Before the first item ¶
00:00:00 Mayor Wilkie: I pay my respects to the elders past, present and emerging and also acknowledge their recognition of each and every one of us as joint custodians with a role in respecting and caring for this beautiful place that we all love and respecting and caring for each other. I note that all councillors are in attendance. Item 4 is confirmation of the minutes. Can I have a mover and a seconder for the minutes of the ordinary meeting held on the 15th of October 2026. Which meeting? I think it's councillor Lorentson, secretary councillor Nicola Wilson. All in favour? It's carried unanimously. We have one petition which I submit on their behalf. I move that the petition with 1098 signatories submitted by Joanne Hoey requesting that council oppose amendment 4 at 94 and 170 Holts Road, Cooroy be received and referred to the chief executive officer to do so. The message from this petition is to determine appropriate action. This has attracted huge interest outside the Shire, around Queensland, around the country and overseas.
3 ATTENDANCE & APOLOGIES ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
4 CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
4.1 CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES ORDINARY MEETING 15 OCTOBER 2026 ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
5 PETITIONS ¶
00:01:00 Submissions from Germany, Spain, UK, Hawaii, Argentina, South Africa, and Ireland. Mr. CEO, submit it to you if appropriate. All in favour? That's unanimous. There are no presentations. We have two deputations. The first is from Kay Thornton, Emma Scowan and Trevor Butlin. The topic is Dog Park in Cooroy. Would you like to come up to the lectern? And you have, we've got 15 minutes set aside for exclusively. Speaker 9: Thank you. Good morning, Mayor and councillors and council staff. We're here today on behalf of the people of Cooroy and surrounds to ask for a fit for purpose dog park.
7 DEPUTATIONS ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
7.1 DEPUTATION APPLICANT: KAY THORNTON TOPIC: DOG PARK FOR COOROY SPEAKER/S: KAY THORNTON, EMMA SCOWEN, TREVOR BUTLER ¶
00:02:00 In 2024, we presented a petition for such. At that time, it garnered about $600. Signatures. And since then, thanks to Kevin of Cooroy, we've got another 400 odd signatures asking for a fit for purpose dog park for our area. Now, we are very much aware that there is an area designated for off-league dog park, but it is totally unsuitable. That has been, it's not just us that says so. It is not you. The people in the surround say it's not used, it's not usable, it's not suitable for people with with access problems like Trevor and his and his wife with mobility issues. It's Bobby wet.
00:03:00 As someone said, if you've got a small dog, it had disappeared down the drain there and never to be seen again. It's close to busy roads. I could go on and on. Why? It's not suitable, so we're looking for an area that we could have a trial where we could see where we could have an off-league area where we could let our dogs off-league without being worried about being fined and with the idea that a permanent dog park that would attract people to the area to let their dogs off-league and socialize. Would be considered. Now, we've gone all around the area close to Cooroy and the only area we believe is suitable is the Pony Club. I don't know if council has looked at that as an area.
00:04:00 I understand that from my contacts that you were thinking of moving the Pony Club from Tewantin to Cooroy. Now, I'm an equestrian coach, was for 20 years, and I think that's a really bad idea because so much money is needed to be spent on that Pony Club to make it suitable for extra equestrian activities. That's my opinion. I think we're talking hundreds of thousands, but I think it's really suitable for a dog park. Well, parts of it. There's areas up the back that we could use. It's fenced to the front. There's not a lot of money that would need to be spent to get it up and running fairly quickly. So, I'm asking, has anyone looked at that prospect? Has anyone got any other ideas?
00:05:00 So, anyone got any comments on any of that? Mayor Wilkie: The deputation is your opportunity for us to listen, but after you've finished, Kay, you'll be off on your own. You'll have an opportunity to speak with staff and councillors. Speaker 9: Right. Okay. Well, I'd like Emma, perhaps, to come up and talk about how we see it going out. Thanks, Kay. Emma Skowin: Good morning, Mayor and councillors. Thank you for hearing from us today. I am Emma Skowin, and I'm here to ask council to work with us on a six-month trial of an off-league dog park on the council-owned land behind the Cooroy Boney Club. So, we've looked at council-owned land in Cooroy and believe this is the most suitable site for trial. The ground is flat. It's easy to get to, and there's parking nearby. Our dev rank here, Trevor, has mobility issues and has explained to us in depth that being able to park close by and get from your car to the park over level ground can make all the difference whether you can take your dog out or not.
00:06:00 The site is also close to the RV stopover, so people travelling with dogs would have somewhere nearby to give them a run. A park that's easy to get to could draw people from surrounding towns, too. If some of them stop for a coffee, grab lunch, or pick up a few extra things, that's extra trade for our local businesses as well. Our long-term goal is a securely fenced and gated off-league park with separate areas for small and large dogs. But the six-month trial would give council a chance to see how often people would use the site, how well it works for people with mobility aids, and what would need to be considered before investing in a permanent park. For the trial, we're asking for regular mowing and a bin that's emptied routinely so owners have somewhere to put their dog waste bags. Keeping the grass short makes the ground easier to navigate and gives people a better view of where they're walking, particularly when they're concerned about snakes.
00:07:00 We'd also like to work with council on clear signs so owners know where the off-league area begins and ends and what's expected of them. We'd welcome input from the pony club and nearby users so the trial works alongside their activities as well. Kay, Trevor and I are willing to form a dog park committee for the six months. We can help promote respectful use of the space, collect feedback and raise any issues with council early. We'd like to agree upfront on what a successful trial looks like. Are people coming to it regularly? Can people with walking aids get to and use the site comfortably? Is it working for the pony club and other neighbours? And at the end of six months, can we bring that feedback back to council? So, for some of you who don't know, I run the Kevin for Cooroy page, which has a large engaged following. Kevin has a regular column now in the Cooroy Rag.
00:08:00 And he's also been a guest on the ABC Sunshine Coast and 91.1 Hot FM. And recently been featured in the Courier Mail. He also has several more media appearances scheduled. So if the trial goes ahead, we can use that reach to get the word out. Encourage people to use the park respectfully and hear how it is working for them. A lot of people have been following the dog park campaign through Kev. And there's already plenty of interest in what comes next. The petitions that Kay spoke to earlier have shown that people want a better place to take their dogs. A trial would let council see how that can translate into day-to-day use. When people have a place they can actually get to. So our request today is that council assesses the land behind the pony club for a six-month off-league trial. And nominate someone we can work with on the site. The basic maintenance and how we'll measure their success. And Kay, Trevor and I are ready to help get it underway. Thank you.
00:09:00 Trevor Butler: Mr Mayor, Councillors, my name is Trevor Butler. My wife and I have been in Cooroy for over 13 years. Before that we were in Butterham for 33 years. It was a good move coming up here. But when we were in Butterham, our house was broken into. I asked the police what was the best way to protect against burglaries. And they said to get a dog. Now many people, many elderly people, I'm not elderly, I'm ancient. Many people have dogs. They are good for security but also dogs need exercise. I take my dog to Pomona virtually every day. Now when you're talking about biospheres and electric buses,
00:10:00 just recall I am using over 600 litres of fuel a year driving to Pomona with my dog. And I am just one person. There are a couple from out Lake Macdonald Way. There are others all around. And so part of the responsibility is to cut down on fuel use. And conservatively I'm using over 600 litres a year driving up there. Up there the council is to be congratulated on the park up there. It's an excellent park and I don't think we can get anything like it in Cooroy. But that's part of the way. Walking the dog originally when we got him around the roads here, we met a lot of people. We made a lot of friends.
00:11:00 Going to Pomona, we made a lot more friends up there. And so for social reasons a dog is a great thing. We met people who live not far from us. They've become good friends. Dogs need socialising as well. And they don't socialise by being kept at home all the time. And they only socialise to a degree walking them around the road. The other thing is we go to Pomona. My wife has a wheelie walker. Quite commonly she will say while we're here we'll duck over to the supermarket. All that business is being watched at Cooroy. We duck over to the baker. We get a coffee and sausage rolls for the dog.
00:12:00 The coffee shops down here. When I was walking him around the road, we used to see a lot of people with dogs at the coffee shops. Well, we don't walk around the road very often at all. But I don't see a lot of dogs at the coffee shops these days. In fact, three years or more ago, a lot of people, I used to walk my dog around and used to walk home across the sports grounds. A lot of people did that. There were a lot of dogs running off lead up there in those days. I know it was against the rules. It was never organised. It was sometimes you walked across and people would say, oh, what about getting the dog to run? But I got caught by the council. I've got no argument against that. No bad feelings at all. But since then, I've been going to Pomona. Now, a look at the park here.
00:13:00 My wife and I drove to every off lead park, except the beaches within the Shire. There are only three we considered suitable. Weaver Creek, Dorian Point, and Pomona. Dorian Point was right out of the way. Couldn't get much use at all. Weaver Creek is quite good. And I'd say gets a lot of use. We're used to it a few times. Pomona is really excellent. But Kay and I went looking for suitable places. The Pony Club, is about the only place we can see that's really suitable. The sports grounds, I don't think there'll be too many objections. A lot of them are unreasonable.
00:14:00 But however, they do get a lot of use. The Pony Club doesn't appear to get much use. And the area at the back and on the western side doesn't seem to get any use at all. And that's the areas that we think we could use. Right? With very little cost. And that's, I realise, is very important to the Council. Is to minimise the costs. And so that is our proposition. That there's parking there. I don't know who pays for the mowing on the Pony Club. But some of these areas don't get mowed. Mine in Frequent. I don't know who pays for the mowing on the Pony Club. And so we think the Council should look at that. There's an awful lot of people who we, I'm sure, once it gets known, will use it.
00:15:00 Thank you very much. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Senator. Thank you, Emma. Thank you, Kai. Trevor Butler: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Speaker 1: Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: For a deputation, it is Rod Lees and Tim Scott on the subject of glyphosate and weed management. So Rod and Tim, would you like to come up to the lectern? Speaker 6: Good morning, Mayor and Councillors. First of all, I'd like to thank you for what you do, both councillors and staff. It's a very difficult job that you do and you're kind of on a hiding for nothing. You can get hit in all different directions and I'm about to hit you with another one. Next month I turn 81, though I try not to dwell on it.
