significant barriers for many residents. Reliance on this approach may be a challenge for many residents. On the website, assumes residents have the time, technical skills, and capacity to locate and interpret lengthy and technical documents. This excludes many people and discourages meaningful participation. Pop-up events, often held during business hours and in locations that do not support inclusive or detailed discussion. One-on-one engagement requires residents to engage with the community. We have a number of opportunities to be already informed. Without prior access to information, such conversations cannot be effective. Facebook is not universally used and should not be relied upon as a primary consultation tool.
00:16:00 Requiring QR code registration for meetings creates unnecessary access barriers, with simpler alternatives are available. Finally, Your Say surveys are widely perceived as instruments for creating sentiment, rather than genuine consultation. When surveys appear leading or outcome-driven, being structured to support predetermined outcomes, confidence in the process is undermined and participation declines. I now turn to the case of 62 Lakewood. Lakewood, Cooroy. Council advised residents in 2024 that a letter had been sent in July 2022. Most residents did not receive that letter. One resident who did receive it requested further information, but no additional information was provided.
00:17:00 Council's intentions for the site were embedded in the Noosa Housing Strategy 2022, Action 5511, with planning activity commencing as early as 2019. A letter drop occurred on 23 May 2024 to residents in Dianella Court and via Facebook. At the Council meeting in the community meeting in Cooroy on 15 May 2025, the Director of Strategy and Environment confirmed that residents in Kerry Street did not receive that letter. A broader letter drop on 5 August 2025 to more than 133 surrounding properties was an improvement. However, by May 2024, planning was already well advanced. A land purchase price had been agreed.
00:18:00 Grant funding secured. A memoranda of understanding signed. Planning had moved well beyond what could be reasonably described as preliminary or essential behind the scenes work. At that stage, meaningful community consultation should already have occurred. Following the May 2024 correspondence, residents requested meetings with Council. A steering committee was formed, with broader resident participation through an active email and messaging group. These meetings are described as community consultation on Council's Housing in Cooroy web page, which was created only after residents requested engagement. Information was not shared proactively. Attendance of meetings was restricted, particularly where presentations were involved.
00:19:00 Presentation materials were provided only to attendees and with instructions not to share them. This approach is inconsistent with principles of transparency, open meetings, publicly available information and genuine consultation. Small group engagement alone is inadequate, where decisions affect the wider community and set precedents for future development, particularly in hinterland towns such as Cooroy. I now refer to Council's resolution on 20 January 2025, which requires that the process for considering and investigating future uses of lots 2 and 3 at 64 Lake MacDowell Drive include community consultation.
00:20:00 That consultation is proposed to occur only after feasibility work at Neeser Heads and Tewantin. Residents are extremely concerned that civil works currently underway deliver infrastructure suitable for housing, effectively pre-empting future decision making, and limiting genuine consultation on alternate uses. To avoid misunderstanding, I would like to clearly articulate the community's expectations in relation to community consultation as follows. First, a public community forum, open to all residents, held in Cooroy, on the future uses of lots 2 and 3 at 64 Lake MacDowell Drive. Second, clear and accessible notification of that forum, including date, time, location and key issues,
00:21:00 using methods that do not rely solely on digital platforms. Third, open and transparent information sharing, including a clear explanation of the implications of receiving $178,000 from the Australian Government's Housing Support Program, and $4,099,040 from the Queensland Government's Residential Activation Fund in 2025, and how this funding affects future land use options. Four, assurance that community views will be genuinely heard, respected and reflected in outcomes, consistent with Council's resolutions and stated consultation processes. Finally, Cooroy seeks equitable treatment. Hinterland communities should not experience reduced transparency or consultation compared with coastal centres.
00:22:00 Thank you for your time. Thank you Pat. Mayor Wilkie: We have four submissions that cover the question time. The first application of two questions is from Ms Ria Den Brassen. Ms Den Brassen could be here today and she requested that Ms Pat Spicer read the questions, which will be answered by Chris Steele, Acting Director of Infrastructure Services. Ms Spicer, you already have elected. Thank you. Please read the questions please. Pat Spicer: Through the Chair. Ria's first question. Excuse me. Pat Spicer: What is the cost per tonne of material removed by truck from 6264 Lake Macdonald Drive? Mayor Wilkie: Thank you for your question Ms Miller. Council is unable to provide the cost for the tonne of material removed from Lake Macdonald Drive. It would be breaching the commercial rights of the contractor.
8.1 RHEA DEN BRAASEM ¶
00:23:00 This is sensitive information. Pat Spicer: Question two. How many tonnes of material have been removed by truck from 6264 Lake Macdonald Drive so far? Mayor Wilkie: Thank you again for your second question. The amount of tonnage so far approximately is 15,500 tonnes. Speaker 1: Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you Pat. The next application with two questions from Mr John Spencer. Spencer, welcome to the lectern. And question one will be answered by Acting CEO Richard MacGillivray. Question two will be answered by Acting Director of Court Services Mark Baxter. Thank you Chairman. Speaker 7: Thank you Chairman. My question has partly been raised by a previous speaker.
8.2 JOHN SPENCER ¶
00:24:00 The background to my question relates to the ways in which Noosa Council gathers information on community opinions. As is required by the relevant statutory acts. The background is that these consultation processes or surveys are often conducted, as we've heard, in-house using council staff. The results are often presented as a very brief summary with no detailed analysis or breakdown and only superficial mention of the methodology. This type of consultation, as we've heard, does not inspire community confidence. As there will always be a perception of bias towards pre-existing council plans. Adverse community reaction to the Noosa River Forefront Plan and now the new Destination Management Plan indicates that carrying out an in-house community consultation process is not always entirely satisfactory.
00:25:00 Determining public opinion on any subject is a skilled process and organisations exist which specialise in this. One such company claims it is used by 60% of local governments throughout Australia. Obtaining detailed information on public opinion in this way, as part of the planning process, would be cost effective as time and money spent on plans unacceptable to the community would not be compressed. My question therefore, very simply, is would it not improve the quality of public opinion and improve community confidence in the consultation process if council conducted surveys and opinion polls through an appropriately qualified independent third party? Speaker 6: Thank you very much Mr Spencer for your question. I appreciate it. Council has committed to meaningful engagement that is reflective of a broader community
00:26:00 and its practices are underpinned by the International Association of Public Participation by AP2. Globally recognised for its best practice approach to community engagement. Council also has a community engagement framework to provide the context on how to plan, design and implement the community engagement process for identified projects, strategies and decision making processes. Surveys are one part of the conversation with our community as we adopt an integrated approach to community engagement which is consistent with best practice. There are a range of options offered including face-to-face engagement, community engagement, and the opportunity to provide written submissions. Council staff make an operational decision to design, develop and test community engagement surveys in-house and these are developed by highly skilled engagement professionals. The cost to engage an independent third party to provide the service can be significant. Some of the complex or high-profile community engagement projects such as the Noosaville Poreshore Infrastructure Master Plan, Pomona Place Plan and the Housing Strategy, we have
00:27:00 partnered with specialist consultants to assist. with survey design and analysis of the data. In line with our community engagement framework, we endeavour to close the loop with the community by reporting back what we have heard and how it has influenced Council's decision making. We acknowledge that there has been some delays in providing reports for some of our recent engagement projects. We continually review and investigate methods to enhance our engagement and encourage members of the community to sign up and be part of our newly formed community engagement feedback panel for future projects. John, second question. Speaker 7: Second question. Speaker 1: The background to us is, which is far less important, Mr Chamber. Speaker 7: The background here is that the audio-visual system we have in this Chamber, which is used to make good tools available to the public for proceedings of Council, including public questions such as this, is manifestly not state-of-the-art.
00:28:00 Not only can the person asking the public question not be heard, it may have been brought to the public. But much of the proceedings of ordinary meetings can be hard to hear and the image quality is such that it can be hard to know who is speaking. Visually, the various charts and motions put on display during Council meetings can often not be seen clearly. So, my second question is, will the Council improve the quality of the audio-visual system used to make available to the public the proceedings of ordinary meetings and public questions? So, my second question is, will the Council improve the quality of the audio-visual system Speaker 4: Thank you Mr Spencer for your question about improving our sound system in the council chamber to ensure the public questions are heard as clearly as the responses. I have proposed an immediate and long return solution. The immediate is within the chamber today. For the immediate solution we can utilize our
00:29:00 portable PA system with two mobile microphones. This system is already used effectively during our remote council meetings throughout the region. By using this PA system we can amplify the questions so that the streaming audio picks them up clearly ensuring that the public question is heard with much more volume and clarity. But in the longer term we plan to investigate and understand costings to further permanent upgrades for the Mayor Wilkie: council chamber. Thank you very much. Thank you Mr Spencer. The third out of the two questions is from Mr Brian O'Connor. Mr O'Connor, welcome to the lectern. The first question will be answered by Acting Director of Community Services, Paul Brinkman on behalf of Kerri Contini and the second question will be responded to by Margaret Gatt on behalf of Tim Williams. Speaker 1: Thank you councillors. Pomona remains the only town in Noosa Shire without a flagpole at its war memorial. In its responses
8.3 BRIAN O'CONNOR ¶
00:30:00 outlining progress on the Pomona Place Plan initiatives, the council states that the placement of a flagpole at Pomona War Memorial is under consideration. An action that has been underway on and off since before the memorial was refurbished and rededicated in 2018. The question is this. This matter having been under investigation for the past seven years, what are the considerations around a flagpole at this location? And has that consideration resulted in any outcomes such that the Pomona community can look forward to permission being granted for a flagpole to be located at the Memorial Rotunda in Joe Basso Park? Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Mr. O'Connor. Mr. Brinkman.
00:31:00 Speaker 5: Thank you, Mr. O'Connor, for your question and your continued interest in the Pomona Place Plan initiatives. Council acknowledges your long-standing interest in the proposal for a permanent flagpole near the Pomona Rotunda War Memorial in Joe Basso Park. Over several years, Council officers have carefully evaluated various factors, including the park's limited space, high community use, safety concerns related to children and pedestrian movement, and maintenance implications such as mowing access and obstruction risks. A permanent flagpole in the open park was not supported. These considerations were outlined in previous correspondence to you. The idea of installing a flagpole was included for consideration in the Pomona Place Plan and will be further assessed by Council to see if it could be accommodated in an existing garden bed. This proposal still needs more research and hasn't yet become a funded project. The evaluation process will continue as resources, staff capacity, and overall organisational priorities permit.
00:32:00 In the interim, Council advises that temporary flagpoles can be effectively utilised for commemorative events, offering flexibility without permanently impacting the park's functions. Additionally, the permanent flagpole located outside the Pomona fire station across the road is also available for use. Speaker 1: My second question is this. If it takes seven years to consider something as relatively simple as the placement of a flagpole in a park, beside a war memorial at Pomona, what prospect is there that Nursery Council will complete all 52 actions in the Pomona Place Plan within a 10-year time frame, some of these actions being complex, in need of detailed planning, and requiring close contact with the local authorities?
00:33:00 Mayor Wilkie: Thank you Mr O'Connor. Acting Director Margaret Gatt. Speaker 4: Thank you Mr O'Connor for your question. I'm responding on behalf of direct strategy environment Kim Rawls. The Pomona place plan has actions with specific time frames for commencement to ensure implementation of the plan can be staged in a sustainable long-term approach. A draft short-term implementation plan has been prepared showing good progress against many actions in the place plan. This will be continually monitored over time with medium and long-term projects being considered over the appropriate time frames as part of the council budget process to ensure adequate funding. Thank you. Thank you Mr O'Connor. Mayor Wilkie: The last application for two questions is again from Mrs Pat Spicer. Mrs Spicer your two questions will be answered by Acting Director Margaret Gatt on behalf of director of strategy environment Kim Rawls.