7.2 DEPUTATION APPLICANT: ROD LEES TOPIC: GLYPHOSATE AND ROADSIDE WEED MANAGEMENT IN NOOSA SHIRE SPEAKER/S: ROD LEES, TIM SCOTT ¶
00:16:00 Every day I promise myself that in the unknown period I have left on this planet I should stop worrying about things so much and spend more time travelling, more time with family and friends, eating good clean food, swimming in the ocean and riding my bike down the coast and through our amazing hinterland. This morning we nearly collected three kangaroos, or actually three kangaroos nearly collected me, so I'm here to tell the tale. And then I see a utility driver down our street in the canals in Noosa waters with a big tank on the back marked glyphosate, at least it's got the markings on it. The driver is leaning out the window with a spray wand, constantly streaming glyphosate in the gutters. While he had a long-sleeved shirt on, he had no gloves, no glasses and no breathing protection. I then see other council workers in the community, and I've noted them in Thomas Street and Gibson Road. Amongst all our residents. Residents are there, sprayers are there. The residents have no idea what's going on. The workers are armed with a knapsack, spraying glyphosate everywhere, waving the wand about
00:17:00 in a manner that seemed to lack due care and attention. This time, short-sleeved shirt and shorts, no masks, no proper eye protection. While the level of protection required varies depending upon the safety data sheet, that's different safety data sheet for each particular product amongst the thousands of varieties, the bare minimum requirement for spraying glyphosate in Queensland from WorkSafe Queensland is follows. Chemical resistant gloves, protective clothing, masks, most likely, eye protection and protective footwear. WorkSafe Queensland is particularly concerned about skin contact, breathing and vapor from spray mist and accidental ingestion through poor hand hygiene. Some councils in Australia go beyond the minimum for safety, even though the STS may not require it. As an example, my wife and I, my lovely wife Karen there, and I were recently doing a hike around Uluru, one of Australia's most major tourist attractions.
00:18:00 We came across a warning sign that said, spraying in progress, take care. We found the workers down the track who were all dressed up like they were about to land on the moon. They were spraying glyphosate to get rid of buffel frost. So for both my mental and physical health, I go for a ride in the hinterland and I see the result of what appears to be random rampant spraying that has no pattern except for a concentration in the gullies and the waterways. That's where the spraying is going, in the gullies and the waterways. Most advice on location spraying clearly states that these areas should be avoided. I surmise that they do this as it may be difficult to mow. It appears from my limited knowledge that they may just be spraying grass that has been planned to stop the erosion. What is left is bare earth that gets washed away along with the residual spray during the next rain event and it all ends up in our waterways increasing sedimentation and polluting our rivers.
00:19:00 We know that from the three year local study, that was a local study, concluded in 2023, that glyphosate remains in the soil for at least 12 months and it kills the soil microbes in the process. Apart from the plants, it is the soil microbes that hold the soil together and gives it life. Now the debate on whether glyphosate causes cancer or not is ongoing and with only 15 minutes we do not have time to talk about the latest research. However, any evidence that is contrary to the position of the multinational chemical companies is an immediate attack. In addition, these same chemical companies have infiltrated our universities, research centres, schools, agricultural conferences and land care. They've even donated some roundup to a recent land care tree planting program. You know, I find that free planting and then glyphosate, I have difficulty with that. My background is in irrigation and health and I'm extremely concerned about our environment
00:20:00 and the survival of our planet. So it's very easy to get depressed about what is happening in our neighbourhood and beyond. So for inspiration, Karen and I, we go to visit our farming friends who we've met through Slow Food Nurser. They are all either certified organic or at least certified organic. And they say that glyphosate is a chemical spray free. I ran into two of them on Sunday and I said we were doing this deputation but I was getting cold feet and I thought I'd pull the pin. And they said, oh no, don't do that. We've got to have somebody get up and talk about this stuff. So here we are. This chemical spray farming successfully. This is what happens on all farms prior to the place of all growth. So the chemical industry will replace the bombs and the gas with chemical fertilisers and pesticides along with the growth of industrial agriculture. So at this point, I'd like to introduce you to Tim Scott.
00:21:00 He's one of the farmers we visit. Tim is from Kandanga Certified Organic Farm and Store and he's here to tell you part of his story. Now, while Kandanga is not in the Noosa Shire, the situations and experiences are the same. Tim knows more about this whole area than anyone else I know and he's been fighting the battle for over 10 years. My only concern is I've given Tim five minutes and he could take five days. Anyway, Tim. And then I'll come back and finish up. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. Speaker 8: Thanks. Thanks for the opportunity and thanks, Rob, for organising it. There are solutions out there, but it takes a complete mind shift and we don't have time to explain all those steps in doing that. Today, I guess the only thing we really have time for is a certified organic farmer and a resident in this area. We have lots of customers over in this area. We are the only shop in the country that doesn't sell synthetic chemicals and synthetic
00:22:00 fertilising chemicals. And that's a massive financial problem to us. And this is how this industry developed is that about 50% of the revenue of most of these rural shops comes just from one product, just from LifeSafe. So it's a massive ingrained part of our system and that's why you're seeing it pushed to you guys to use everywhere. It's causing more problems, though, than sort of what is in the media. So I guess the only thing I can really talk about quickly is reverse onus and this is a topic that came up, you know, we did a day the other day to try to help Vicky with how we get food into Noosa and do distribution here. And this reverse onus topic, I've never really heard it before. I heard it again with a deputation through the Senate inquiry into Paraquat the other day. And that's how the APBMA is operating now, too. Once a product is approved, there's an onus then on everyone else to prove that there's something wrong with it, rather than proving the companies that sell it to prove it's safe.
00:23:00 So we get this a lot in the organic world because we have a certified organic farms. The onus is on us then to tell everyone, don't spray our area. And it's as if there's an underlying, I don't know, mentality that everyone wants to be sprayed. It's just the weird people that have to sign a chemical free register or whatever you call yours here, intolerance register or something, some crazy name. And so what if that onus is switched around? And what if you had to sign up to be sprayed? So where we are, we have to put up these signs saying don't spray, you know, stopping us from spraying this area. I don't know why we can't use GPS like every other spray contractor in the world, but we have to put up signs. So what if it was the other way around and everyone had to put up a sign saying, you know, spray my area? Does that change the view? Do people travelling to this area have a preconception that it's a biosphere area and it's clean
00:24:00 and green? So what if we started to get people that actually want to have their roadsides maintaining this way? Show everyone. It turns it around completely. This reverse onus thing is something that's going to cause a liability issue, I believe, for councils across the country, because at the moment they're relying a lot on the assumption that everything they're being told for the APVMA is correct and their residents want to have chemical exposure. And I don't think any resident would sign up to that if they had to sign a spray reg and just say, please spray them. So it's just a different way of thinking about it. And there are alternatives and we've run trials on this over the years. We continue to run trials, but most of it is around setting the context. Why do you have to spray the side of the road when there's a road sign that tall? Why is the sprayer on the bottom of it? It's not a visual issue. So this goes back to main roads and there's all sorts of, we can go through that too. But if my wife has just got a chemical residue, we've been organic diet for 40 years, she's
00:25:00 got that report back to say she's four times over the legal limit and that's causing her an issue. So she can't really work in a business anymore and I don't, she's, I don't know how many people have actually gone and got a biopsy test ever, but when you end up in hospital, that's the sort of stuff you do. So how many people are on that spectrum leading up to that point? And then what do we do? We've got a business that we can't run. So the liability lies somewhere. The closest sprayer we have is Council, it's 100 metres to the end of our driveway. There's a million ways to solve these problems though, isn't there boys and girls? Mayor Wilkie: Thank you Tim. Thank you. Speaker 6: Thanks Tim. We've probably got about five minutes left, so I need to get to the point of all this. Here are some suggestions, one Tim's already made, which is instead of, don't spray, spray anything.
00:26:00 And I was talking to one of the organic farmers in the area the other day and he said, I have to pay $1,700 every year to let people know that I'm spray free and everyone else doesn't have to pay anything, it's crazy. So some issues, is the amount of chemical spraying taking place in our community really necessary? Is it being applied appropriately and are there better alternatives? If you're going to spray glyphosate in Noosa, do you have a responsibility to warn the residents? It's a legislative requirement in a lot of other parts of Australia. Ensure that your workers are adequately protected and maybe, given Tim's experience with his glyphamba that's four times over the limit, maybe you should test the glyphosate levels in the staff who are spraying what appears to me unprotected to see how they rate. The chemical sensitivity. The chemical sensitivity register that Tim mentioned, that's the Do Not Spray register, and it's touted
00:27:00 in the Nurses Council staff document that was recently given to you as councillors. The problem is it's a secret. No one knows about it. I had difficulty actually registering. And when my first phone call said that they don't know anything about it, eventually I got registered. And then I had a call from a councillor staff member who drove down our street and he said, well, you're going to have difficulties. You've got pavers in there. All that grass that's grown up in between the pavers, even though you're on the Do Not Spray register, if there's grass there, we'll spray it. So I have a fellow that does our yard every fortnight. He comes and he's out on the road with his whippersnapper spraying through the pavers so that we don't have any stuff coming up. It takes him five minutes. It's not a big deal. Examine the implications of the current spraying levels with your desire to promote regenerative agriculture, which is part of the Nurses Plan. I know Tom's heavily involved in that.
00:28:00 And also, promote the Nurses Plan in our community and improve the quality of our soils, which is part of the recent LGAQ conference motion that I know you took to Cairns and you got it through. So you want to improve the health of the soils within Noosa. It's a contradiction of terms to talk about healthy soils and regenerative agriculture if you're going to spray it. It just doesn't... They just don't go together. Other implications for the renewal of the Noosa Biosphere. I know in talking to biosphere staff, they're concerned. Develop a plan to reduce the amount of spraying in our community and advertise what you're doing. You have the opportunity under the 2026 Biosecurity Plan. Examine again the many alternatives that are available. Tim's got a whole lot of stuff there and that have now been adopted. There are at least 13 LGAs in Australia and it took a very quick AI search for me to come
00:29:00 up with those 13. This is not one of them. They have some alternatives to what the current spraying level is. They don't... They haven't eliminated glyphosate. There's some councils tried to eliminate, then they've come back on it, but they have a plan. They have a... They have something that's there that says, this is what we're going to do. Have a look at what Europe is doing. Germany has largely eliminated glyphosate spraying due to... And they've actually measured it as 75% reduction in insect populations. I said to Amelia the other day, when you go for a drive at night in your car and you come home, do you have the insects on your car that we used to have? No, we don't. They're just not there. Why is that? Because there are insects that are disappearing and so are bees. The last time I sprayed in our yard, I sprayed with some weed and feed. I was into everything's got to look good and our grass was the best in the street.