00:34:00 Pat Spicer: Through the Chair. Background information. The Queensland Board of Office Local Government 2024 report report 13-2024-25 available on the website. The press release in October 2025 stating council had been directed not to release information about the fraud so as not to jeopardise ongoing investigations. The report at the December ordinary meeting outlined the rather comprehensive measures that have been put in place in retrospect. But were staff aware of this possible fraud target area prior to the event? So my question is while there were restrictions on releasing information to the public regarding the loss of 2.4 million through fraud in December 2020, were all the staff in the financial department fully briefed on the contents of the Queensland
8.4 PAT SPICER ¶
00:35:00 Audit Office report immediately after the report was received as it explicitly warned about the fraud risk in super master file data changes and provided a case study of a recent council loss through such data changes being made to supplier bank account details? Very good. Speaker 4: Thank you Ms Spicer for your question. I'd like to confirm that whilst the initial loss was 2.3 million dollars through recovery by the bank and our insurers the current figure is 1.7 million. This is still a substantial amount and council does not take this lightly. We have been making a range of changes and additions to prevent this from happening again. Council was notified by the QAO in March 2024. At the fraud event that targeted the City of Gold Coast before the calculated attack on Noosa Council.
00:36:00 As also documented in our previous reports to the Audit and Risk Committee and to Council, the recommendations from the 2025 QAO Noosa Shire Council Interim Audit Report have been implemented or substantially progressed. Council has met all its reporting obligations. Council have conducted regular mandatory cyber fraud training to better equip, our staff for such activities. Council has strengthened processes for updating, maintaining and securing the Vendor Credit Master File including the development of the Vendor Maintenance Policy. Council is in the process of establishing an independent risk-based financial accountability program to review and audit the accuracy and proper use of financial information. Council has substantially progressed the implementation of third-party payment protection software to validate the analysis of the financial information and processing of the financial information. Thank you.
00:37:00 Pat Spicer: Next question, Mrs Spicer. Through the Chair, I don't feel that answers the question, because it doesn't say when the staff were informed back in March. And that was my question. The report that Mark Gafferstone has been exemplary, and I admire the way she's undertaken that. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Order by answer. Pat Spicer: Whatever order I know. Right. Thank you. Thank you. I have no right to comment. Background information. Housing strategy. The housing crisis requires action by all levels of government. Council has acted in this area by amending the Noosa plan to allow greater diversity in housing, making it easier for housing to be built on land owned by churches, et cetera, allowing residents to build granny flats or smaller houses on their existing residential lot. And providing incentives for developers to build affordable housing.
00:38:00 Councils were originally set up for four essential services to the community. Roads, water, waste collection and waste water. Responsibility of local government today are quite extensive including infrastructure, local roads, footpaths, stormwater, drains and bridges, waste management, public health, overseeing public health services including food inspection, and managing public pools and other facilities, animal control, registration, parking, planning and development, land use and zoning, building approval, signage and advertising, community services and facilities, parks and recreation, libraries and community centres, arts and culture, aged and childcare, safety and environment, fire prevention, emergency management, environmental management, government and representation, representation to other levels of government, local laws, strategic planning.
00:39:00 While this list is not exhaustive, it serves to indicate that council has a large area of responsibility. The why question is one I get asked regularly and can't answer the question, so I'm asking. Why is Noosa Council taking on the state responsibility? Noosa Council has the responsibility of providing housing by spending millions above grants to remediate and install all infrastructure for housing at 64 Lake McDonnell Drive, Cooroy as well as entering into a contract with Coaster Bay to build 26 units when it is in fact that the site does not meet the housing strategy actions of ready access to services, transport and proximity to work. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you Mrs. Slicen. Thank you. Speaker 4: Thank you, Mr. Spicer, for your second question, responding on behalf of Director Strategy Planning and Environment, Kim Rawlings.
00:40:00 The housing crisis currently gripping Australia is one that neither the state or federal governments are going to be able to solve alone in a short time. Rather than sitting back and expecting the problem to be solved by other levels of government, Noosa Council, along with many other local governments, has chosen to be part of the solution. Despite the belief that this is not a local government responsibility, local governments have a responsibility to ensure that their communities are places where people want to live and families can thrive with amenities and services critical to people's livelihoods. Local governments are specifically required to plan for the needs of their community under the Local Government Act. This could legitimately include land use and development outcomes to support housing. Many councils across Australia are concerned about the needs of their communities. They are increasingly exploring how they can support affordable housing in response to local needs, including Sunshine Coast and Moreton Bay, amongst others.
00:41:00 Councils also have a critical role in enabling housing outcomes through planning, servicing and often land. Noosa Council's 2018 Social Justice Charter commits Council to implementing policies and providing services that decrease inequality to doing what it can to ensure Noosa is a diverse country. Noosa Council has been working to improve the quality of life for people in the community where there are affordable places for people to live. At the 2021 Census, there were 2,461 low-to-median income noosav Shire households in housing stress. Since then, the situation has only worsened. To illustrate, the median weekly rent for Cooroy has increased from $500 a week at the time of the 2021 Census to $800 in the September 25 quarter. This is a 60 per cent increase in four years. In endorsing the 2022 housing strategy, Noosa Council committed to encouraging greater public
00:42:00 and private investment in more social and affordable housing in the Shire, and partnering with the registered community housing providers and others with the aim of providing more social and affordable housing. This included investigating council-owned land which might be put to the use of the purpose of housing locals. The land at Lake MacDonald Drive was just one subject. The land at Lake MacDonald Drive was just one subject. Shareeting Registration Centre was just one site. Subject to feasibility investigations with others being in the centres at Noosa Junction and at Tewantin. These actions are specifically listed in the housing strategy and meet the housing strategy actions. A guide for local governments in delivery of affordable housing produced by the ALGA Housing, Australia and Australian Community Housing, has recently showcased Noosa Council's efforts. fade to for 23 minutes, as we look into the Radian schedule. Thank you for your land-based contribution to social housing delivery. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you.
00:43:00 Thank you Mrs Spicer for your finance and advocacy. Ladies and gentlemen we now take a ten minute adjournment. Thank you.
01:00:00 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Let me just just close the espe consortium down for a second. Councillor Lorentson: Not the staff that But council rights to the state. So delete the Minister for the Environment and Tourism. It's actually the Minister for Primary Industries, Tony Parrott. Point of order. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Question was what's on the board now, what was submitted, or was the original submitted? Because there can't be an amendment. I've been notified of a motion to submit it.
10.1 THREE-MONTH TRIAL OF ALTERNATE SHARK MITIGATION MEASURES DURING SOUTHERN WHALE MIGRATION ¶
01:01:00 Councillor Lorentson: That's not the... That's actually not the response that was given to me by the CEO when I actually noted the mistake a few days ago. Mayor Wilkie: We'll just get some advice on whether another motion can be changed by a mover. Councillor Lorentson: So the advice, and I can pull out the advice from the CEO, because I attempted to make the change about a week ago and was told just to change it on the floor. So I'm happy to... Mayor Wilkie: Look, hold on, I'll make a call. But please change this. It's a minor change, so let's... Councillor Lorentson: It is. That's been authorised by the Chief Executive Officer of the Minister's Council. Appreciate it. Thank you, Mayor. But council right to the state requesting that during the 2026 whale migration period, the Queensland Government consider a three-month trial
01:02:00 of replacing traditional shark nets with smart drumlines, or other contemporary non-lethal mitigation technologies that allow for the safe passage of migrating whales with Noosa Main Beach proposed as the trial location. This trial should apply specifically to the southern migration period where whales, including vulnerable calves, are travelling south and where the majority of entanglements are known to occur. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. May we have a seconder for that, please? Happy to second. Thank you, Councillor Phillips. Councillor Isner. Councillor Lorentson: This is one of the most significant natural events for our region. It is central to our identity, our visitor economy, and our community's deep connection to the ocean. As a UNESCO Biosphere Reserve, we also carry an internationally recognised responsibility to lead in environmental stewardship and to champion approaches that protect both people and nature.
01:03:00 This motion reflects that responsibility. Every year, traditional shark nets pose a known and preventable entanglement risk to whales, especially during the southern migration, when mothers and calves travel closest to shore, and when the majority of entanglements occur. These incidents are distressing for the animals and traumatic for the community members, volunteers and responders who witness or participate in rescue efforts. They also create a paradoxical safety issue. A distressed whale can attract sharks, potentially increasing risk to beachgoers, rather than reducing it. Nets do not create a barrier. They do not stop sharks from entering swimming areas. And when a whale is caught in a net, the thrashing, the blood and distress signals, can draw sharks closer to the shore. Human life is our highest priority, and recent events in New South Wales have reminded us why this conversation matters now more than ever.
01:04:00 In the past week alone, New South Wales has recorded multiple shark attacks, a stark reminder that outdated technologies are not keeping pace with modern coastal risk. We owe it to our community, and to the people of New South Wales, that we are here today. We need to ensure that the tools used to protect them are the most effective available. Modern technologies, such as smart drumlines, are more targeted, enable rapid response and significantly reduce bycatch, while still focusing on the three shark species most associated with serious incidents. They are contemporary, evidence-based tools used increasingly across Australia, because they provide better protection for beachgoers than passive nets. The Cardinal Report, formally titled Queensland Shark Control Program, Review of Alternative Approaches, and commissioned by the Queensland Government in 2019, reinforces this.
01:05:00 It remains the most comprehensive, independent, scientific assessment of shark control equipment used in Queensland. Importantly for Noosa, the report found that replacing the two shark nets at Noosa with additional drumlines, quote, could potentially make a difference in the quality of life for sharks. In other words, equal or better safety outcomes for people, with dramatically less harm to marine life. Council has already shown leadership on the issue. Last year, the Local Government Association of Queensland endorsed the investigation of alternative updated shark mitigation technologies, with overwhelming support from 77 councils across the state. This motion reflects that evolving position, and aligns with best practices, is critical. And also with our obligations as a biosphere reserve to model innovative, sustainable solutions.
01:06:00 When I first brought the LGAQ motion to this council, I faced resistance, but I stood my ground because I knew how important it was to our community. That motion went on to receive overwhelming statewide support and I'm taking that same principled approach today. I've not withdrawn this motion out of fear that it may somehow jeopardise our relationship with the state on other advocacy matters, because it won't. Respectful, clear and constructive advocacy strengthens relationships. It doesn't damage them. That is precisely why I've prepared and will now table a sample letter with this motion to show fellow councillors exactly how we should deal with this. I intend to approach the minister respectfully, constructively and with a refined, simple request.
01:07:00 It makes clear, if you read the letter, that this is collaboration, not confrontation. You may hear after I sit that we shouldn't raise this again because the minister has previously declined a full-season trial, but this is not the same request. It is materially different in scope. Different in timing and different in intent. We're not asking for a six-month removal of nets. We're not asking for a full-migration-season trial. We're asking for a short, targeted, three-month, southern-migration trial and some community members... Councillor Lyons from the council is here. Happy for Councillor Lyons to continue. Councillor Phillips: Yeah, that's fine. Councillor Lorentson: Yeah. Thank you. So, I want to note that some community members who originally did not support the earlier proposal have already indicated that they're open to this more refined approach.
01:08:00 Some have even suggested even a two-month window that we should be throwing to the state. That is what finding middle ground looks like and this approach has never been put forward to the minister. Advocacy is not about asking once or twice and walking away. It's about listening, refining and evolving our position. And that is exactly what this motion does. Relationships with the states are not damaged by respectful dialogue. They are built through it. Strong relationships are formed when councils show they are willing to adjust, to collaborate and to keep the conversation open, not when they fall silent on issues that matter deeply to their communities. There's a quote that I love using, if we do nothing, nothing changes. And in five months, the whales are going to begin their migration. If there is an entanglement and history tells us there likely will be, I want to know that we as a council did everything we could to prevent it.
01:09:00 This motion is not about conflict, it's about responsibility. It's about protecting human life. It's about protecting marine life and protecting the mothers and calves that passed our coastline every year. It's about standing up for those without a voice. It's about living up to our role. As a UNESCO biosphere, where innovation, environmental protection and community wellbeing must go hand in hand. The worst case scenario is that the minister is going to say no, but what if he says yes? The risk of momentarily upsetting a minister can never, never outweigh the risk of another whale or calf becoming entangled off our shores. One is political discomfort. The other is irreversible harm. This is a reasonable, respectful, evidence-based request.
01:10:00 It reflects community expectations. It aligns with emerging best practice and demonstrates leadership. And it also aligns with both the State and Noosa Council's priority of protecting human life. Again, Councillors, if we do nothing, nothing changes. Thank you. I hope you support the motion in front of us. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Lorentson. I'd like to move an amendment. I'll just read this. It says that we note the attached correspondence, which is four pieces of correspondence, to and from the State Governor and Noosa Council's request to trial the removal of shark nets during the year 2020. The motion is to include the removal of shark nets during whale migration season in conjunction with deployment of non-lethal mitigation methods, including smart drumlines and aerial drone surveillance, and b formulate a range of advocacy strategies, not limited to litter writing,
01:11:00 to achieve the objective of a trial for shark net removal during whale migration season. These strategies are to include advocacy for a three-month trial during the southern migration period when whales, including vulnerable calves, are travelling south when the majority of the native contaminants are known to occur. May I have a seconder, please? Councillor Lorentson: Point of order, please. Through the Chair. Point of order. Chair, I raise a point of order understanding Orders 29. My original motion is narrow, precise, and entirely self-contained. It directs Council to take one action only, to write to the Minister with a refined request for a three-month southern migration trial at Noosa, Main Beach. The intent is clear. The scope is limited, and the operational impact is minimal. The amendment before us does not simply adjust or refine that motion. It fundamentally alters its character.
01:12:00 It introduces a broad advocacy program, requires staff to develop multiple strategies, and shifts the focus from a single, targeted request to a much wider campaign for shark net removal across the entire whale migration season. This is not an amendment. This is an amendment that retains the identity of the original motion, as required by Standard Orders 29.1. It is a new motion in substance, scope, and effect. Standing Orders 29.1 are explicit. An amendment must be in terms that retain the identity of the original motion and must not directly negate it. The identity of my motion is in its simplicity. A single letter requesting a specific three-month southern migration trial. The amendment replaces that simplicity with an entirely different proposition, a multi-layered advocacy strategy that goes well beyond what was contemplated. It does not retain the identity of the motion.
01:13:00 It transforms it. Furthermore, Standing Orders are designed to prevent amendments from being used to introduce new subject matter or impose new operational burdens to staff. Yet that is exactly what this amendment does. My motion requires one letter. The amendment requires strategy development, ongoing advocacy work, and potentially public-facing campaigning. These are new obligations, not refinements. They were never part of the original motion. And they will never be. And cannot be inserted through an amendment without breaching the intent of Standing Orders 29.1. It is also important to note that Standing Orders exist to protect the integrity of decision-making processes. They ensure that Councillors know exactly what they are voting on, and that motions cannot be reshaped mid-debate into something materially different from what was originally put forward. Allowing this amendment would undermine that principle. Councillors would be voting on a motion that no longer resembles the original motion. The one I gave notice of. And that is precisely what Standing Order 29.1 is designed to prevent.
01:14:00 Finally, the amendment alters the purpose of the motion. My motion seeks to reopen a conversation with the Minister through a refined, reasonable request that has never been put to the State. The amendment pre-empts that process by escalating the matter into a broader advocacy campaign before we even have made the refined request. That is a substantial request. The motion is intended to shift in the intent and Standing Orders do not permit amendments that change the purpose of a motion. For all those reasons Chair, the amendment does not comply with Standing Orders 29.1. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you for that, Councillor Lorentson. The intention of the amendment is that it does not negate the intent of your motion. It is intended to improve the chances of success for the idea at a State level. Formulated by the Royal Commission on the Right to Have a Decision on the Amendment to the We have a discussion and a council discussion forum or council only forum where we can talk about ideas such as advocacy to the state, face to face delegations, so on and so forth. It is not an expensive exercise. It's about to increase the chances of success for this idea of a three month trial.
01:15:00 So my ruling is it does not negate the intention of the original motion and that it be allowed. Councillor Lorentson: I'd like to move a motion that the ruling of the Chair be dissented from and I also would like to move that Chair, given that you are the mover of the amendment, I respectfully submit that it would be inappropriate for you to rule on a procedural matter relating to your own amendment. I therefore request that the deadline for the amendment be 10 days. Mayor Wilkie: As chair as the mover of the amendment, I'm entitled to speak in favour of it. I believe
01:16:00 I have made the right call. Let democratic processes take their course. Allow the amendment. If councillors have any concerns about it's nature, or the course of action it's proposing, it can be voted down. That's the reason why I'm saying that I want to come forward. Councillor Lorentson: And through the chair, can I ask the CEO, my understanding with standing orders is that when I move a motion that the ruling of the chair be dissented from, does that not trigger a vote of the councillors? Speaker 6: It does. Councillor Lorentson: It does? It does, yeah. So why is that step? Mayor Wilkie: It needs to be put to the councillors now whether. Councillor Lorentson: Thank you, but that was not offered. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. It is part of the process, but it's part of the process. The chair has a right to argue the reasons why he or she has made that decision.
01:17:00 Speaker 6: So you can go to the vote. Mayor Wilkie: Go to the vote? Speaker 6: Around. Mayor Wilkie: Whether the chairmen's ruling be dissented from, but the chairman has a right to vote on that. Speaker 6: Correct, correct, yes. So, Karen. The answer is we're basically voting around, and the standing order is clause 29-1, around whether or not that the amendment to the motion shall be in terms that's retained the identity of the original motion, in terms of what Mayor Wilkie has put forward, whether that retains the identity of the original motion and does not directly negate the motion itself. Mayor Wilkie: We're actually voting on a motion, we're actually voting on a motion that the chairman's ruling be dissented from. Yes. Yeah. Okay.
01:18:00 Thank you. Question? Councillor Phillips: If the amendment was from someone other than the Chair, I've just got to get my head around if I haven't had this before. The amendment's from the Chair, so if it wasn't from the Chair, how, does that differ from how this process would work currently? Mayor Wilkie: I'll just say, we're not voting on the amendment at the moment. No. We're voting on whether the ruling of the Chair, that the amendment be allowed to be debated and put to the vote by the Councillors, be dissented from. Councillor Phillips: No, that bit I'm aware of, sorry. My question is, how would it differ if it was, say, Karen's amendment, the Chair votes whether the... Yeah. How does it work if it's the Chair? Because that doesn't really feel like it's... Speaker 6: Yeah. So just from a procedural point of view, so we do, we've just got some clarification,
01:19:00 we do need a seconder around the dissension motion that's being put forward. So we need another Councillor to second that request, whether there's the dissension under clause 31. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: And can I ask the question, under 31.7, which is the dissent from the Chairman's ruling, are there any provisions that suggest the way it's handled, varies depending on the role of the Chair person in the matter being dissented from. I can't see anything in there from A to F that would suggest that. Mayor Wilkie: Councillor Fletcher.
01:20:00 Councillor Finzel: In terms of process around the stamp orders, how would this work if we go to the vote before we've even debated the first motion? Councillor Lorentson: This is just an amendment. This is just the amendment. So then it goes back to the original motion and we debate that. Councillor Finzel: And then you would have opportunity if you want to raise that again further down the track. Mayor Wilkie: So the process is a motion can be moved and then once the motion is moved, seconded and the mover has spoken to it, an amendment can be moved which is what's been done. It hasn't been seconded yet. Councillor Lorentson has challenged the right of this Councillor to move an amendment. And when I've ruled that the amendment be allowed to be put to debate and vote, Councillor Lorentson has moved that the Chairman's ruling that the amendment be allowed be dissented from.
01:21:00 So if this procedural motion is carried, I could not, we could not accept the amendment as part of the debate. Speaker 6: And in addition, so as mentioned, so the motion for rule of dissension needs to be seconded before you can proceed to the vote. So there needs to be a Council to second whether that request for dissension before it goes to the vote. Mayor Wilkie: Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: A question through the Chair to the Acting CEO. If no one seconds this, does this just fall? Councillor Lorentson: The dissent does, but the amendment stays. Councillor Finzel: Yes, to clarify, does the dissent fall for no seconder? Speaker 6: If there's no seconder, it does. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. Okay, seconded by Councillor Wilson.
01:22:00 So we put it to the vote. Councillor Phillips: I still have a question. I still need to understand, because how the Chair can rule on something that's to do with their own motion. So I need to understand if it was someone else that moved an amendment, I understand that then the Chair's, but how do you vote on something that you put forward? To me that, I just need clarification. If it was someone else that made the amendment, I understand that the Chair could step up. That's the right, that makes sense to me. I don't, when's the process when the Chair moves the amendment? Mayor Wilkie: Yes, I can say that, as Councillor Stockwell said, there's nothing in the Standing Orders that rules the Chairman out. Okay. Of ruling on something, an amendment that he's moved. Councillor Lorentson: Okay.
01:23:00 Can I ask a question to the CEO through the Chair? In terms of the Standing Order, the Standing Order is 29.1. Can you, other than read what it says, explain to us what it means? Speaker 6: So this is going back to the basis for your calling of dissent? The dissension, absolutely. Councillor? Councillor Lorentson: Yeah. Speaker 6: Look, I'm happy to provide comments. Obviously Clause 29.1. is basically the amendment to the motion should be in terms which retains the identity of the original motion, and does not directly negate the motion. So, whilst the procedural motion that's put before Council is essentially what is being sought, is whether or not the position from the Chair is agreed upon or not.
01:24:00 So, in order for this to progress, given we have a seconder, my advice would be for the Councillors to make the decision on whether that amendment should be allowed based on the outcome from the dissension ruling itself. So, my advice would be is to let the Councillors make the vote in relation to this to allow whether the amendment be retained or not. Okay. Councillor Lorentson: Thank you. Another question through the Chair. So, if it's found that it is outside Section 29.1 in terms that the amendment has actually introduced new subject matter or extends the scope of the motion, does that stop the Mayor from adding maybe still an amendment to the motion?
01:25:00 That possibly modifies what's being put in front of us now. Speaker 6: Through the Chair. Look, if you're asking for my specific opinion. Councillor Lorentson: No, it's not an opinion. CEO, I don't want your opinion. I just want to understand and give clarity to the Councillors here that if the decision has gone outside the scope and the intent of the original motion, that doesn't stop the Mayor to still proceed with another amendment that doesn't impede on the scope or intent of the motion. That it's, at the moment, it's very broad. My motion is very, very targeted and specific. Mayor Wilkie: Point of order. Just another question. The issue that you read out there is does the amendment, does the amendment negate the original motion? And the answer is no. And that's, yeah, that's, yeah, that's, yeah, that's the key issue.
01:26:00 Speaker 6: Yeah, just to answer the original question, you are correct, Councillor, that at any stage later the Mayor or other Councillors can make further amendments. In response to Mayor Wilkie's comments, absolutely, in terms of the voting for Councillors, it's in relation to essentially around the amendment put forward and the dissension that's proposed is around whether or not that amendment is in line with Clause 29 of the Standing Rules. Councillor Phillips: Question. Do we get to speak about a procedural motion? No. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So we just... I can answer that. Only the Mayor and the mover of the motion. That's correct. Councillor Lorentson: I'm exercising my rights to speak. Because I'm the author of the notified motion, I can speak. I can speak very clearly and explicitly about the intent.