00:30:00 And then I got some clover and I thought, oh, I better get rid of this clover. It doesn't... It's not right there. So I sprayed it with weed and feed that I got from Bunnings. And the next day I saw the bees feeding on the clover. And I was calling out, don't eat that, don't eat that. Now we've got clover on our front yard and we're the only one on the street that I'm proud of. Transporting main roads. This is a big issue because a lot of the responsibility for spraying in this community is transporting our own main roads. And I think they're the ones that I see out in the community when I go from the bike ride and they're spraying in the gullies. Now, somehow we've got to talk with them and say, I got finished? Trevor Butler: No, that's 15. That's 15. Speaker 6: Okay. In the end, I imagine from your perspective, it all comes down to cost and efficiency. You have to balance the budget and you have to fulfil your biosecurity requirements. The council staff briefing highlights this along with the continued referral to APVMA.
00:31:00 I won't go into APVMA, but they, 90% of their budget comes from the industry that they regulate. So you've got to question that. So what's the long-term cost? The first court case for negligence, the overall health of the community, the clean green image of Noosan Shire Council, the damage to our soils and waterways, and the loss of bees and other healthful insects. I'm about to finish. One last thought. Possibly the ugliest part of the Noosa roadsides right now are the traffic islands that have been filled with concrete and has multiple dead weeds standing straight in every crack and cranny. Just have a look at the areas between the two roundabouts joining Hilton Terrace and Gibson Road and you'll see what I mean. So you've got traffic islands and all these dead things sticking up. Why don't we? We, I say we, when budget allows, dig up the concrete, replace it with some soil, mulch,
00:32:00 and plant some ground cover for the flowers. It will keep the so-called weeds at bay from the community and the bees will love you poorer. Thank you very much. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Mr Lees. Thank you. We have one public question time application. The application is from Mr Vincent Lombard. Good morning. Welcome, Mr Lombard. And your questions will be answered by the Acting Director of Community Services, Alison Campbell. You have the floor, sir. Vincent Lombard: Good morning, Chair, Mayor, CEO, councillors, and councillors. My name is Vincent Lombard. I would just like to take a few seconds to introduce myself because nobody knows me. My name is Vincent Lombard. I am 71 years old. Retired and a Noosa resident for more than 10 years. I am married. In fact, tomorrow will be my 50th greeting anniversary.
8 PUBLIC QUESTION TIME ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
8.1 VINCENT LOMBARD ¶
00:33:00 We have two children, six grandkids, and the eldest two studying at the university. I am a parishioner at St. Andrews, Anglican Church, Sunshine Beach, and serving on the committee, which raises funds to support chaplaincy at the Sunshine Beach State School. I am a volunteer at the University of St. Andrews. I have worked here in Noosa for five years. I am a member of the Lombard Gulf Sunshine Coast, captain in 2022. Over 10 years, our club raised and donated $300,000 to organisations helping persons in hardships and in hunger problems. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Mr Mayor, we have to keep with our standing orders, and there is no ability for a speaker to a question. They have to have only the question while I understand. Vincent Lombard: I can learn. I thought you don't know me, I'm a resident, but it's wonderful to meet you. So now I'm moving forward to the associated background material, and I'm speaking today as a local resident.
00:34:00 I am a senior member, or senior resident, of Noosa, who regularly uses the Noosa Leisure Centre for sport and recreation. Many seniors, particularly those aged 55 and over, regularly use the facility for physical activity, social connection, and maintaining their health and well-being. During hotter periods of the year, temperatures inside the centre can become extremely uncomfortable, and at times unbearable for participants and spectators alike. My two questions are, one, given the importance... ...of the Noosa Leisure Centre facility to the local community, will Council consider installing air conditioning as part of any future works, or upgrades to the Noosa Leisure Centre? Second question, please. Mayor Wilkie: We'll get an answer to your first question first, Mr. Lombard, if that's alright.
00:35:00 Director, Acting Director. Yes, yes, maybe. Speaker 2: Come up to the table, Lord. Mayor Wilkie: Sure. Speaker 2: So, lovely to meet you, Vincent, and welcome, thank you, so Council recognises the important role the Noosa Leisure Centre plays in providing sport, recreation, and physical activity opportunities for the local community, and acknowledges that indoor temperatures during the warmer months can impact the comfort and experience of facility users. The installation of air conditioning has previously been considered as a potential future improvement, however, it's currently not identified as a priority project. This may be revisited as part of Council's future asset management planning for the facility. Mayor Wilkie: Okay, the second question now. Vincent Lombard: The second question is, if it was not going to be considered, why not? Sure. Speaker 2: This project is currently not identified as a priority project, which I have mentioned.
00:36:00 Significant capital investment required to install and operate a refrigerated air conditioning system represents a considerable financial challenge, particularly when balanced against other competing infrastructure and facility priorities. Okay. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. We'll catch up with you on the break. Okay, thank you. If you'd like to have some more of your questions answered in a conversational setting. Yes, thank you very much. Okay, so thank you to the deputations. We'll have an adjournment for 15 minutes now, so you get to meet dog park deputies, meet with Director Richard MacGillivray, who can help you, Mr. Leaves, and Tom, Tim, our Acting Director of, sorry, our Director of Environment and Strategy, Kim Rawlings can help you as well. Speaker 1: And we'll be, we'll reconvene in 15 minutes.
00:54:00 Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: Welcome back, everyone. We're up to item nine. There are no more minutes. We have one notified motion from Councillor Larison, a review of annual kerbside collection. Councillor Larison, would you like to move your motion? Can we have a seconder? Councillor Lorentson: Thank you. I'd like to move that the council request the CEO provide a report to the The April 2027 Council meeting now, formally responding to a portion of the community's request for reinstatement of annual curbside bulk waste collection, including Council's current position, true possibly current approach, reinstatement options, alternatives, and a recommended pathway forward.
9 MAYORAL MINUTES ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
10 NOTIFIED MOTIONS ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
10.1 REVIEW OF ANNUAL KERBSIDE COLLECTION ¶
00:55:00 Happy to second. Mayor Wilkie: Seconded by Councillor Lomson. Councillor Lorentson: Thank you. Mayor, this issue is important to our community, and that's why I brought this motion forward. In 2020, Council suspended the curbside bulk waste collection as a temporary COVID-19 measure. What began as temporary has quietly become permanent without a clear decision about the future. Many residents remember that one of the arguments for de-amalgamation in 2013 was that Noosa Shire would continue to provide an annual curbside collection, so it's not surprising people still feel strongly about it. A portion of our community has consistently asked for the service to be reinstated. Bulk waste collection was one of the top 10 issues raised in a consultation for Council's 2023 waste plan.
00:56:00 That same consultation also found that the community's highest waste priorities were removing litter from our oceans and waterways and promoting personal responsibility. I want to acknowledge the work Council and our community have done here. Noosa has made real progress in reducing landfill and increasing recycling. That success belongs to our staff and to the many residents who have changed how they manage waste. We should be proud of it and protect it. So there are two sides to this. Some residents want curbside collection back, but our community has also set its top priorities as a priority. Some residents are reducing litter and encouraging people to take responsibility for their own waste. We need to weigh both. To some residents, this isn't a small issue. Noosa has an older community. At the last census, 27.9% of the population were aged 65 or over, well above the Queensland average of 17%.
00:57:00 Not everyone has a ute, a trailer or a family need vital help. And with the cost of living pressures, paying to remove a mattress or an old fridge isn't easy for everyone. Other councils have found different answers. Brisbane provides free annual collection in every suburb. Gold Coast offers one free flexi-skip per eligible household each year through a booking system. Townsville offers a choice of one free curbside collection or two free small low-tip vouchers. And Northern Bay discontinued its curbside selection service. A booking system, a needs-based service or tip vouchers are all worth looking at. Equally, the review may find our current approach remains the best option for Noosa. The aim is to understand all the options, including the status quo, before we decide. That's why this motion asks the CEO for a report to the April 2027 Council meeting round, formally responding to the community's request for reinstatement.
00:58:00 The report would include Council's current position, the true costs of the current approach, reinstatement options, alternatives and a recommended pathway forward. I'd like to thank the staff who met with me with this motion over the last probably six months. The report, and I do want to stress this, the report doesn't bring you to any decision. And supporting this motion doesn't mean choosing a side. It just means choosing to listen, getting the facts and giving our community a clear answer to a question that we actually never answered six years ago. So I ask that, I'm going to add that when people see a decision and understand the information, and when they can see that a decision was made fairly and openly, they're far more likely to accept it, even if it's not the one they wanted.
00:59:00 So again, this is the purpose of the motion to basically get the information, to listen and to give our residents a clear evidence-based answer. So I ask that you support the motion in front of us. Thank you, Councillor Anderson. Mayor Wilkie: Who else wants to speak to the motion? Councillor Lorentson: Councillor Wilson. Councillor Wilson: Council has a clear position on kerbside collection, diversion targets and landfill management in Council's Waste Plan 2023-28 from Waste to Resource. This plan begins with a message from then Mayor Clare Stewart, and I'll quote some key points. Feedback from our community showed overwhelming support for the waste hierarchy principles that encourage avoidance of waste in the first place. Reuse, recycling, the use of waste to make energy, with landfill as a last resort. You also told us you felt strongly that we must all take personal responsibility.
01:00:00 for minimising waste, along with advocating to reduce waste at the source, and this will be an important ingredient in the success of this plan. The plan also gave statistics of the 2019-20 kerbside collections, a cost of half a million dollars, 850 tonnes sent to landfill, 27,000 kilometres travelled, and only one in five residents using the service that everyone paid for. The financial cost per rate payer might not be that high, but it encourages residents to make their waste Council's problem, which leaves no incentive to minimise waste at the source. And this comes from the waste strategy. The service may appear convenient, but in addition to the cost, it contributes to substantial amounts of recyclable materials, such as wood, metal, cardboard, e-waste, etc. ending up in landfill due to the complexities and expenses involved in sorting the waste collected in bulk kerbside collections.
01:01:00 850 tonnes sent to landfill, with very little of that being able to be diverted to recycling. Of particular concern is the improper disposal of hazardous materials like asbestos, batteries and chemicals, as well as the risk of litter and microplastics finding its way into our ocean and river through stormwater systems. Our pavements and grass verges are not the place for dangerous waste. For those without suitable vehicles or the strength to lift large items, Council has established a directory of 10 local service providers who collect large household items and transport them to landfill or to recycling. These service providers will make sure that waste is sorted, deposited at the appropriate areas of the facility and recycled where possible. Note many household items can be disposed of for free, such as e-waste, steel, paint and chemicals, white goods and polystyrene. Fees apply for mattresses, concrete and timber. But a small load with a car is $15.