01:27:00 Mayor Wilkie: Excuse me, Councillor Lorentson, you have already spoken and given your response. Speaker 6: And happy to clarify, so only the mover of the procedural motion and the Chairperson may speak to the procedural motion in that order. So, therefore, Councillor Lorentson, and then the final response from the Chair. No other Councillors may speak to the procedural motion. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So, can I just confirm that the motion is in line with Clause 29 of the Standing Rules? A vote in favour on this one is a vote that you think that the amendment doesn't retain the identity and or directly negate. A vote against means you think the amendment is acceptable. Is that correct? So a vote for the motion of the second chairman of ruling is that you believe that the amendment does not retain the identity and or negates the original motion. A vote against means you are happy that what is proposed is an amendment to the motion.
01:28:00 Councillor Phillips: So it's opposite to what you think it is. It is. It is. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Councillor Phillips: Okay. Mayor Wilkie: So a vote against allows the amendment. Councillor Lorentson: And a vote for allows the original notified motion to proceed. Mayor Wilkie: Those who agree that the Chairman's ruling be dissented from, raise your hands. Those who believe, that's Councillor Lorentson, Phillips and Wilson. And Finzel, those who believe the Chairman's ruling not be dissented from, that's Councillor Wegener, Stockwell and Wilkie. So the amendment is, that's carried. That means the amendment is not allowed. Speaker 6: Back to the original motion.
01:29:00 Councillor Wilson: So can I just clarify that for the procedural motion? Speaker 2: That's Councillor Wegener, Phillips and Wilson, and against for picking up on Stockwell and Wilkie. Mayor Wilkie: Yeah, yes. Okay, anyone else wish to speak to the original motion? Notice of motion. Councillor Phillips: I will. When I first put my hand up to run for Council, I remember meeting some community members that had spoken passionately about this because it's been quite topical. And I think for years swimming in the ocean, I hadn't really thought too much about it. But there's definitely many of our community that are asking Council to
01:30:00 step into this space. From my perspective, I've always had these kind of almost contrary groups of people who approach me, you know. Fishermen saying that they can't even catch a fish without the shark taking it first. And then we've got, you know, absolute horrific scenes of whale calves being caught off our beautiful beaches. So that's definitely not something we want either. But the one thing that stuck in my mind, because I hadn't met Councillor Lorentson at that stage when I ran for, when I was getting to know some of the community groups. And they'd said how passionately she'd been involved in the shark net. So I thought when I get to it, I'll probably reach out and see where you're at with how much work has been done. So I think for me, I've probably, this is years ago now, and knowing that this is a space that you've sat in, I think most people would know that you're out in the water more than definitely at the moment. So
01:31:00 first of all, then part of that, speaking to that is just that I want to fully acknowledge that you have been in this space for a long time. And I like your tenacity of not letting something go. I don't really want to get involved in like a political debate over how this all works. That's why today disappoints me because I just want to, like the work that you did, I just want to see it probably, it's simple, it's clear. And I can't bang on on other days about clear communication and then go against it here. So I guess, even though I sort of understood the amendments, for me, it's just making a real, like what happens next after today, it's pretty clear for me in this notified motion. So that's why I'm going to support it. I guess there's a lot of other opportunities for throughout council only discussions to bring up other ways, maybe the
01:32:00 council can move forward in other advocacy spaces. I know that's how I've had to bring through my e-bikes and things like that before the so there is other processes that we can do that without being, I guess, awkward for all of us sitting here around what we want to achieve today. So yeah, I'm very supportive of the the proposal to ask the state whether that temporary three-month migration period is considered. Yeah, thanks. Mayor Wilkie: I'd like to try another amendment then, following on from the advice. Please bring up the original amendment and I'll have changes to the wording. Okay. I would like it... A list, discuss. In part B, change the words to councillors discuss.
01:33:00 Discuss. A range of advocacy methods. So get rid of formula. Formulate a range of advocacy strategies. Comma, not limited to letter writing. Yeah, and the rest is as is. So the part B has been changed to cancelling. Cancelling is discuss a range of advocacy methods, not limited to letter writing, to achieve the objective of a trial for sharp net removal during a wild migration season.
01:34:00 Don't need the next sentence. Yeah. These methods instead of strategies. Mm-hmm. I'm sorry. Mayor Wilkie: I'm sorry. I'll just leave, yeah. Just say these are to include, leave it as is. These are to include advocacy for a three-month trial during a sudden migration period in the wilds, including involving cars that travel south from the majority of the attack points in the area of dirt. May I have a second effort to test this amendment, please? Thank you, councillor Wegener. Councillors, the idea is good. The context is important. Thank you, councillor Wegener. That's why I've attached the correspondence to and from the state government about our request to have sharp nets removed during wild migration season.
01:35:00 On every occasion we've written in a respectful, clear, and collaborative way. The state government has made it clear it will not be removing the sharp nets for any amount of time during the winter season or at all. One letter carried the full endorsement of 77 Queensland councillors as a result of an LGAQ meeting. The state government again indicated its reasons for not removing nets for any amount of time. There is a very well-known wise saying that advice is against doing the same thing over and over and getting a different result. In this case, continuing to write on essentially the same topic and the same method risks weakening the relationship between the two. The weight given to Noosa Council's advocacy on state issues.
01:36:00 I think we should continue to advocate on this. It's too important. But it's important that advocacy be effective. It will take some time. If we're genuine about successfully achieving the goal of net removal, we must think more carefully about the range of advocacy methods. This is why the amendment proposes we discuss a more strategic approach. This is why the amendment proposes we discuss a more strategic approach. This amendment offers that we have a chat in the Council discussion forum about methods that are more strategic than relying on the ad hoc practice of having a notice of motion every time we have a new idea. We need to have a process that is seamless, can result in council conversation, and it can just happen.
01:37:00 This involves consideration of use. This involves consideration of use. We can talk about use of delegation. We can talk about use of delegation. Working with the community, face to face meetings. Careful consideration of the timing of the advocacy as well. Careful consideration of the timing of the advocacy as well. For instance, to coincide with the lead up to the next state election when policy positions are known to shift. For instance, to coincide with the lead up to the next state election when policy positions are known to shift. We and many groups in the community are seeking to achieve, and this does not negate our letter being a part of that, but I'm suggesting we have a chat about other things, ways we can achieve the same end, including ways of delivering the message about the two-month trial. For example, with Councillor Nance, face-to-face meetings with ministers, there's an opportunity coming up in a couple of weeks where that can occur.
01:38:00 I'm just saying we don't give up, but we don't keep doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result. And publicly signifying this with a notified motion, it's likely to make the Minister give in deeper. But, respectfully... Communication has been the hallmark of all communication to date, and we all just need to be a bit more strategic, and I'm sure just in the Council discussion forum, we can do that. And that's all this is asking of you, but we need to think a bit harder. I haven't finished my point yet. Councillor Lorentson: Point of order. I can't sit and listen to this. Excuse me, Councillor, what's your point of order? My point of order is that we are actually re-prosecuting an amendment that we... that has just been voted against, changing three words does not change, and this is the part where I have requested, through the Chair, whether we could actually just seek...
01:39:00 Mayor Wilkie: Sorry, Councillor, we've already had that discussion, and Councillors will vote according to their conscience on this. That's not a reason to stop debate on an amendment that's been moved and seconded, and debate is underway. Councillor Lorentson: So, I'm going to ask you, through the Chair, to the CEO, why are we debating the same amendment? Mayor Wilkie: Excuse me, I can answer that question. It is substantially different because it does not involve staff time, a complex array of strategies. It's a Council discussion forum I propose. Councillor, I'm going to finish my speech uninterrupted, please. I'm drawing to a close anyway. Thank you. Thank you.
01:40:00 So councillors, this does not make up the original motion, it's, we all want the same things, it gives us an opportunity, and I've said enough, thank you. Councillor Wilson you have your hand up. Councillor Wilson: Thank you, I'm a little bit uncomfortable talking about this topic today and I just want to acknowledge Nico and his family in New South Wales for the last few days. But, just on a kind of admin kind of comment, the amendment should say, pardon me, that it should be from that council. So that council, councillors discuss a range of advocacy methods, so grammatically it doesn't make sense for a staff,
01:41:00 but also if councillors discuss a range of advocacy methods there's no action from that, there's no way we can actually measure whether that's happened. So I'm just not at all with this wording. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you Councillor Wilson. And now councillors wish to speak to the amendment. Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: Yes, thank you Mr Chair for the opportunity to speak. We talk a lot about, you know, advocacy and we sat here this morning, we've heard community come in and present to council very good points around community engagement and how we can improve that. On the attachment with the reading on this agenda item, we've got the, I'll just check what the meeting is called because I didn't attend the meeting, I didn't know the meeting was on, and I'm only close to members. The meeting minutes for Oceans for All, the trial of replacing shark nets during whale migration season dated 26-09-25.
01:42:00 Sandy Bolt was in attendance and there's quite a number of people present, I won't go through that list, it's quite extensive and people are able to see that online. I do note that the, I can't find which one it is, the Noosa World Surfing Reserve, Trevor Back, against proposed trial. The reasons he put were lack of consultation on the Merrill minute. Two, absence of non-biased data based on fact rather than emotion. And three, no evidence of what will replace the nets. Now we've heard this morning around the table, community coming to us and we have voted quite extensively.
01:43:00 We've talked through all our discussions, through all the leaders that we can pull on through council which is open to councillors to represent our community in a fair and effective way. I won't support this amendment on B. Because as councillor Nicola has stated, there's no measurement around this. Our community is called for action. I, you know, we can't just keep having talk fest. I would prefer to see that this provides opportunity and based on only one of the people that I can mention here today that I'm using for my debate. Again, it's back to our community. This also is a state issue. Happy to be advocating. We have supported around the table time and time again, we've done the letters, we've supported it, we're listening to our community. However, our community is also calling for action.
01:44:00 So if it means that our community wants to get together and advocate and there's several opportunities that I feel is probably more effective and hear their voices heard than what we can do today, having a councillor discussion around advocacy methods. How do we measure that? We have to collectively come together and work together as a community. As an elected representative, I'm here today to represent fair and equity, every voice across the community, not just one, not just some, and go beyond council boardrooms, council advocacy groups, reaching into our community who have told us time and time again what they want and they want action. I feel the best way to support the action of the people that want to see a trial is again to write to the minister and then call upon the community to continue to advocate.
01:45:00 I will support where I can. I will put my hand to the plough. But I will not support councillors again just having a range of discussion around a meeting that we cannot even measure the effectiveness or how we reach that advocacy and then how do we then communicate that back to community. I think that it's ineffective, yeah we can have a discussion, but when we're reaching in for major change that leads the way of how from now and into the future, sustainable conversations, I talk about this all the time, we are in a point, we are facilitators of change. This is a challenging intersection that we sit at. And we have to look at new ways of being, new ways of conversations around the table and new ways of governance. When we talk about the leaders that we can pull on, yes there's many, but we are also limited as all the people here at the table. We run out there for community, we run for election and you land in here and we have our own constraints.
01:46:00 Collectively we need to pull together, to work together to be a strong united voice for generations now and into the future. And I think we can do better than support councillors discussion around advocacy methods. We all know what they are, we all know how to do them. And I think we need to have a stronger voice in supporting our community and our ocean animals and our environment for future generations. These are very significant times that we live in. We're making major decisions for the future of our young people, of our families, of our ageing population, our environment, our wildlife. These are very significant decisions being made by people like us around tables. We are at an intersection of change. From like babies, from the cradle to the grave, across the globe, we see the unrest.
01:47:00 Today we're seeing as a nation, we're lowering flags, we're lighting candles. We're looking at being the light overcome in the darkness. And we have to be, I am very mindful today of the people across our nation who are suffering. And I will not be supporting another talk fest when our community has called for action. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you councillor Finzel. Does anyone wish to speak to the amendment? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: I'll give the balancing argument. And I do it from someone who's spent 25 years in state government, who's written the drafts for responses to ministerial letters, who's engaged directly with ministerial officers. And there's two levels. There's obviously the bureaucracy, who have done the report which is referenced in councillor Lorentson's speech. And there's the ministerial advisors who have critical appointments.