01:02:00 The Waste Plan identifies personal responsibility as a critical aspect. This involves taking ownership of items that are no longer needed and being mindful of unnecessary consumption. This approach is in line with the Waste Reduction and Recycling Act 2011 and Queensland Waste Strategy Less Landfill, More Recycling by 2035. As custodians of our Shire, we all need to be personally responsible for waste. Every time we consider buying new furniture, household items, sports items, clothes or internet bargains, we need to also consider the cost to dispose of them. That shouldn't be left to Council. It's a personal decision and needs to be part of the purchasing budget. Got money to buy new stuff? First consider whether you also have money to dispose of the old stuff. Why does it need to be thrown on the street for Council to pick up? Some will argue that goods on the street get picked up by others, like a free market store. But there are multiple ways to dispose of items in good condition without putting them out on the street.
01:03:00 Charities, Facebook Marketplace, the Reviver Store, Office to Friends, responding to requests and community pages. Many local op shops also provide a collection service for larger household items if they're in good condition and can be sold at their shop or passed on to clients. Council's customer service can also provide advice on specific things. I've moved house a few times, more than I'd like to remember, in recent years. So I've had plenty of clear outs adapting to new spaces and combining two households into one. And generally, I don't have the vehicles or the strength to take much to landfill myself. So first I sell or give away what I can. The benefit here is people come at an arranged time to pick things up from your home and not from the street. Then, once there is a pile of rubbish that's of no use to others, I know I'll need at least about $100 or $150 put aside for someone to take my waste away. But that also gives work to someone in the community. Why should other ratepayers pay for that? It's my waste, my responsibility.
01:04:00 Nationally, we have a society addicted to convenience and disposable buying. People buy cheap plastic stuff online for one party or event, and then it gets thrown in the bin. Decorations, costumes, props, inflatables, cheap clothes that don't last and the op shops can't sell. If Council keeps offering free curbside collections, we're not going to change behaviour. If these things end up piled on our pavements and grass verges, in the rain, waiting for pick up, all those microplastics end up in our stormwater systems and eventually our waterways. We want to encourage people to minimise waste going to landfill, not loading up the street with their poor purchasing decisions. Of course, sadly, things do break or lose appeal, but we can still be responsible without the need for curbside collection. The big takeaway for me, and I had this confirmed by our waste manager, waste collected from curbside collections will not be recycled and can cause environmental damage and safety risks. I support the concept of personal responsibility, as outlined in our waste strategy,
01:05:00 and don't believe we need further work to determine this. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Wilson. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: I'll speak to the motion. I can't support the motion. And fundamentally, that's because it's based on a version of history that's incorrect and the premise that, as I quote, quietly became permanent without a decision The waste plan overtly considered the issue. We had several workshops as councils. We had questions directed to the public. The waste plan made the decision. The waste plan clearly articulates that it's not council's policy to have bulk curbside collection. To suggest anything else is misleading this chamber. The waste plan is really clear that what we want to do is achieve consistency in the Sunshine Coast region
01:06:00 in disposal of bulky items by connecting the community with accredited platforms and organisations specialising in recycling of secondhand goods, unwanted item collection and sustainable disposal, develop a central resource detailing service providers to assist with bulky item collection. This wasn't something that was slowly brought in by stealth. Yes, initially it was around the public health hazards around as one of the issues around the COVID. But it wasn't just COVID related. We had one site that had cost tens of thousands of dollars to clean up because asbestos was in it. We had other sites that had tens of tonnes being dropped in from residents from outside the Shire. We had many waste facilities propping up that if we'd applied for them, we'd never get approval under environmental legislation. We had issues with biohazards.
01:07:00 And we were exposing our contractor staff to unacceptable workplace health and safety issues. It was a decision made based on both the risks and also the driving force behind our waste plan, which is, as was a high priority of the community identified by Councillor Lorentson, for people to take their personal responsibility for their own waste. It's really important that we're thinking about the costs to our ratepayers in the current cost of living. It's really important to understand that the dollar figures of around a half a million dollars are seven years out of date. Since then, the waste levy has gone through the roof. We would unlikely be able to do this if we could find a contractor willing to expose their staff to the risks for under a million dollars. And that's a million dollars for 20% of ratepayers. So that means 80% of the ratepayers would be getting a rate rise that they see no benefit from.
01:08:00 And if you think about it, the people who may be buying a new fridge and wanting to get a free service are not likely the ones that are struggling with the cost of living. If we're struggling ratepayers at the moment, they're unlikely to be generating a whole lot more waste. And they will, as Councillor Wilson was saying, take into mind what it might cost them as a whole. And it is important that this is part of the behaviour change program to understand. And it's not just the individuals buying. It also sends a signal to the market that those selling also have to recognise the whole of life implications of the product they're selling to make sure, where possible, that they're recyclable or reusable. And we've also seen since that time the large rise in the use of facilities like Marketplace. And I, like everyone else, used to walk around locally when I'd walk my dog and pick up something here and there
01:09:00 when there was kerbside. And I understand. But that's largely gone by the wayside now because people just put it up on Marketplace. So I can't support a motion that's asking staff to re-persecute a very detailed analysis of this issue that went, that straddled multiple years. It wasn't a short process. It straddled multiple years where we're continually briefed, looked at the issues and to put this up at a time when we're now got staff absolutely at the peak time for our waste contract. When we've got huge projects that require the attention to do something that tries to reopen an investigation that is to look at something that's contrary to our current strategy, to me is unacceptable. Councillor Lorentson: A question to staff. So just listening to Councillor Stockwell. So the waste plan, and I don't disregard the waste plan. Question to staff, it was kerbside collection was identified in the top 10 of concerns by residents.
01:10:00 My question is, given that it was listed in the top 10 of concerns by residents, was the formal cost benefit analysis undertaken, comparing bulk kerbside collection with alternative arrangements, for example, a booking system or a needs process or tip vouchers, and given the level of community feedback requesting bulk kerbside collection, again, top 10 of the concerns in the waste plan. Why did Council decide not to support its reinstatement? And more, did the individual submissions or responses, did Council investigate that further? Point of order? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Yes, it was a question, a debate in the form of a question.
01:11:00 Councillor Lorentson: Yes. Apologies and their questions, Bill. I need to say that respectfully to you. Good. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Speaker 5: Through the Chair, councillor. I think for me, the conversation is around, you know, what are the systems and mechanism of a bail of support residents with the management of their waste? I try not to focus on the conversation around kerbside bulk residential collection because that is a name and as a historical practice. You know, what the waste team has done through the preparation of waste management strategy So the main objective for us is to look at what are the mechanisms and tools that are available to our community, including our waste collection system to support and facilitate the management of waste within the council area. The use of kerbside collection is a historical approach. It has been outlined here on the floor that there are a number of available mechanisms that our community can draw upon.
01:12:00 A number of those mechanisms have become available as we have matured as a region with a number of commercial opportunities now in play. Skip bins, skip bags, flexi bags, the number of local providers that are available. The waste management strategy is very clear in that we are in a model of fee for service. So the user pays for the management of their waste and the approach that we have in place through our waste management strategy takes us down that path. And so from the perspective of a curbside collection process, it is inconsistent with the waste strategy. It is inconsistent with the approach and the outcomes that are sought through the waste management strategy, which is seeking to reduce waste to landfill. It is seeking to maximise the recovery of waste and put that towards reuse and a commercial outcome and gain.
01:13:00 It's seeking to maximise the life and opportunity for our landfill to be extended. It's very correct that any bulk of curbside collection process will send all waste to landfill. And no curbside collection process will come free of charge. Yeah, there is a cost. To the management of our waste. And there will be a significant cost to the management of our waste through a curbside collection process for a small proportion of our community. And there are a number of alternatives that are available and the waste management strategy and the waste team are focused on supporting and making aware to the community the available opportunities. More than happy if conversation around the table requires us or asks us to do so to run the numbers. On all of the options that are available to us, options that are in place through local councils throughout South East Queensland, and all of those options are pretty much been raised in the conversation that's already playing out today.
01:14:00 So that work is able to be done and can be done. It will, I expect, deliver a very similar answer to what's been discussed around the table at the moment. Councillor Lorentson: Thank you. Just a further question. And I'm not sure who to direct this with, but my understanding was our, how do you say, 2023 community consultation report recorded something like 15% of open-ended comments that requested the return of a bulk curbside collection, with residents explicitly asking for the annual hard rubbish collection to be reinstated. Point of order. What was the question? My question is... Deputy Mayor Stockwell: No, point of order. Point of order. Excuse me. Councillor Lorentson: The Chair... Deputy Mayor Stockwell: I haven't... Councillor Lorentson: The Chair manages... Deputy Mayor Stockwell: I haven't... I haven't... I haven't raised the point of order.
01:15:00 I haven't... Councillor Lorentson: I haven't raised the point of order. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: I haven't raised the point of order. I haven't raised the point of order. In this chamber, I believe that there should be a clear direction not to ask questions you know the answer to. Councillor Lorentson: Through the Chair, I take offense to what Councillor Stockwell has just said. He's making assumptions. I don't know the answer because the 50% of open-ended questions that were asked in the survey, I can't find it in the waste plan. My question is, were they reflected in the waste plan? Speaker 5: Through the Chair, Councillor, that's a question I'll have to take on notice. I wasn't here at the time that that survey was undertaken, so I'm more than happy to look into the results of that and to ask the question about how it was considered in the waste plan itself.
01:16:00 Mayor Wilkie: Possibly. At the heart of this notified motion, I think, is a request for more communication with our community. So I'll address that. But I think it would be helpful and far less resource-intensive if a frequently asked questions information sheet, perhaps, could be compiled to assist any councillors with any inquiries they may receive, rather than requiring staff to generate a full report to a future council meeting via a notified motion on an issue that council has already had a clear direction on. It's already, the information's already on the council's website as to our position on bulk kerbside collection. And it's in the Waste Resource Plan, which was unanimously endorsed in 2023. It has a list of alternative on-demand services that Councillor Wilson mentioned. Basically, using our neighbourhood as rubbish dumps is no longer considered environmentally or financially responsible
01:17:00 and does not divert waste from landfill. Noosa Council no longer supports bulk kerbside collection as this doesn't reflect the change. Community, community thinking captured in the consultation that we all must take more personal responsibility to the waste we each generate. The top priority for residents in the Waste Strategy and captured in many other plans was listed as protecting our environment, waterways, and oceans from litter. We all know that bulk footpath rubbish dumping allows contaminants such as asbestos, paint, litter, dangerous chemicals, and microplastics to be washed and blown about into the stormwater and into our creeks, river, and the sea. Knowing what we know about stormwater runoff and our commitment to protect waterways through actions such as the Burgess Creek Cash Management Plan, which we are endorsing today, we cannot willingly leave rubbish on our streets anymore. We no longer use our footpaths as trash tips because it's also very expensive for ratepayers. $500,000 was the cost many years ago. You wouldn't get much change from $1 million now, that's just an estimate, and yet it was found to be only used by 1 in 5 households.
01:18:00 We know that too many valuable resources ended up buried, around 850 tonnes were sent to landfill, including materials that could have been reused or recycled. With most waste being unsorted and going to landfill, and not only wasted resources, it increased the cost burden on ratepayers. The objective is to minimise the waste going to landfill, and therefore the waste levy paid to the State Government for every cubic metre tonne of waste buried. The practice was popular because it was easy. So easy, it also attracted dumping from residents who lived outside the Shire, who would travel into Noosa to discard their trash. Noosa's last annual collection was also resource intensive, requiring 4,000 staff hours and 27,000 kilometres of truck travel. Modern waste management is based on the waste hierarchy, as mentioned by councillors. Today's focus is on a circular economy.
01:19:00 Noosa is just one of many councils around the country no longer turning streets into temporary rubbish dumps, and instead providing on-demand services where users pay us. Modern communities are recovering more resources, better protected, and more affordable. The aim of the council is to ensure that the council is responsible for the environment and spending ratepay and money on waste-to-resource practices that are financially, environmentally and socially responsible. I respect that inquiries that some councils may be receiving for a well-thought-out response is genuine. So perhaps, instead of a full report from council, a frequently asked questions information sheet could be compiled to assist any councillors with any inquiries they may receive, explaining the reasons why, the costs, the burdens, the benefits, and the decision-making process that got us here. Council Phillips. Councillor Phillips: Thank you. During the election, I had so many people ask about this, and it was one of the commitments that I made to my community that I would investigate the re-introduction of the kerbside collection.
01:20:00 I still get asked probably weekly about it. So, as you all know, I grew up in the Shire, and I've lived through the generation where kerbside collection was something that council provided. I remember it, my family used it, my friends used it, and I always thought it was a really important service for our community. So, when I made the commitment to understand why it stopped, and I spent a long time with the waste manager over the last couple of years, hours of conversations, and to land at a point where I have completely changed my position, I've also changed my family's behaviour towards waste collection. I may not quite have changed my husband's. My change in my position is not because I don't believe in supporting residents,
01:21:00 but I've come to understand much more about the costs and the challenges, and importantly, the opportunity we have to do things differently. Recently, leading into Christmas, I asked my two daughters what they got for Christmas last year, and neither of them could remember. But they did remember where we were on Christmas Day, and the memories that were made in that moment. So, there was something really special in that. We do live in a world where we're constantly encouraged to buy more, consume more, and replace more. But perhaps we don't spend enough time thinking about where it all ends up. We talk a lot about sustainability, recycling, promoting plastic-free Noosa, and protecting what makes this Shire so special. Our commitment to sustainability has to extend beyond what we consume, to what we throw away. As I said, I've also had extensive conversations with our Infrastructure Director and our Waste Manager about improving our waste education and our communication. I do believe we can improve on that.
01:22:00 I think that we could spend more money on our facilities and our infrastructure, our landfill, because I genuinely believe that this is now one of the most important areas of work for the Council. We need to reinvest more of our waste management, our waste collection, and our waste collection. We need to support circular economies and reduce the long-term financial environmental legacy of landfills. We need to support circular economies and reduce the long-term financial environmental legacy of landfills. This motion is actually perfect time because right now, as we drove past my house, my brother's trailer is sitting out the front. Last weekend, we went through the garage and the girls' bedrooms, and we are about to take a load off to the tip on the weekend. And yes, there's going to be a cost. My husband will also whinge about that. It's a cost that's associated with my waste that my house generates. So, I'm going to struggle with fairness about asking a resident living in a unit who may generate very little bulky waste to continue towards a service that predominantly benefits a household like mine.
01:23:00 I believe we need to take a greater responsibility for the waste we generate. This also means I've had to have some challenging conversations with residents that are firmly wanting me to continue to push this. And I'm happy to tell them I stand in where I've made my decision in this particular topic. But I do think that I like the idea of exploring alternatives. So, whether that's doing more to support elderly residents, maybe people with trailers or transport issues, maybe we can improve our communication about the existing services, or explore targeted collections during peak periods. I'm not sure, but I remain open, and I always will, to different approaches. So, that's going to bring me to Councillor Lorentson's motion. And I do want to say something about Amelia, because I think it matters in this position.
01:24:00 She gets criticised for notifying motions, but it is a genuine pathway available to every single councillor here. If someone wanted to put in a notified motion next month about reducing glyphosate from our Shire after the deputations we just heard, then I would support that method, because that is the method available to councillors to bring an emerging topic to the Chamber. We do have other methods, but Amelia is one of the most tenacious advocates for her community that I've had the privilege of working alongside. She listens, she challenges the status quo, and she's never afraid to bring something to the Chamber, because she believes it matters. It matters to the people that she represents. So, whether I agree with the position or not on kerbside election, I respect that enormously to the people who voted for her. They should be incredibly proud of the work she does on your behalf. She has heard from the residents who want this service reconsidered, and she's brought that voice into this Chamber, and that's exactly what we're elected to.
01:25:00 I'm never going to criticise a councillor for genuinely advocating for their community, even if we reach different conclusions. I think good leadership means being prepared to change your mind whenever this changes. I've already changed my mind once on kerbside election, so I'm open to maybe a report suggesting otherwise, or just reconfirm the position that I'm in. I'm also open to the possibility of a more detailed report that could reinforce this for our community, give them more education, and that's why I'm glad that you brought it to me today. Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: And Councillor Phillips. Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: Thank you, Mr Chair. Interestingly enough, I saw this come through when I was reading my reports in preparation of the meeting today. I didn't see a problem with it. I had no speech because I thought this is just, yep, this is great. We want to hear what our community's got to say. At the centre of this, what I see is just what aligns with our corporate themes.
01:26:00 We're just asking for transparency, good governance, openness outward facing to our community. I don't think it's about whether I have a personal opinion about annual kerbside bulk or otherwise. I agree with both sides of the story that have come to the table today. I think it's a perfect opportunity to encourage shared responsibility. Also, the cost of importing goods and how that could be translated at a higher level of government. So that means we can talk about advocacy. You know, we are in a position where we can write to ministers. We can talk to the federal government. When we talk about circular economy, this is something somewhat not unlike the import of the e-scooters. That comes important to our nation, comes down and becomes a problem on the ground.
01:27:00 And then before you know it, we're trying to address all the unintended consequences of what that meant to our local community. We could also move that to waste. I think this is perfectly acceptable and part of our roles when representing our community to ask for a report that is transparent around the annual kerbside bulk. It provides opportunity to look at the cost of life of the goods coming into our country. Recently, I was in the city and going into the plaza down there to look at like, you know, Christmas and what's going on. All the grandkids and everyone loved it. But you know what was going through my mind? Where is all this material goods that are in our faces every day? Where are they ending up? Yes, we can talk about this at a local level. Yes, we've tried to address it over many years to a complex problem that we have
01:28:00 where we've got to go. What are we doing with the goods that we end up with at the end of the life? Not unlike our infrastructure cost of thing, where we've gone to LGAQ to advocate. Mayor Wilkie: Councillor Finzel, can I keep you? You seem to be straying from the topic. Councillor Finzel: No, I'm making a point, Mr Chair. Thank you. Could you just address the motion, please? Yes, I will address the motion. Thank you. I beg your pardon? Mayor Wilkie: Are you in favour of the report? Councillor Finzel: I'll get to that, Mr Chair. Thank you. Thank you for the reminder and I'll stay on track. We're looking at waste as a resource and the cost of doing nothing. We're looking at the effective use of our time and money and energy and first of all and foremost service to our community. I will support this amendment as it stands. That is our role. That is our job and I support it. Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Finzel. Any other councillors wish to speak before Councillor Lorentson closes?
01:29:00 Councillor Lorentson, would you like to close? Councillor Lorentson: I will. And firstly, I want to acknowledge the debate around the table. I respect the diversity in opinions and I want to put that forward. Notices of motions, and I'm going to speak about notices of motions. They're fundamental. They're fundamental parts of local democracy. Mayor Wilkie: I'm sorry, Councillor. Can I direct you just to the motion? Councillor Lorentson: I am and I'm responding to Councillor Phillips' reference to notice of motions. Thank you. As Councillor Phillips said, they exist. The council is to raise issues on behalf of the communities they represent. And respectfully and agree with what Councillor Phillips said, I'm also tired of being criticised for doing my job. The process is a process. It's available to every councillor around this table.
01:30:00 Residents have raised this issue about curbside collection with me repeatedly, weekly. It was a main issue over the 2020-4 election. And I also made a commitment that I would request a review of this. I made no promises about outcomes. And the motion isn't about outcomes. I think people have just misunderstood the purpose of the motion. Curbside collection is part of Council's core business. That's why communities and residents pay rates. They expect to see value for their rates. Again, we know this motion does request the information that Councillor Phillips took two years to understand. The community is asking the same thing. It's not pre-empting a decision. It's not saying that we're going to reinstate options. It's allowing our residents just the information to understand why we've chosen if this is the path to go down this path.
01:31:00 I also would like, and this is part of my conversations with our waste strategy guys, is to explore. You know, it's simple to say yes or no. It's harder sometimes to explore alternative pathways. And I think as a Council, we made a commitment for continuous improvements. And one way we can do that is by exploring alternatives like tip vouchers and need spaces, understanding our demographics and our elderly people. Other Councils have managed to find a solution. And I just think that we owe it to our community to work a little bit harder. This issue isn't going away. And again, the decision today is not to choose one side or another. It's just to answer a question that keeps coming up six years. The question keeps coming up. We just owe it to our community to listen and to provide that information.
01:32:00 I don't think it's a big ask. Like I said, I've spent six months with staff trying to work on the wording so that what's in front of us is workable and doable. And it's an imposing resource and implications to them. They're happy with the motion. And they too understand, you know, this is a question. We can kick this can down the road, but it will resurface again. So I think we have a fundamental obligation as Councils. A, to listen to our constituents. But two, to understand our number one job in local government is to serve our community. This is important. And I think we serve our community by listening to them and providing them an answer to a question that keeps getting resurfaced. So, again, appreciate the conversation. Don't appreciate the personal results, but I do appreciate the conversation around the table.
01:33:00 Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: I'll put the motion. Those in favour? Councillor Laurrenson, Phillips, Finzel. Those against? Councillor Wilson, Stockwell. And Wilkie. The motion is lost. It now brings us to consideration of committee recommendations. 11.1.1. Audit and risk committee recommendations dated 23rd of October 2026. 11.1.1. Queensland Audit Office QAO closing report. 11.1.2. 2025-26 annual financial statements. 11.1.3. Noosa Shire Council 2025-26 annual report. 11.1.4. 11.1.5. Governance and policy update. 11.1.6. Corporate culture update 2526. 11.1.7. Work base health and safety report 2526. 11.1.8. Queensland audit office managing cyber security risk self assessment.