01:48:00 The first step in writing to the ministry is understanding who's going to answer it. And in this one we've already had a civil answer so it's unlikely to get past the ministerial Councillor Wegener: advisors. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So let's be rational. The chances of success of the original motion are generally quite low. Just in the way that advocacy works. Writing letters to the minister is easy, it's simple, it's straightforward. But to suggest that it's taking action is probably not realistic in the perception that it's going to make a difference. And everyone around this table understands the importance of change and we've adopted approaches that have not been successful to date. Hence why the mayor has suggested that we try and do more. So for me the amendment is adding on to the original motion in that it's saying if we
01:49:00 are passionate about this issue we should be trying to do more to enhance the likelihood of success of our advocacy. It's as simple as that. The original motion has a low chance. Do we want to spend some time trying to improve that chance? Councillor Lorentson: Councillor Soffer. Councillor Lorentson. Thank you for your opinion Councillor Stockwell. I stand back. I'm not going to support the amendment and I've already sort of made clear my reasons. This again, in my opinion, negates my original motion. My original motion is one single specific action to write to the minister. Councillors can, regardless of whether this amendment goes up or down, they can still discuss a range of advocacy methods. I'm part of Oceans for All and members that have been sitting here. We've been part of this movement for the last six years. I'm part of Clean Oceans Foundation.
01:50:00 I'm part of Surf Rider Australia. I've been a member of the surf club for the last 16 years. My children are lifeguards. I'm in the ocean six to seven days a week. There are other opportunities. If you want to join the range of advocacy methods, our doors are open. Welcome to come and sit in a meeting at any time. Please give a respectful tone, Councillor. I'm passionate. Please be respectful. Totally accept that. But in terms of discussing a range of advocacy methods, that's going to transpire. If you're passionate in this space, there are tons of opportunities for you to get involved. Again, going back to my opinion, is this amendment negates the intent of this amendment. And the scope of my original motion, I also think it's a breach of standing orders 29. I'm not going to be supporting. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Lorentson. Any other councillors who wish to speak to the amendment?
01:51:00 Councillor Wegener: I'd just like to quickly note that the advocacy, we talk about we're not doing enough. The Noosa Biosphere Reserve Foundation has done incredible advocacy for learning about the situation. About learning about the behavior of sharks. About learning about alternatives. They started with the symposium. That sort of started this whole thing off. They have the current bull shark program, which is being funded partially by the Biosphere Reserve Foundation. And I think the best thing that the Biosphere Reserve Foundation supported was the Surf Safe Noosa campaign, which educates people on shark safety. And that is a wonderful campaign. So we are advocating. That's why I think that this is meaningless in a way. That we're already doing stuff. We need to continue the pressure on. I think that the destination management plan will address these things in a better way.
01:52:00 And with working with the NBRF and continuing their advocacy on learning about shark behavior and working within the system is better. Thank you. That's the way I think we should move forward. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Whittaker. I will close. Look, of course, if we discuss a range of advocacy methods, it's discussing and implementing a range of advocacy methods. This is happening already. I've had face-to-face meetings with ministers about this. And that will continue. So even if this amendment doesn't get up, it signals to the community that we are thinking about this. And I think it's going to be broader than letter writing. Letter writing that we know is going to get pushback from the minister. That we're not going to give up there. And that the advocacy is going to continue beyond letter writing. This is too important. It's not about us. This is about the marine mammals we're wanting to protect.
01:53:00 So I was wanting to give the original motion a greater chance of success by adding on other forms of advocacy for that idea. Which is instead of a six-month trial over a wild migration season, a three-month trial. It is a different approach. It was about giving that idea to the state through other methods other than a letter, a front-on letter, which we know is going to receive the same response. So, councillors, thank you for your feedback on this. Councillor Wilson, I do note your comments about this. I think it's important to note that the advocacy is not about the charter tax down south. And that is always the drawback with raising issues like this only through a modified motion, which is a very public form, every time we have a different idea. Whereas the advocacy can take different forms.
01:54:00 It doesn't need to be via a council resolution. All right. Thank you for your feedback, councillors. The advice that I've given you today is that we need to be more open to the public. And the important thing is that we continue to do that. And that will continue beyond just letter writing. I put the amendment to the vote. Those in favour? Councillor Wignell, Stockwell and Wilkie. Those against? Councillors Lorentson, Phillips, Finzel and Wilson. The amendment is lost. We go back to the original motion to which councillor Lorentson and Phillips has said spoken. Anybody else wish to speak to the original motion? Councillor Wegener: Having been involved in the Shark Smart program and really watching all of this, I believe that we are far from taking an evidence-based position on the adequacy of smart drumlines
01:55:00 and drones. There is a lot of work to be done on these, on these shark medications. And there's a lot of misinformation. When people say shark nets do nothing to stop sharks, stop especially white sharks, well, do we have an evidence-based, science-based opinion or study that says that the shark nets don't? Because really, really smart people put them there in the first place a very long time ago. So I think that there is a, I want to support evidence-based solutions. There are solutions to this very serious problem with the shark attacks on the rise in Australia. Taking out the nets at this time is, doesn't, is not based on what we consider evidence-based in my, that's my thought. And I think, so I won't be supporting the motion, but yeah. Yeah.
01:56:00 Mayor Wilkie: Councillor Wainwright. Speaker 1: I'll speak to the motion. Mayor Wilkie: Councillor Wainwright. Councillor Wainwright. If the council's, if the council's wanted the right to elect the Minister again, we can do that. I'm not against advocating putting this idea to the Minister by the same method that we tried before. But also we ought to be investigating other methods of advocating as well. So if a letter is part of that, I've got no issue with that. Okay. The Repending or the Feedback. As I say, it's too important an issue to not think carefully about and not be persistent about. So I'll be supporting the latter to the same.
01:57:00 Any other councillors wish to speak? Councillor Wilson, you have your hand up. Is that your wish to speak? Councillor Wilson: Yeah, thank you. I'll support it. I think it's a little bit redundant given what we're already doing, but it doesn't stop us doing other advocacy. And I think it's good to keep the pressure on. I'm not sure at the moment if the Queensland State Government will support this, so I think it's good to just keep giving our opinion on this. So I will support it. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Wilson. Any other councillors wish to speak? Councillor Finzel? Councillor Finzel: Yeah, I'd like to thank Councillor Lorentson for bringing this. I agree. I think we've got to keep the pedal on. I think writing letters to State, they're free to respond in whatever manner they like.
01:58:00 We're here to represent the people. This is at the forefront of our people and our community. We've done all our surveys. We've done surveys, livability surveys, all surveys where we've engaged the community environment continually with consistency comes up number one. I support it. I think writing letters and keeping it front and centre for the State is advocacy at its best. It's not up to us to measure those outcomes. The State will make their own decisions. It is redundant in a way because they are aware of where we stand, but I'm happy to support it. And with regards to advocacy, we are continually advocating in our role as councillors daily, every day of the week, calling on whatever mechanisms we have. Why I didn't support B was the same reason. I feel that we're already doing those jobs. I think it's back to community. I want to congratulate all the people out there every day that are out pulling a jump from the ocean, that are looking after our beaches, that are looking after our environment.
01:59:00 All kudos to them. And, you know, supporting a letter to represent their voice and the importance of what that is to them, to our community and the State, I'm happy to support. But I'm also with Councillor Wenda that we do need to have more discussions and I'm not an expert. We want to have the evidence, we want to hear from the scientists and the specialists and the people that are out there daily collecting the data, doing the measurements, being in the water. So I think, yeah, we can drive this forward. Probably next time there might be better ways that we can do this. But this is what's before us now and so I will not support the letter to the State. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Finzel. Any other councillors wish to speak before Councillor Lorentson who closes? Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Lorentson: Just to address a few things that were raised around the table. In terms of the notified motion and with all sincere and dear respect to the lives that have just been taken,
02:00:00 and those that have been part of the attacks down in New South Wales, the notified motion was put to Council before those incidences. So I would like that on record. Secondly, in terms of Councillor Wegener, the notified motion does not seek to remove the nets. It seeks to replace the nets with what the Cardmo report, which is the Queensland Shark Control Program review of alternative approaches that was commissioned by the Queensland. Government in 2019. Part of their recommendations where they found that replacing, not removing, replacing the two nets at Noosa with additional drumlines, quote, could potentially maintain catches of the three most dangerous target shark species, which is the tiger, the bull and the white shark, whilst reducing catches of other sharks and by catch by approximately 97%. That is to date the most comprehensive, independent, scientific assessment of shark control equipment used in Queensland.
02:01:00 Thank you for the conversation around the table. Thank you for allowing me to speak over my five times and also for pulling me up when I do get passionate. I respect the processes and I also respect my obligations as a counsellor to speak respectfully around the table. What the motion in front of us, before I speak to that, I also want to acknowledge some incredible people that are sitting here in the chamber today. And that's Albie Curtis and Peppy Simpson. I have been walking alongside these two incredible water men, water people, some of the most respected people in this community, who live and breathe and who are living and breathing. They are literally the voice of our marine animals.
02:02:00 And I stand here proud to represent you. What the notified motion here is, is a refined three month targeted trial that has never, ever been put to the Minister. Not once. The question before us is simple. Is the small risk of creating political harm? Discomfort? Is the small risk of getting a no or from the Minister? Is the small risk of the Minister not even replying to us? Is that greater than the very real risk of seeing another whale or another calf entangled in our nets in five months time? I don't believe it is. What we're proposing in a letter, and again, I've provided a template which I really encourage everyone please to read.
02:03:00 It's a measured, respectful, modern letter that aligns with the State and Noosa Council's own priorities, which is to prioritise human life. Replacing passive, static nets with smart drumlines. Deploying piers to deter whales and dolphins. Trialling alternative hooks. Expanding drone surveillance. Every one of these tools strengthens human safety. The State's and Council's number one priority. While also giving whales and their calves and other endangered species like turtles and dolphins a genuine chance at safe passage through our waters. We all know what will happen in five months. The migration will begin again. And if there is another entanglement, we around this table can say that we tried. That we took a responsible, evidence-based step to prevent it.
02:04:00 So again, take this opportunity to thank, great conversation around this table. And to the Councillors, you know, there's someone told me many, many years ago, you've got two choices in Council. Do the right thing or do what's right. And every day I try to do what's right. Jane Goodall to end in with a quote. She reminds us that what you do makes a difference. And you have to decide what kind of difference you want to make. And today, let's make a difference, guys. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Morrison. Put it to the vote. Those in favour? Councillor Wilson? Yes. That's unanimous. The motion is carried. Now up to 10.2, independent review of community service surveys. Councillor Phillips, would you like to make your motion? Councillor Phillips: Thank you. I have a notified motion this morning, which I'll read.
02:05:00 My recommendation for independent review of community surveys, that Council requires community engagement surveys that are developed to support consultation and or decision making for significant Council projects. Undergo an independent review by a suitably qualified third party prior to release to ensure methodological integrity, neutrality of framing and confidence in the reliability of the data used to inform Council decision making. And B, request the CEO to provide a report back to Council for further consideration and or decision that explores the potential opportunities and costs in line with Council's standing orders. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. Could we have a seconder for that, please? I think she's second. I second. So, Councillor Lorentson just shouted at you.