11 CONSIDERATION OF COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1 AUDIT & RISK COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS DATED 23 OCTOBER 2026 ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.1 QUEENSLAND AUDIT OFFICE (QAO) - CLOSING REPORT ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.2 2025-26 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.3 NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL 2025 - 2026 ANNUAL REPORT ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.4 FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT ASSURANCE PROGRAM - YEAR 1 WORKPLAN ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.5 GOVERNANCE & POLICY UPDATE ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.6 CORPORATE CULTURE UPDATE 2025 - 2026 ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.7 WORKPLACE HEALTH AND SAFETY REPORT 2025 - 2026 ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.8 QUEENSLAND AUDIT OFFICE - MANAGING CYBER SECURITY RISKS - SELF ASSESSMENT ¶
01:34:00 11.1.9. ICT cyber risk report. 11.1.1.0. Rates and charges debt management and recovery. 11.1.1.1. Fringe benefits tax project update. 11.1.1.2. Super under contractors project update. 11.1.1.3. Is all these audit committee recommendations on block. May I have a mover and a seconder. Moved Councillor Wilson. Seconded Councillor Phillips. All in favour? That's carried unanimously. We now come to the general committee recommendations dated 6th of October 2026. 11.2.2. Planning applications decided by delegated authority September 2026. 11.2.3. Noosaville community battery project report. 11.2.4. Operational plan 2026-27. Quarter 1. Quarterly reporting. 11.2.5. Bridgend active street. I'd like to declare a conflict of interest.
11.1.9 ICT CYBER RISK REPORT ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.10 RATES AND CHARGES DEBT MANAGEMENT AND RECOVERY ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.11 FRINGE BENEFITS TAX (FBT) PROJECT UPDATE ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.12 SUPER ON CONTRACTORS PROJECT UPDATE ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.1.13 AUDIT & RISK COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS ENBLOC ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.2 GENERAL COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS DATED 10 NOVEMBER 2026 ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.2.1 CAPITAL PROGRAM 2026-2027 DELIVERY STATUS REPORT ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.2.2 PLANNING APPLICATIONS DECIDED BY DELEGATED AUTHORITY – SEPTEMBER 2026 ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.2.3 NOOSAVILLE COMMUNITY BATTERY PROJECT REPORT ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.2.4 OPERATIONAL PLAN 2026-2027 Q1 QUARTERLY REPORTING ¶
01:35:00 So like Councillor Frank Wilkie informed the meeting I have received conflict of interest for item 11.2.5 Bridgend active street update. On this agenda as the matter involves a proposal for a new footpath in Lorikeet Drive, Perigia. And I and a close relative, my mother, live in nearby streets that connect onto Lorikeet Drive. Although I believe I can make a decision in the public interest to avoid perceptions of a conflict of interest. I choose to leave the meeting room while this matter is discussed and voted upon. Councillor Wilson: I choose to leave the meeting room while this matter is discussed and voted upon. Sorry Chair, that's in the further reports in part 13. Sorry Chair, that's in the further reports in part 13. Mayor Wilkie: There's two parts. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: I'll move a motion to address that. Mayor Wilkie: There'll be dealt with. Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. As I just foreshadowed, I shall move that the item 11.2.5 be dealt with via the further report at item 13.2.
11.2.5 PEREGIAN ACTIVE STREET UPDATE ¶
01:36:00 Can I have a seconder, please? A second. A seconded by Councillor Wilson. No need for discussion. All those in favour? That's unanimous. We can invite the Mayor back in. Thank you. Vincent Lombard: I know I didn't miss much that time. Mayor Wilkie: Okay, we're up to item 11.2.6, Burgess Creek Integrated Catchment Management Plan. We have a couple of conflicts of interest here for declaration. We have them on the screen. Thank you. Thank you, Laura. Councillor Lorentson: I, Councillor Miriam Lawson, inform the meeting that I have conflict of interest for item 11.2.6, Burgess Creek Integrated Catchment Management Plan in St. Jeanville. My brother lives approximately 550 metres from the mouth of Burgess, and I have recently purchased property in Sunrise Beach approximately 550 metres from the mouth of Burgess Creek.
11.2.6 Burgess Creek Integrated Catchment Management Plan ¶
01:37:00 This distance has been checked and confirmed by the governance team in any previous statements I made on the square of estimates. In an abundance of caution... Consistent with advice from the Office of Independent Assessing, I believe it's prudent to prepare this interest. Consistent with legal advice previously considered by this Council on the question of proximity, proximity alone gives rise to a conflict of interest only, not a material personal interest. My position falls within that same characterisation. The Integrated Catchment Management Plan for Burgess Creek is a shire-wide body of work. It forms part of a board and is a catchment strategy for waterways. The decision before this meeting affected the entire community. It is in that community interest that I wish to contribute. I've consistently declared this interest and believe I am able to consider this matter impartially and in the public interest.
01:38:00 I choose to remain all need of room and vote on this issue. Mayor Wilkie: Councillor Stockwell. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Yes. I also wish to inform the meeting that I have a conflict of interest under for item 11.2.6 which is the Burgess Creek Integrated Catchment Plan on this agenda as due to my role as President of Noosa Lions Football Club which has fields in the catchment. I do not believe a reasonable person could have a perception of bias because the club does not profit from or suffer a loss as a result of the plan, and while larger an area than most allotments has no significant greater interest than the many people who live in the catchment. As I have specialist expertise and significant experience in the subject matter, I choose to remain in the room and vote on the matter. Mayor Wilkie: Councillor Stockwell. Does someone care to move the motion? Councillor Finzel: Councillor Stockwell. Mayor Wilkie: Seconded by Councillor Finzel. Any discussion? All in favour? That's unanimous. 11.2.7 is Noosa Design Principles.
01:39:00 11.2.8 is MCU 21-0175-38, Walterhay Drive, Noosaville, Material Change Abuse Office and Showrooms. 11.2.9 MCU-1105-19-20, Trading Post Road and 15 Pearsons Road, Cooroy, Extension to Currency Period. 11.2.10 MCU and OPW, Seven Noosa Parade, Noosa Heads, Other Change to Dwelling House. 11.2.11 Noosa Shire Council, Annual Report. 11.2.12 Noosa Mayor's Attendance and Representation of Council of Mayors, SEQ, Overseas Delegation, 2027, International Travel. I'd like to move this item separately. I have a motion. Councillor Stroud. I move that Council note the report by the Chief Executive Officer to the General Committee dated 10th of November, 2026, regarding the International Delegation to Los Angeles County,
11.2.7 NOOSA DESIGN PRINCIPLES ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.2.8 MCU21/0175 - 38 WALTER HAY DRIVE, NOOSAVILLE - MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE - OFFICE AND SHOWROOMS ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.2.9 MCU15/0111.05 - 19 & 20 TRADING POST ROAD AND 15 PEARSONS ROAD, COOROY - EXTENSION TO CURRENCY PERIOD ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.2.10 MCU25/0053.01 & OPW25/0074.01 - 7 NOOSA PDE, NOOSA HEADS - OTHER CHANGE TO DWELLING HOUSE ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.2.11 NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL 2025 - 2026 ANNUAL REPORT ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
11.2.12 MAYOR'S ATTENDANCE AND REPRESENTATION OF COUNCIL – COUNCIL OF MAYORS SEQ, OVERSEAS DELEGATION 2027 (INTERNATIONAL TRAVEL) ¶
01:40:00 organised and funded by the SEQ Council of Mayors, scheduled for February 2027. B. Note that the Mayor will not be attending the Council of Mayors' SEQ 2027 International Delegation as the Noosa businesses that have expressed interest in attending have withdrawn. And C. Request the CEO facilitate a review for councillors of the councillors' expense reimbursement and provision of the facility policy, including consideration of expense limits and public reporting requirements, the new draft of the policy, to be presented to council for endorsement as per standard practice. I second. Thank you. Councillor Finzel. Okay. Councillors, I've moved this because I can advise that Municipal Council will not be attending the Council's business delegation to LA will not be proceeding as the Noosa companies who expressed interest have all withdrawn. As mentioned last week, preference was being given to businesses from Shires accompanied by a Mayor due to it being oversubscribed.
01:41:00 A major reason for attending was to ensure our Noosa businesses did not miss out on the opportunity to expand their export bases. As they are no longer attending, there is no driving imperative for Noosa to go. The majority of other councils are still attending this delegation that is funded by the South East Queensland Council of Mayors. There was also a good idea that was supported unanimously last week about reporting requirements for a delegation or any, you can expand that to any councillor, ratepayer funded councillor travel, about reporting on the key learnings and benefits after a councillor's attendance at work-related conferences and professional development that ought to be captured. That's why I've included Part C. This is one of the key reasons why I've requested the CEO facilitate a review for councillors of the Council's expense reimbursement and provision of facility policy, including consideration of our expenditure limits, practices, public reporting on public reporting requirements about key learnings after the councillor has
01:42:00 returned with a new draft of the policy to be presented to Council for endorsement as per standard practice. A review of the current expenditure and reimbursement policy also will help demonstrate our awareness of and respect for community sentiment on this issue of ratepayer funded work-related related expenses. It shows that we're aware that there's community sensitivity about this and will help determine whether the Council's expense and reimbursement policy scope and expense limits continue to be seen as fair and reasonable and I hope you'll support it. Councillor Kinzler question. Councillor Finzel: I just have a question, do we know that the information collected by council of mayors given we are in that group, are they prepared to share the knowledge or information gained
01:43:00 at the event that you'll no longer attending with our council? Maybe that's a question to the CEO. Mayor Wilkie: Okay. Look, usually there's a post-mission report circulated, and I'm sure there will be one for this delegation, which we can share. Well, I'll double check, but I've seen no reason why I can't be sure. Councillor Lorentson: Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: Do we have questions? Councillor Lorentson: I'll skip to the motion. Thank you, Mayor, for bringing this forward. First of all, I'll be supporting the motion that you don't proceed with the trip to Los Angeles. I respect your reasons for not going, with businesses having pulled out of the trade mission. I also respect our local businesses and the decisions they've made. The reason today that's been given is a valid one. But that's not my reason for supporting this motion. My reasons are simple. Between the general committee meeting and today, I asked for some further information about the purpose and outcomes of the divide trip.