10.2 INDEPENDENT REVIEW OF COMMUNITY SURVEYS ¶
02:06:00 Sorry, Councillor Wilson. Councillor Phillips. Thank you. Councillor Phillips: Okay. Thank you. First of all, I just want to start by acknowledging the staff that we do have in the space of community engagement. Because at no point through processes that I want to do in this role is to ever sort of undermine or, you know, question the credibility or expertise in the room. So, that's how I want to start today. But probably from day one, I've sat in here and heard deputations or on community around consultations. We've heard it again today. And so, for the last few months with the CEO, I have been working on how to look at opportunities to rebuild trust with community around this, our engagement through the specific surveys that we do. I want to just take you back to 2008 for a second when I graduated from the police academy
02:07:00 as a very young constable. And I got given all these proformas from the sergeants around how to have questions with community because I, you know, had to follow these sort of standard questions. And I remember standing at a break and enter reading through my sheet questions, answers. And at the end, you know, my senior officer sort of stepped in without a proforma and asked questions that I'd completely missed because I followed this proforma. And he took me aside after and he said, the proformas are great, Jess. But you're not listening because you're just following this sort of process, right? And he sort of started my journey of what he said active listening looks like. And he said, if you're actively listening and the way you phrase a question will give you the outcome. And then sort of through my experience, then I gained so much more around how that actually looks.
02:08:00 So I was part of a full review with the QPS around interviews because we used to interview with questions that were eliciting a certain response. And then we looked at this, the way they interviewed today, which is called investigative interviewing. And it's all around open-ended questions and how do we get the most from our questioning techniques. That took so many reviews. And I'm sure you've watched, you know, movies where someone's sitting in, you know, the police officers demanding, you know, that the person lock themselves into a narrative or a story. So anyway, my point is, questioning is, the way it's phrased can give you a certain outcome. And in my experience now, when I came to Council, I remember sort of standing up and you'll remember, I would read from a sheet of paper because I felt like I've got to say the right thing. And if I fumble over it and say, you know, people are going to think I'm not an expert communicator.
02:09:00 But that's actually not reality. You know, communication is eye contact. It's body language. It's all of the things that come into play. And when we take offline or we're not face-to-face and you can't see my body language, that's so interpreted so differently because around 80% of our communication comes from non-verbals. So a smile, a head nod, the gesture, so I'm listening, the way we, you know, communicate. That's why when on paper, when we write an email or on Facebook, you might get a comment saying, that says a certain... Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Point of order. We're dealing with getting third party review of surveys. We appear to be having a speech on good communication. I think it's widely off what the motion is on. Councillor Phillips: I'll bring it in because I am going to... Thank you. I am going to talk about why. So through communication, when we're speaking like this,
02:10:00 when we're doing our surveys, we don't have that. We don't have someone from Council standing. Actually, through the DMP, we had that great response where community, when they were face-to-face with our director, she said to us how much different the communication was when they were out there. And we've heard it today around when they do pop-ups, it's different. So the purpose of today is around the actual surveys because when we put out a survey, the questions have to be really fine-tuned around what we're trying to achieve. So we're hoping that community can give us their honest feedback. And for me, the three major things that we've probably seen with DMP, planning scheme, the foreshore plan, some of the feedback we got was the questions gave us the outcome. And today, I just want to... The motion was more around if we have that third party, we talk about the statistical valid information that comes out of the survey results,
02:11:00 but we can't really confidently say that prior to that, it's gone through a third party review. That really gives us confidence that there's no unconscious bias, which everyone has. And it really gives us confidence that when we have that data and the outcomes from the survey, that it really gives us confidence. So, sorry, I apologise for... I was on track until the point of order. I just want to bring it back to the points that I wanted to raise, because it did tie into effective communication. So, I might go over my five minutes because I've been thrown off a little bit. The community are asking around the nation about trust between local, state and federal government. They talk a lot about feeling misheard, misrepresented. I worked with the CEO
02:12:00 on this notified motion, and he considered that it really will give us an extra layer. It's not going to please everyone. I know that there's no outcome today that's going to completely give us, you know, that. But I'm trying to build trust with our community. I'm trying to say every time we make decisions in this room, we have gone through a really robust process. I'm not saying that that doesn't happen today. I'm just asking for another layer. It's not about undermining the organisation or the process that we currently have, but it's actually simplifying and strengthening and making our process more mature and up-to-date with what can be done. So, I do hope you consider what I've put up and support it. Thanks. Thank you, Councillor Phillips. Mayor Wilkie: Any other councillors? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: We should move an amendment, please.
02:13:00 Mayor Wilkie: An amendment? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So, the amendment deletes the A and rewords B to request the CEO to provide a report back to council for further consideration that explores the potential opportunities, implications and costs of obtaining independent review of surveys to be used as part of the community... of community engagement on... Oh, no. ...significant council projects and plans. Mayor Wilkie: Can we have a seconder for the amendment, please? Councillor Wegener. Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor Stockwell. I want to start by saying I support the objective that Councillor Phillips has outlined in her supporting information, particularly with respect that what she is attempting in this motion is to support transparent and defensible decisions making, align council practice with recognised standards
02:14:00 in research, social science and community consultation, and that it reflects Noosa Council's commitment to high-quality engagement and evidence-based policy. It's therefore unfortunate that it was raised as a notice of motion without any high-quality engagement nor significant evidence base. We've heard the justification is that there has been some issues raised by the community and I hear them. We heard some this morning. We heard that it's leading to lower participation rates, which, if we get the statistics, you'll find that probably... we're probably one of the highest-level governments in Australia in terms of participation on significant projects. And the fact that we do get statistically valid responses to surveys suggests that participation isn't being affected. We've got massive participation. We've got very high expectations in the community. We've got people in our community who are interested in participating. We've got people in our community who do know a lot about surveying.
02:15:00 We heard that, you know, that there's concerns about the... that not having the civil expertise. And we know that our community consultation coordinator has extensive experience in that discipline and a PhD. And if she was in consultancy, she'd be one of the people we'd be paying to do third-party reviews of surveys. So, by raising it as a notice of motion, it doesn't give us the opportunity to fully consider the implications of this isolated approach to one element of consultation. There is no urgency to make this decision now. There is no significant consultation coming up or surveys that doesn't allow us to consider it in full context with the evidence base, with an understanding of how surveys are currently portrayed. Like, the two biggest surveys we've run are done by the leadership of... I don't know if it's in the field in Australia. So, is that the target of them?
02:16:00 Maybe not. So, what I've done is removed the direct developments. The direct development in A is basically saying, we're going to set the policy, then we're going to ask for a report about it. I've just suggested, let's get a report, and actually that will come with a prior workshop or something that's picked around the table. So, we all have an understanding of what this might mean. I would like to make my decision after receiving the advice of our qualified and experienced staff, and some have decades of experience in this field. I want to hear what our staff think about what is the most effective use of ratepayer dollars, because A really commits us to higher cost consultation on significant projects. And as we have said in response to one of the questions, quite frequently, we do have independent experts as consultants to these projects. I want to say, how do we best get community input and community engagement? Is it paying consultants to do third-party review? Or is it investing in upskilling our staff?
02:17:00 Because maybe part of the issue is not the community engagement area, but other parts of the council that could benefit from understanding how to construct surveys. And that's a great example of building the capacity within, rather than committing to paying consultants out into the field. And also, the amount of money we would spend on third-party is going to receive better results if we invest in other aspects of engagement. We've heard recently, we've upgraded our Your Say Noosa page, and that's a platform now that we can receive a lot of informal inputs from the community, and the page itself is leading edge, and it can analyse the sentiment. So maybe the importance of formal surveys aren't going to be as high in the future. So, the amendment doesn't negate the motion. As I said, I understand where we have done surveys of some concerns, and always we should be trying to encourage staff to have that process of continuous improvement and innovation.
02:18:00 But what it does say is, if we are committed to good engagement, then notice of the motion aren't the way to do it. Really clearly. And if we are committed to evidence-based, we don't need to do that. If we are committed to background information to a notice of motion, we do it after considering all the facts. And I understand why it's raised, but I think we've got time to consider it in more depth, and to come up with, it might be the same recommendation, but we will have considered the evidence-based and considered what is best to spend the ratepayers' money on, in terms of improving the inputs from our community to our significant projects and their plans. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. Thank you, Councillor Stockwell. Councillor Phillips: Question to the CEO. During the process, the lengthy process, I've gone with the CEO, Larry Sengstock about this. I put to him questions around when we go for grants, that it could be part of the process.
02:19:00 So I just want to clarify, because he did say to me that it's certainly available to us, that we, through the, you know, when we apply for the, because I've specifically said it's for the major, significant Council projects, that, just to clarify, that there's a really strong potential it won't imply any costs to Council, because it'll be part of the consultation budget that's put to the projects. So Councillor Lewis, Mayor Wilkie: what's the question? Councillor Phillips: I just want to clarify, because Councillor Stockwell's raised something that it's going to imply costs, but I already checked with this that it would be part of the consultation, like a budget that's already part of the project. Mayor Wilkie: So you're making a comment or you're raising a question? Councillor Phillips: I'm raising the question, because it negates what? The question starts with how, what, why, Mayor Wilkie: when, or when. Councillor Phillips: Can you, Mayor Wilkie: can you? Okay. Could you, could you, I still haven't heard a question in what you're asking. Councillor Phillips: Can you clarify?
02:20:00 Yes. When we go for our major Council projects, that there is a budget that has consultation in it. The CEO, to confirm, for the Councillors around the room, he has told me that it can be part of that process, that it's an external third party rather, and it won't cost Council anymore, because it'll be part of that big, the project budget. Speaker 5: Thank you. Thank you. Speaker 6: Thank you. Yeah, through the Chair. Yeah, happy to answer that. You know, I'm happy to give some advice on it. Obviously challenging in the sense that each project will attract different types of funding potentially. Some of it may be partial. Some of it may be co-contribution. So whilst Council as part of its request for grant can incorporate communication and planning as part of its budget bid, it will, it, potentially may vary. So I guess it's not a blanket confirmation that it will always be covered without any additional cost to Council, but in cases where we have received grants, some of that can incorporate costs for private consultancies in terms of design, but also engagement as well.
02:21:00 So there's no one fits all. It can be in certain situations, but also there may be situations where Council may need to fund that or co-contribute to the overall project costs. Councillor Phillips: Just a follow-up question. And I appreciate, Richard, that you're not who I've had these conversations with, so I apologise. But when I was discussing this with CEO Larry Sengstock, that's part of B, which was going to come back to the report to us. So we weren't making financial decisions through this notified motion. I just want that to be very clear. Speaker 6: That's just it. Thank you. Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: I just want to speak. I was going to call. I don't want to bore you up, but I missed that opportunity because I didn't want to interrupt. I just think that when you're addressing a Councillor, that you don't need to mansplain to her what the question is.
02:22:00 I think that is disrespectful, Mr Chair, to have to mansplain who, what, when, why to the Director. I apologise if I have to move out of that. However, I will rephrase that. When we come together around the table, I think we're called to be respectful. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. And it is my job to ascertain a question when, if a Councillor is speaking for a long period of time and a question still hasn't been, it's not obvious, it's the Chair's role to evince that question, get that question clarified, so that the meeting runs according to standing orders. And I'm going, please if I explain something, let's not use gender-based discriminatory language. And I'm going, please if I explain something, let's not use gender-based discriminatory language to describe behaviour, if that's not appropriate.
02:23:00 So, thank you, Councillor Phillips, for getting to the question eventually, in order, in response to your point of order, Councillor Finzel, that's the Chair's role to get Councillors, to cut to the chase with questions. Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: Thank you, yes, thank you, Mr Chair, I appreciate your interpretation of the standing orders and what's expected around the table. I just think that we can... Mayor Wilkie: Is this a point of order? Councillor Finzel: I just wanted to respond to your comment. Mayor Wilkie: No, you are wrong. Councillor Finzel: Well, my apologies. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. Now, I'm going to exercise my right to speak. I'm going to support the amendment for a simple reason, because it's the correct process. It clarifies the correct process, because Part A requires community engagement surveys take place. With the, um, with review of the process. It's done by a survey-qualified party, whereas the correct process is to have the report to Councillors first, be done first, about the costs and implications of obtaining the independent survey reviews.
02:24:00 So, it achieves Councillor Phillips' objective, but it's, it's the, puts it in the correct order of process. The other reason I support it is because, um, there's a lot of discussion in the community about Council relying a lot on consultants. So, it's very important that if we're going to go down the track of implying more consultants, the costs of that are understood, the costs and political implications of that are clearly understood by Councillors before we commit to that. The other reason is a cultural one. Um, and that is culture starts at the top, and the tone set by Councillors, um, and the words and the language used by Councillors does have an impact on the staff. So, we're talking about independent, uh, neutral, neutral, unbiased language.
02:25:00 And Part A, um, does mention, uh, it does question the integrity, the neutrality, and the reliability of the staff's work. So, by, uh, removing Part A, you go to Part B, which is a more neutral and unbiased resolution that's unlikely to impugn the integrity, neutrality, and the confidence and the reliability of staff work. So, it still achieves the same outcome. It's correct process and uses more neutral and unbiased language. Um, Chris? I support the, um, I support the amendment. Councillor Lorentson: Um, question. Councillor Morrison. So, question through the Chair. In terms of process and even language, um, Councillor Phillips, you've raised that you've been in discussions for some time with the CEO.
02:26:00 Can I ask, um, was any of this advice afforded to you? Councillor Phillips: Actually, we've been tic-tacking for months about the wording, and the CEO was satisfied with, um, the end result, um, last week before. So, um, there was definitely a process around how to make sure that, as I spoke, um, uh, to answer your question, he helped me through the process and satisfied with the wording. Councillor Lorentson: Um, another, uh, another question through the Chair. You raised, um... Councillor Wilson: I've had my hand up. I'm sorry. Speaker 6: Oh, yes. Excuse me. Oh, sorry, Councillor Nicholas. Sorry. Councillor Wilson. Sorry about that. You have a floor, Councillor Wilson. Councillor Wilson: Um, I want to speak against the amendment. Um, I think it substantially changes the original, um, motion put forward by Councillor Phillips. And also, unfortunately, I didn't hear most of what Councillor Stockwell said, um, because there's been a bit of an audio issue. But I think, to begin with, he said that, um, this wasn't in any way, um, uh, supported by community feedback.
02:27:00 And I don't think the amendment in any way helps that point. So, um, there has been community feedback that, that the surveys are biased and multi-pronged and lots of different issues with the surveys. And I don't think this amendment actually goes in any way to, um, to solve that. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Wilson. Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Lorentson: Um, I, I might just speak to the amendment in front of us. Um, I'm not going to support it either. Uh, I go back to section 29 of the standing orders. And I believe that, um, the amendment materially alters the original motion because, um, it changes an immediate requirement. The original notified motion, when you read it, requires surveys undergo independent review.
02:28:00 Um, the motion or the amendment in front of us requests a report that explores opportunities rather than a directive to implement independent reviews. Um, so, for me, what I'm reading in front of me, uh, delays action and weakens the original intent. And also, we've heard through Councillor Wilson that she's been advised over many, many months that the wording, um, was fine and that the CEO was satisfied, um, with the original amendment as it stood. Mayor Wilkie: Councillor, question for Councillor Stockwell. Councillor Stockwell. Does, does your, your amendment, does that just require that there be a report to Council informing Councillors about the costs and implications of doing the independent survey, review of surveys before Council makes a decision on whether they do it or not? Or, yeah.
02:29:00 Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Yeah, that, that is the intent. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. You're not saying that Councillor, Council is, is not going to do it? You're saying you get a, a review of the implications of costs before deciding to do it? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Yes. It's to, to be informed by staff prior to making a decision in that. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. Councillor Phillips: I'll speak, um, against the amendment, please. Um, it does change the intent of my notified motion completely. Um, the community continually taking time out to come and do deputations. I don't want another report. I want a part of it. But my point is, we actually, they just keep asking for us to do something. They want action. Um, I feel that they're spending a significant amount of time coming in asking for us to review, um, and look at how our surveys have been conducted today. Again, we've heard it.
02:30:00 Um, so, it doesn't meet, um, my intention at all around, um, what I'm asking from the organisation. Mayor Wilkie: Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: Yes. Um, question through the Chair to Councillor Phillips. During those ongoing discussions, did you discuss the, um, viability of, um, putting the energy into when the survey is actually set up? So that, I'm interested to hear, like, how those discussions went so that it was more of a set-up stage rather than the, the review at the end. Councillor Phillips: Yeah. That's exactly right. Um, Councillor Finzel, it's, um, not about the results that we're getting from the surveys. It's the set-up and the wording. Um, and I didn't want to, again, um, with respect to staff, I wasn't wanting to highlight that, um, we all have unconscious bias and when they're working on projects. So this was just more to give community real satisfaction that it has gone through somewhat
02:31:00 a third party to review that there's no leading questions or any type of, um, wording used in our questioning that already sort of gives us an outcome, um, because otherwise we're relying only on the statistical valid information that has come out of the survey, not in the preliminary development of the survey. Does that answer your question? Mayor Wilkie: I have a question for Councillor Stockwell. Your amendment is part of the Report Act of Council. In terms of it explores the implications, is that about the, the work that's done or written? This process is done before it's written? And the impact on staff is going to a third party consultant? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Um. What do you mean by, what do you mean by implications? Oh, well, the, the first one just said opportunities and costs. Um, you, implications are broader than just the opportunities and costs because there will be implications, uh, that are non-financial.
02:32:00 So it's about what are the, all the implications. For example, if we're in a tight timeframe and we've got this requirement and we have to go out to a third party review, uh, quite often there's councillors who set very tight deadlines. Does that mean that this trumps the fact that we're going to a deadline? There's a range of different, um, dynamics within the process, um, and so the implications is just broader. Mayor Wilkie: Yeah. And is your point that a notified motion doesn't give councillors all the background information they need to make an informed decision about whether they make this big change? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: That's what I said. Yeah. Thank you. Councillor Lorentson: Um, question through the chair. Um, this big change that you reference, uh, Mayor Wilkie. Yeah. Um, at the moment, in terms of significant projects, so I'm referencing botanical gardens, um, Pomona placemaking, destination management plan, our state amendments.
02:33:00 Um, who currently designs the project? Our, our, our survey and engagement processes. So, the, is, is that correct? Through the chair. Speaker 6: Yeah, uh, through the chair. Yeah, so, we're already counceling and I think it was, um, alluded to in response to a public question time this morning, but we do already engage consultants around, um, public engagement strategies and, um, so we bring on highly skilled consultants to help us around with different methodologies. And we've set about really one of those methods of how we garner and gather feedback from our community. Councillor Lorentson: In terms of engaging or outsourcing the engagement process, what's the criteria used to select providers, just out of curiosity?
02:34:00 Speaker 6: Through the Chair, I don't have the specifics on that at hand, so I can take that on notice and get back to you specifically around that. Whether it's through a broader tender process or through Q and A approaches, but I'll come back to you on those for the response, Councillor. Councillor Lorentson: And a question to the author of the notified motion. So given that we already are outsourcing and engaging independent parties, can you just clarify that your notified motion sort of just mandates it for significant projects with huge public interest or concerns around it? Councillor Phillips: Correct. That's why we, the CEO and I, worked on the significant part of, just so it wasn't... Constantly, Council are putting out small surveys, so this was more around the significant one. And it was kind of off the back of finding out through the DNP process that the questions weren't actually written by the consultants,
02:35:00 they were written in-house, and that was one of the most recent ones that we got feedback that they felt, the community felt, that the sort of decisions were made through that process rather than meaningful consultation. So that was kind of what triggered the final part of me putting this way. I've also raised it, you know, I've had community surveys on our Council-only discussion forums quite a few times. I think we've spoken about comms, so I think this was the only next step for me, and I worked with the CEO on that as well. Mayor Wilkie: Okay. Anybody else wish to speak to the amendment? I'll close. Councillor Stockwell? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Yeah, so I appreciate, I'll move closer to the speaker, that Councillor Wilson had difficulty hearing, but what she suggested I was saying was not correct.
02:36:00 What I said is I acknowledge that you do see community feedback and input around our surveys. And I know that there is room for improvement in everything we do, and surveys is one that we have a number of people who quite frequently identify what they see as shortcomings. It's, yeah, the process on big projects of getting a third party involved, I've got no objection to. But it's really important that when we as councillors come here and say the community has been asking to us, without the evidence, then we should question it. And I question that Councillor Phillips can talk on behalf of the community when a mere handful of people based on social media and Reel have raised it,
02:37:00 when we've got 30,000 or more voters. We can't just take informal input as being representative. And we can't make decisions on policy on the run. And this is what this will do. This is making policy decisions on the run. And we can't say we're committed to high quality engagement if you've talked to the CEO about this for four months but haven't talked to your colleagues. It's poor practice. So if I'm going to make decisions about community engagement, a subject that I've had a lot to do with in my career, you know, I've had many decades and worked with community to win many state and national awards for my community engagement, and I'm not saying that I disagree with this being one of the options to improve the way we do it. What I'm disagreeing with is to put up a notice of motion and expect a decision without the evidence base and with the quality of engagement with your colleagues to get there.
02:38:00 Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. Councillor Stockwell. Those in favour of the amendment? Councillor Stockwell. Councillor Wilkie. Those against the amendment? Councillor Morrison. Councillor Phillips. Councillor Wegener. Councillor Finzel. Yes. Councillor Wilson. The amendment is lost. We go back to the original motion to which only Councillor Phillips has spoken. Any other councillors wish to speak to the motion? Councillor Wegener: Yeah. I understand Councillor Phillips' concerns. We've discussed it quite a bit. Around the table and informally. But I think this whole notice of motion thing is, in my opinion, a waste of time. We're spinning our wheels so much time here.
02:39:00 Next, I think that we're trying to force what we should be doing. I think our job is actually, when we're around the table and a big project comes up with us, we can sit down with the team and say, okay, we're going to do this. We're not really happy with the survey questions. We're not really happy with them in the past. Maybe we should have a look at that and look at it at that time. We don't do this notice of motion and create a new bureaucracy, a new level of bureaucracy, when our job is to actually oversee and manage these big projects. So, I'm not going to support this because, as you know, I'm very, very against micromanagement. I'm very against numerous layers of bureaucracy. I suggest that we'd be much more efficient and much more productive if we, in my opinion, did our job around the table better. And I think our job will evolve.
02:40:00 As we learn, we go forward. But through the next program, if we say we want the questions, our consultation, we can get our fingerprints on that consultation. That's what we do. That's our job as councillors. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. Thank you, councillor. Any other councillors who wish to speak to the notice of motion? Councillor Wilson. Councillor Wilson: Thank you. I will support this. I think in my almost two years as councillor, this has come up several times already. And we don't get to see those questions before they go out. So, I don't like micromanaging either. So, I don't like micromanaging either. But this is really important that when something goes out to public consultation that it's not biased. And I know from being in education when I've been writing multiple choice questions for assessments, it's hard.
02:41:00 Like, this is not something that, you know, this is something that has to go through lots of layers of review and testing. And you can be too close to it. And I just think we need someone independent to be part of this process. And that's what we need. That should just be a given every time. But it's a big kind of project. And we've gone through it with the foreshore plan. We've gone through it with the planning scheme. We've gone through it with the DMP. And I think now it's time to just say, okay, this isn't working. We're getting the feedback that it's not working. And we need to do something. We need to bring in some people who are not involved in these projects and get them to help us out here and make sure that every community consultation is best practice. Councillor Finzel: Thank you for the notice and motion. I think we can get better efficiencies than raising through notice and motions.