01:44:00 The previous overseas delegation had a proposed LA trip. I was unclear, as were many in the community, about what the trips were for, and in particular, what direct benefits they delivered to Noosa, and why the overseas delegation was justified. I believe this information was emailed just before the meeting, so I want to acknowledge and thank the CEO for that information. I want to also mention the CEO. I totally support, so I think that's a really important addition, a review of our policy and overseas travels and delegations. We give that information that I was seeking before this meeting. I think it's also important in terms of future proposals that come to Council and for future Councils as well. Once it's set in policy, then this sort of discussion will never come back again.
01:45:00 So, thank you very much. So, again, support the motion, support the request to review our policy, and respect the Mayor's reasons. Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Wilson. I have a councilor to speak. I'll wait my right to close. That is in favour. That's unanimous. Thank you. We now come to the general committee recommendations on block. That's the recommendations of the general committee meeting dated 10 November 2026. And we would like to see the recommendations to be received and adopted except where dealt with by separate resolution. All in favour? Councillor. Councillor Lonson. Councillor Finzel. Thank you. All in favour? That's unanimous. We come now to item 13.1, Financial Performance Report October 2026, Budget Review 1A 2026-27 and Revised 26.27 to 2045.36 long term financial forecast.
11.2.13 GENERAL COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS ENBLOC ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
12 REPORTS REFERRED FROM THE GENERAL COMMITTEE ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
13 ORDINARY MEETING REPORTS ¶
01:46:00 We have Financial Services Manager Zach Morton-Adair and Director of Corporate Services, Margaret Gatt, here to report. Alex, could you please give us a summary of the report? Speaker 3: Good morning, Councillors. Let's head straight over to our Manager, Financer, to take us through the report. Speaker 7: Thank you, and through the Chair, I will take the report as brief. The report presents Council's financial performance to the 31st of October 2026 against the revised budget for the 26-27 financial year as adopted on the 20th of August 2026. The report covers the first four months of the year, or roughly 33% of the financial year. As at the 31st of October, Council reported a favourable net result variance to budget of $3.7 million. This comprises a favourable operating variance of 2.4 and a favourable capital revenue variance of 1.3. There are no significant financial risks currently identified that are expected to materially impact Council's financial position.
13.1 FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE REPORT OCTOBER 2026, BUDGET REVIEW 1A 2026/27 AND REVISED 2026/27 TO 2035/36 LONG TERM FINANCIAL FORECAST ¶
01:47:00 I would like to draw attention to some of the matters raised in the report, unless otherwise stated that comments relate to the 31st of October 2026. Council has received $76.7 million, or $46 million. The overall operating revenue variance of $26.7 million is 1.7% of its full operating revenue budget of $164.2 million. The favourable operating revenue variance of $2.4 million represents 1.5% of our overall operating budget. The variance mainly reflects higher rates, levies and charges of $0.5 million, coupled with investment earnings of $1.4 million. Our operating expenditure was $53 million, or roughly 32% of our full-year operating expenditure. The unfavourable operating expenditure variance of $0.2 million represents 0.1% of our overall operating expenditure budget.
01:48:00 Lower employee benefits of $0.5 million, due to normal vacancies and attrition, were offset by materials and services costs of $0.8 million above budget. This is primarily driven by legal fees associated to date relating to development and maintenance. Operating expenditure remains within acceptable budget parameters with no material areas of concern currently identified. In regards to Council's business activities, the overall favourable operating position comprises of $1.8 million from Council's core operating activities and $0.6 million coming from Council's business activities. Waste management reports a favourable operating variance of approximately $0.6 million. Holiday parks has an approximately $16,000 unfavourable variance compared to budget.
01:49:00 In regards to our tourism and economic development investment, the year-to-date expenditure is broadly in line with the underlying operating budget. In regards to our capital revenue, Council has received $10.3 million comprising of $10 million related to capital grants and subsidies and $0.3 million from Council. In regards to our cash contributions and infrastructure charges, Actual capital works expenditure excluding contributed assets, loan redemption payments and commitments was $18.8 million, or 19% of Council's $99.6 million capital works programme. Excluding recovery works, capital expenditure was $17.4 million to date against a $70.5 million programme. To aid in illustrating the financial information presented in the report, To supplementary slides from the capital works executive reporting have been included in the report. Please note that the information in the rear of this report on regards to VR1A will impact the comparative, the underlying comparatives as we move forward for future multi-finance reports.
01:50:00 Current year end forecast adjustments, including project level timing changes, will be considered as part of budget review 2 due for council consideration in January 2027. Total cash on hand was $15.8 million, including $6.7 million held in trust. Council's investments continue to perform well against agreed benchmarks. On a 12-month rolling basis, total cash holdings increased by $28.7 million, or 23%. However, it is worth noting that of this increase, $16.8 million relates to grants received in advance for the QRA, or Queensland Reconstructional Fund. As these were recognised as contract liabilities within Council's financial statements. Rates and utility charges. Council has collected $57.6 million, or 50% of its $114 million rates and utility charges budget.
01:51:00 In regards to Council's rates, arrears and debt recovery, total rates and arrears were $8.6 million, or 6.7% in the month of October. This reduced by $3.2 million. This represents a 27% reduction from the $11.7 million that was outstanding as of 30 September 2026. This change was largely driven by the reminder notices that have been sent out and the commencement of Council's debt recovery actions in line with the underlying policy. The initial referral through this policy focused on long-standing arrears in excess of 12 months, and it is worth noting that ratepayers who have entered into approved payment arrangements or have active hardship arrangements were excluded from this referral. In addition to the standard monthly finance report, Budget Review 1A has been included in the report in the table in front of me today.
01:52:00 The report also includes the revised $26.27 million, or $27.7 million, as of today. It is worth reminding that Budget Reviews are a routine and prudent budget management process. Budget Review 1A updates the current Budget, following the finalisation of Council's $25.26 million financial statements, and also revised estimates around recovery works associated with grants received in regards to the Western Queensland Surface Rump Disaster. Recovery works increased from $29.2 million to $78.1 million. This comprises $77.3 million received in grant funding on the Queensland Reconstruction Authority for approved works, and a separated budget of roughly $0.8 million in regards to separate capital-funded allowances that sit outside what is eligible within the QIA programme. The increase is primarily supported by the external funding received in regards to these grants, so as a result of that, there is no material impact to Council's adopted financial settings.
01:53:00 Council has projected operating surplus changes from $42,000 in Budget Review 1 to $234,000 in Budget Review 1A. This is mainly due to lower financial costs, following the decision not to draw down a $3.1 million of loans budgeted in 2025-2026. Those loans were related to the Lake MacDonnell Residential Subdivision project and expansion of the Dernan Resource Recovery Program. The change relates to the timing of the drawdown on loans, not a change to how the projects are funded. The loans associated with both of these projects are currently expected to be drawn down in the current financial year. The principal changes to the statement of financial position reflect Council's audited position as of the 30th of June 2021 and the revised recovery program.
01:54:00 These balance sheet movements do not represent a deterioration in Council's financial situation. As part of any budget review process, we update our underlying metrics around financial sustainability. As a result of the changes, there has been no change to the underlying basis of our financial sustainability metrics. It is worth drawing attention to the asset sustainability ratio that across the 10-year period, some of the years come below the 80% threshold. When viewed across the 10-year term as an average, the threshold that needs to be met is 80% in any year. As an average across the 10 years, Council maintains 125.6%. It is management's view and our expectation that once we move through subsequent capital planning and budget review processes, that Council will meet the minimum threshold of benchmarking each year of the 10-year period.
01:55:00 Fees and charges. It is worth noting that in the report today, there is a minor administrative error to the naming convention in one fee. It doesn't affect the fee itself or the charge that has been charged relative to the fee itself. Subsequent consideration will be put forward in regards to administrative elements not needed being brought in front of Council to this level, where the fee or charge is actually unimpacted as a result of the change. To summarise, Council remains in a strong and stable financial position. The October results remain with an acceptable budget parameters, with BR1 ensuring our adopted position represents our year-end forecast. Thank you, and we're happy to take questions. Mayor Wilkie: Would anyone like to move the motion? Councillor Kowalewicz? I'm happy to move the motion. Councillor Lorentson: Thank you. I'll second. Mayor Wilkie: Seconded by Councillor Stockwell.
01:56:00 Thank you, Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Lorentson: I probably wanted to ask questions first, but I'd like to thank the financial service manager, the finance team again for the report. Again, it just gives us a good picture of where we stand. And the way that goes into these reviews isn't always seen, and I want to acknowledge that. Short-term position, as I read it on my financial guru, seems sound. We're slightly ahead of budget, rate arrears have come down a bit, and our investments are performing well. That's good news. But I want to focus on the long-term, and again, I'm no financial guru, but when I looked at the long-term strategy, made me start thinking about how important the decisions that we make today really matter. So happy to be corrected by how I've interpreted the next 10 years. Rate revenue is forecast to rise by about 60%. And over that same period, our population is forecast to grow only about 0.6%.
01:57:00 And that concerns me quite a bit, because I keep going, where is this increase going to fall on? And it seems like it's going to be rate payers. So the people in our community, especially those of us who work in the financial sector, and fixed incomes, that's a red flag for me. Again, I look at the 10-year plan. Our operating surplus sits at about 0.1% every year for the next 10 decades. So that's almost break-even. Again, a red flag for me. There seems to be no buffer, and it's something we will discuss in spite of our ongoing workshops. Costs are growing too. Employee costs in the past rise from $64 million to $87 million. Appreciation doubles. Grants are raised. Grants, this year we expect $79 million in capital grants, largely for disaster recovery.
01:58:00 And then after 2030, again, if I've read it correctly, that falls to around $2 to $3 million a year. When that funding rises, it's going to be about $2 to $3 million a year. So that's something that my red flags and concerns is, is that something that our community needs to pick up? And again, something that we start the conversation today, we'll have it sorted. Probably risk. I'd like to talk about risk in the long-term forecast. I'd like to see maybe risk maybe included as part of the long-term planning. Again, none of this is criticism of the report of the team. Really acknowledge the excellent work that you guys are doing. It's just about making sure we as councillors, and I consider ourselves like board directors, that we really understand the long-term picture and plan for it now, not just for the next
01:59:00 two years of this council. So that's pretty much all I want to say. Again, thank you. And I think we've got some real challenges ahead. Thank you. But we have commitment and the resourcing and expertise around this table and in council to address those challenges head on. So thank you. Thank you, Councillor Lorentson. Questions or speak to the motion? Councillor Lorentson, Mr Lorentson? No, just one quick question. One more quick question. And it's just in light of all the issues that are happening around the world, in France, drops in Microsoft's teams. Just probably my only question today is in relation to just probably if our systems dropped tomorrow, could we still collect bins and phones, pay staff?