02:42:00 I do agree with that. But I will support this coming to the foreshore plan. I think we've all been to the table today. And we've been passionate about that. We all have been. And I think I'll support it in terms of continuous improvement. Some of the conversation around the table today has been a bit like thought provoking about how we've arrived at this situation. But having said that, you know, I think with quite what Councillor Wegener alluded to is that, you know, we need to do our jobs. And, yes, we've had significant changes. We've had significant things come through. And it's all learning. So I think that's where we find ourselves at that intersection today. Because we do have and have had opportunity to engage with staff and consultants and specialists at the table through processes. So I don't think it's completely broken. I appreciate where you're coming from.
02:43:00 Because it is about how can we do better. How can we engage with the community in a more tangible way that really represents their voice coming back to us. And I think, you know, it's to be commended for everyone. All the staff, all the councillors, the CEO, everyone. We're all here for the right reasons to engage our community and have meaningful consultation to inform our decisions moving forward. So I'll support it today in terms of, you know, how we can do better. How we can give voice to our people better. How we can support our staff to do their jobs better. And how we can make it a more trustworthy process so that our community feels that we have all done the best we can in terms of continuous improvement. How we listen to what people say around the table. How we give significance to that voice.
02:44:00 And how together we can move forward to build that consistency and trust in the community. That we will commit to rigorous process and reviewing what's before us. Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Finzel. Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Lorentson: First, I'd like to just thank Councillor Phillips for exercising your rights to bring emergent issues to the table through notified motions. This is an emergent issue. I've been in council now six years and even today, the theme of all the deputations were centred around this very, very matter. Community engagement process and perceived bias. So thank you very much for bringing this matter to the table. The motion in front of us is really quite simple. It's a motion about strengthening public confidence in our engagement processes. We already do this. But we need to do it more.
02:45:00 And particularly in matters that have significant public interest and matter to our community. Independent review. And I need to make this clear. Independent review has got nothing to do with questioning the staff. We have great staff. Very skilled staff. Independent review is about supporting them. It's about ensuring that significant, for significant projects, we have a second set of expert eyes to check for bias, clarity and reliability. I've been, you know, for a number of years, I've been in a position where I've been in universities for 10, I think possibly 12 years. It's a standard practice. In research, it's a standard practice to have a second set of eyes. Social science, as Councillor Stockwell mentioned, in policy development. And it's also increasingly common in local councils. So this is best practice.
02:46:00 Again, especially for the new, not the new councillors. They are experienced councillors. But at the beginning of this term, we saw firsthand what happens when community surveys are perceived as leading or unclear through the Noosaville Foreshore Management Plan, even through the Destination Management Plan. So this motion in front of us helps prevent that. And again, I thank Councillor Phillips for bringing it forward to us. It protects the integrity of our data. It supports transparent decision making. Shows the community that it's important. That we take their input seriously. And most importantly, it supports our staff. Thank you, Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Stockwell. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Yeah, I won't repeat my arguments within the, that I made in the amendments for why I can't support this. But I will support Councillor Wegener. The right time to make these decisions is when a particular project or plan is in front
02:47:00 of us. It's not to have a blanket without a blanket. Because in some instances, it will be perfectly reasonable. And as you suggested, it may be something that's built into a grant application that doesn't. For others, it may be that it isn't the appropriate way forward. That's the key to it. And that's the reason I can't support it, is it's committing council to a policy position, outlying for significant projects. But the term significant project isn't defined. Is it a policy position? Is it just those projects that are highlighted in our corporate plan? Is it like we did last year? List a range of different consultations. Some got more consultation than the other. But then one of those wasn't the botanical garden. So Councillor Lorentson suggested it's a significant project. What does significant mean? We haven't set up that. These are all things that should be addressed if we're going to go down this as a policy
02:48:00 approach. We should have it clear. It shouldn't be left up to others to interpret what's intended. And I think it should be one that we make, you know, the best time to make it is when we've got the significant project and plan in front of us and we're deciding how to do it. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. Councillor Wilson, you have your hand up. Councillor Wilson: Thank you. I just had a question, sorry, before Councillor Stockwell closed. It's my understanding that this is common practice for Sunshine Coast Council. So could anyone confirm that, please? Speaker 6: Look, I can't confirm or deny that specifically on, again, if it's on significant projects in terms of what scale that they do or don't do a third party review or survey. So I can't give that to you right now. But I could make some inquiries and put some advice back to councillors on notice. Mayor Wilkie: Question on notice? There's a question on notice. It's a question on notice. It's a question on notice.
02:49:00 Councillor Wilson, were you able to hear that? Councillor Wilson: Most of it, yeah. Councillor Lorentson: Thank you. Thank you. Councillor Lorentson? Just my understanding is that it is best practice in a few councils. And I would also be, just a question on notice, having a look at Moreton Bay Council and Brisbane City Council. Mayor Wilkie: Right. Thank you. And we'll speak to the motion. I am relieved to see in there that it involves significant council projects only. But as Councillor Stockwell said, there is some wavery around what that actually means. So as long as we're able to have a discussion around what constitutes a significant project, that will make it in the motion.
02:50:00 But I think that the motion is in line with what we understand is happening already. The Planning Scheme amendments, for example, the Noosaville foreshore master plan. I did have concerns about something about the irony of a motion that seeks to have greater collaboration and engagement come through a notified motion process, which doesn't necessarily involve councillors. Like, a lot of these issues that we've seen come through as notified motions can be the subject of councillor discussion forums, where we have a collaborative understanding of what a councillor would like to achieve. And reports can be brought through the organisation, which gives the councillors, when it comes to making the decision, all the background data and costs involved, rather than requiring
02:51:00 councillors to be involved in the process. So I think it's important for councillors to make that decision without that information before them. I note that part B there says that the CEO will provide a report back to council that mentions the costs and potential opportunities in line with the council's standing orders. And perhaps that's where the implications can also be outlined to councillors to consider. So, although I have some misgivings, I don't think I'm going to go into too much detail analysis. I will support this notified motion. But I would like to hope that councillors can take a collaborative approach down about what they're hoping to see and achieve, which is in line with what we're trying to achieve with our community engagement, through our councillor discussion forums, or councillor monitoring discussions.
02:52:00 We'll just talk when we're here together. That way we can all be on the same page and understand what we're trying to achieve. And help that we're trying to achieve and have a more consensus view on the outcomes, which are ultimately for the betterment of the community. And that's what we're all here for. So I will support the notified motion. Councillor Phillips: Closed. Thank you. I'm with you, Tom. I actually, the notified motion process is not, was not my ideal. I really don't want to, I think this is really inappropriate. I think it's really inefficient for staff and for us, especially for this. But I got to the point where I felt like I had raised it at councillor only, and I'd raised it in discussions. So I kind of felt like, what's my next step? In the DMP, we did ask for the questions and that wasn't provided. So I got to a point like I really do think I'm someone that thoroughly tries other avenues,
02:53:00 because I'm really not in it for the politics at all. So I really wanted to be able to go back out to community every time it's mentioned and back our staff. Like I think that, like councillor Lorentson said, it's actually about saying, no, you're wrong. It's been through an independent process. Because we speak about this all the time. There is a lack of confidence in local, state and federal government at the moment. I can't control what they're doing, but I can only control what we do in this room. It's up to us individually to say, what matters to our community? How do I do that effectively? Whether this wasn't the right process, maybe, maybe not. To me, it's just really being able to say, no, it's gone through independence. The staff knew. And if it comes out that it was completely clear that the questions were not leading,
02:54:00 then what a bummer. But it's a thing to celebrate as a council. When we get the outcome and the data and we sit here and we endorse the project, we can stand confidently and put it part of our speech that we've seen the independent process through the whole thing. And that's what I wanted to achieve by it. Wording matters. The wording, the fact that we just got hung up on significant, is exactly why we should go through an independent review. Because wording, the word, can make a difference. It can be interpreted differently. I'm really happy to discuss offline what significant means, Mr. Mayor, because, yeah, you're right. It can be broad. Happy to make sure that it's not. But I do hope that you can understand why it got to this point today and support it. Thank you. Thank you, Councillor Phillips. Mayor Wilkie: I'll put the motion. Those in favour? Councillor Lorentson. Yes. Councillor Phillips, Wilson, Finzel and Wilkie. Those against?
02:55:00 Councillor Wegener, Councillor Stockwell. The motion is carried. Now, Councillors, would you like a break? Speaker 4: Yes. Yes, please. Mayor Wilkie: And adjournment. 15 minute adjournment. And we'll be back at 1.10. Thank you very much. Speaker 2: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
03:13:00 Mayor Wilkie: Welcome back everybody, we're now up to item 11, consideration of committee reports, 11.1.1, the CEO update as part of the audit and risk committee recommendations, 11.1.2, QIO, KPMG, 2025 audit committee written paper,
03:14:00 11.1.3, workplace health and safety annual report, 11.1.4, the Crow recruitment management audit final report, 11.1.5, briefing paper on outstanding ICT action items, 11.1.6, update on the review of outstanding action items, 11.1.7, draft annual rolling works plan and standing agenda item, 11.1.8, discussion to recommend new chair of audit and risk committee, 11.1.9, confidential fraud event and analysis, corrective actions and status update, 11.1.10, confidential public interest disclosure update, 11.1.11, audit and risk committee recommendations on block, and the moving seconder of the audit and risk committee recommendations dated 12 December 2025, Councillor Wegener as a committee member, and seconder Councillor Wilson. All in favour? That's carried. Yes. The audit and risk committee recommendations dated 9 January.
11.1 AUDIT & RISK COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS DATED 12 DECEMBER 2025 ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.1 CEO UPDATE ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.11 AUDIT & RISK COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS EN BLOC ¶
03:15:00 The audit and risk committee recommendations dated 9 January 2026, 11.2.1, QIO, KPMG, closing report, 11.2.2, 2024-25 annual financial statements, 11.2.3, Mr Shire Council annual report draft, 2024-25, annual point 2.4 audit and risk committee recommendations on block, and we have a mover and a seconder for those recommendations. All in favour? Thank you, Councillor Wilson, seconded by Councillor Lorentson. All in favour? That's carried. Yes. And we have the general committee recommendations, 11.3.1, endorsement of the Noosa Local Disaster Management Plan, 11.3.2, response to notice of motion, trial of remote rescue tube rings at uncontrolled beaches, 11.3.3, planning applications decided by delegated authority, November 2025, 11.3.4, procurement contracts assessment working team contracts award under CEO delegation, 11.3.5, financial performance report, December 2025, 11.3.5, financial performance report, December 2025, 11.3.5, financial performance report, December 2025, 11.
11.2.4 AUDIT & RISK COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS EN BLOC ¶
03:16:00 9.6, general committee recommendations on block. Moved and seconded by the general committee. Happy to be here. Thank you, Councillor Phillips, seconded by Councillor Finzel. All in favour? That's carried. We have no reports. Thank you, Councillor Wilson. No reports direct to the ordinary meeting. There is no confidential session. The next ordinary meeting will be at Council Chambers, 9 Fogden Street, Tewantin at 10am on 19 February 2026. Thank you, Councillor Wilson. I believe it's 3am in the UK. Thank you for being here today. 3.17. Speaker 2: Which is... Yes. Mayor Wilkie: And thank you, Councillor, for your contributions today. I declare the meeting closed at 1.17. Speaker 1: Thank you. Thank you, Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Councillor Finzel. Mayor Wilkie: Thanks, guys. Good meeting. Councillor Finzel: Yes.
11.3.6 GENERAL COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS EN BLOC ¶
Council's recording ends before this item. Where a meeting resolved to close its doors, that is what the end of the recording means — see what council discussed in private.
12 ORDINARY MEETING REPORTS ¶
Council's recording ends before this item. Where a meeting resolved to close its doors, that is what the end of the recording means — see what council discussed in private.
14 NEXT MEETING ¶
Council's recording ends before this item. Where a meeting resolved to close its doors, that is what the end of the recording means — see what council discussed in private.
15 MEETING CLOSURE ¶
Council's recording ends before this item. Where a meeting resolved to close its doors, that is what the end of the recording means — see what council discussed in private.