02:00:00 Do we have a plan? Has anyone independently tested them? And I'm probably sort of referencing what happened in France, which wasn't a cyber attack. But they attacked, I think, the refrigerator systems. And I keep thinking, how could that translate into a place like Noosa Council? And is it our facilities, our dean and plan? So a question to you, Zac, do we prepare for these sorts of challenges and scenarios? Thank you, Councillor Lorentson. Speaker 3: Thank you. Thank you, Councillor Lorentson. Thank you, Councillor Lorentson. Thank you, Councillor Lorentson. We do have a disaster response plan, so not just for natural disasters, but for disasters such as losing access to technology or coronavirus or et cetera, et cetera, fires, infrastructure, wobble of our buildings, et cetera. We test those every year, either a desktop test or we do a bit of a live test.
02:01:00 We actually did that last financial, sorry, last, this calendar year. Sorry. We had all members of the executive team, plus governors, plus our ICT people to look at a couple of scenarios. We have our insurance providers that tend to participate in those scenarios and then we get reports with a whole range of recommendations where we can improve. We've also participated in a whole of nation cyber exercise where we had all levels of government involved in that. I can't remember the name of it. And those results were published publicly in these recommendations and we take those into account as well. And we regularly report on our cyber security awareness, it's not awareness, assurance activities through the Audit and Risk Committee and respond to any concerns that they have when we further report to that.
02:02:00 So that's probably just a very open-ended, vague response. But it's quite specific if we were to talk about all the different types of things that could happen. Like the refrigeration or the network, sorry, the Microsoft outage last Friday. So hopefully that gives you a bit of confidence. Absolutely. Thank you, Mark. Thank you. Just to close? Mayor Wilkie: No. Okay. We'll put the motion out of favour. That's unanimous. Thank you. Thank you. Just bring us to item 13.2, which is further report on the Brooklyn Active Street update. So I do have the same conflict of interest. Councillor Wegener: No. I don't need to read it out. Mayor Wilkie: I don't need to read it out, thank you. I'll leave the meeting room. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. If I can invite staff to the table to give us an executive overview of their additional report, please.
13.2 FURTHER REPORT - PEREGIAN ACTIVE STREET UPDATE ¶
02:03:00 Speaker 4: Thank you, councillors. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Welcome, Aidan and Bill. Speaker 4: Thank you, councillors. Thank you, councillors. Our report. Our report on the Brooklyn Active Street is presented to the general committee on the 10th of November. During consideration of this report, the committee requested a further report with the following details to undertake targeted engagement with residents directly, adjoining the proposed section of the Coastal Path and report back verbally on that, and then to include in the written report a summary of the draft report recommendations and how they have addressed community feedback received previously. Further to these requests. The report also outlines advice that we've received from the Active Transport Fund, the federal government grant. On the 12th of November, we received informal advice that our scope change and extension time had been approved. Subsequently, this Tuesday, we received written advice that it has been accepted.
02:04:00 The report addresses how the community engagement has been addressed in this revised design. The original community engagement for this project extended over a number of years, starting with the walking and cycling strategy and corridors starting in 2020 and 2021, which looked at wider community feedback. The project specific community consultation included five pop up sessions through the concept and develop design stage. A workshop with the community. The project included a workshop with the community. And several one on one meetings with residents and membership groups. Some of the feedback we received at the time was about parking impacts the revised design looks at reducing from the previous design where we looked at living 90 car parks down to a reduction of approximately 27 informal car parks, we lost and less conservative interpretation
02:05:00 of that guideline has been investigated, where we can line mark one side of the road, reducing The feedback on the original plan concerned traffic and route running down neighbouring streets, the traffic calming, lowering speed limit and elements associated with the active street perceived to cause this route running have been removed from the scope. There were concerns about property access and displacement, having difficulty with accessing driveways and U-turn manoeuvres. The revised proposal includes some yellow line marking to maintain access to private properties and does not restrict any U-turn manoeuvres that are currently available. Community expressed concerns with safety, speed and e-bikes. There was broad support for localisation. There was concerns about the speed limit to 30km per hour.
02:06:00 There was concerns about interactions between fast moving e-bikes, pedestrians and vehicles, and vehicles driving in bike lanes and through roundabouts. Similar to some of the other feedback, this has not been addressed with this revised design in that the scope for traffic calming devices has been removed from the scope following council resolution on 18th June and previous community feedback. There was concerns around vegetation drainage and neighbourhood character, strong preference to retain and insure trees, including the pandanus, and desire to minimise visual and environmental impacts. This has been addressed through the proposed up versions of the pathway to retain trees and keep the character of the street as though existing. Community expressed concerns and requested policy changes. For further investigation into design alternatives and route considerations, the proposed pathway alignment is based on the high priority corridor study and the walking and cycling strategy planning documents.
02:07:00 The proposed route is considered to align closer to the coast, connect with more attractors, be easier to implement, and then come at a lower cost. It provides benefits for both local residents and regional coastal pathway users. Thank you. Speaker 4: Part of the request at the committee meeting was for further diagrams, some cross sections, and artist impressions have now been provided. Since the committee meeting, staff have spoken to, knocked on doors, and made attempts to speak with over 52 different properties. We've received feedback from approximately 26 of those properties. That was through phone calls and a door knocking session on Monday afternoon.
02:08:00 Overall, the feedback indicates that revised coastal pathway design has improved community sentiment compared to the earlier concept. However, concerns remain, particularly regarding the parking loss, traffic impacts, and perceived need for the project. Residents fell into sort of three groups. One being supportive of the project. Two being supportive of the project. Two, cautiously supportive or neutral, requesting changes before they support the project. And three, completely opposed to the project. Of the people we spoke to, 46% were supportive of the project. 23% fell into that second category of seeing the project as being improved on the previous design. However, they still had concerns. This related to reducing car parking to one side of the road, sort of thing, and then they would support the project.
02:09:00 We had concerns that the project should be undertaken from Lower O'Keefe Park through to the Village Square in one go. And that would be enough for them to support the project. And then we had other residents that didn't have a view, that simply wanted to go with what their neighbours thought. The consultation suggests that support now outweighs opposition. But most support is conditional on minimising the parking impacts. Speaker 5: Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Okay. Is someone willing to move the motion? I'll move the revised motion. As set out in front of us. Have I got a seconder? Councillor Finzel: Oh, happy to second for the debate.
02:10:00 Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Sure. So, Councillors, we're aware of the local concerns. The issue here we've got is we've got a road, street that runs along the beach that has a lot of traffic. And the issue here is we've got a road, street that runs along the beach that has a lot of traffic. We've got a problem in that it's identified as a coastal pathway, and during peak periods it's reduced to a single lane. Not only is it unsafe for pedestrians and cyclists, it would create nightmares to get emergency services to access to any emergencies. We've got the principal concerns relating to this road map. And this relates to a fairly standard perception in the community that's been developed over many years
02:11:00 that there's a perceived right to be able to park your car in front of your property rather than creating enough car parking on your property to be able to safely park. We know this is something that's developed over many years in Australia and is globally being challenged as an acceptable form of transport planning. Creating that in this case means that the cycleway and pathway foot pedestrian way is dangerous during peak periods. The concept that we're losing spaces is really a difficult one to get around in that these informal parking arrangements probably are not in a way that if a standard application of safety rules could occur.
02:12:00 So if we just put off this decision at some stage in the future, councils being aware of the safety risk will have to make a decision. We have got now the ability to use the two funding sources to be able to construct a safer system that while not providing all the utility of the previous proposal does improve safety. And for me as a councillor, I couldn't not support a grant funded project that allows whether it's young people, old people or in between to walk to the shops, to the beach, to ride, to the shops, to the beach, to school, knowing the existing situation without doing something about it. And that's why I support the motion in front of us.
02:13:00 Councillor Wilson: Councillor Wilson. Just a question, please. I think from the feedback from the community we've seen this week, the biggest probably thing outstanding for me is the driveways. Could you please just explain a bit more about the impact on the driveways? Where there's the new footpath? Speaker 4: To undertake construction of the pathway, there will potentially be some driveways that will need to be reconstructed to achieve appropriate crosswalk, right? There is also concerns about access to driveways, particularly with reversing trailers. We have addressed this through sweat path analysis. And we'll continue, if the project is to proceed, to work with neighbouring properties to ensure vehicles' access is maintained. There is no intention to block access to any of these options. Thank you.
02:14:00 Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Question from Councillor Orrington. Councillor Lorentson: A question to start. Councillor Stockwell referenced quite a bit in his debate about the importance of emergency services and safety as being one of the main reasons to progress. This morning, I received an email from residents filled with a lot of questions. And one of their concerns was in terms of the 3.4 to 3.8 metre roadway. And they referenced Queensland Department of Transport and Main Roads' tampered traffic management guidelines, which identifies 5.5 metres for a two-way residential street. So my question is, can you talk a little bit more about that? Can you explain how cyclists, emergency vehicles and residents entering or leaving properties will be safely accommodated, and whether or not, you know, the narrowing roadway, 3.4, 3.8 metres, is actually safe?
02:15:00 Speaker 4: Mr Chair, the existing situation with the vehicles parked on both sides of the road and a narrow through lane, where vehicles have to wait for others to pass, is not ideal. As part of the previous Active Street proposal, we looked at addressing that through on-road line marking, formalised car parking, which would maintain a two-way access for vehicles. As per the Council resolution in June and the community feedback, that was removed from the scope of the project. So we'd be retaining informal car parking on both sides for the length of Borough Quay Drive. What this does is, we left with that situation of complications with access.
02:16:00 What it does do is it does slow vehicles down. To achieve a wider through lane, we would need to line mark one side of the road. The negative side of that is that you encourage faster vehicles, because there is now no reason to wait for oncoming vehicles and to safely manoeuvre around that. So the traffic advice has been, if you are going to pursue restriction of car parking on one side, then you would need to also implement local area traffic management, with street canyons, speed bumps and other speed deterring devices. The revised design initially shows line marking on both sides of the road at these diversions, so that there is room for two vehicles to pass. We are taking a less conservative interpretation of the standard to allow car parking on one side of the road then.
02:17:00 If, through implementation of this project, we discovered that was an issue, a simple line marking exercise could be undertaken at a later date to prevent vehicles parking there. It's a compromised position. Councillor Lorentson: So to simplify what you just said, Aidan, is that the proposed design, that's been put at the table at the moment, does it or doesn't it safely accommodate emergency vehicles, cyclists, residents, visitors? Yes or no? Speaker 4: The proposed design, the pathway, would not restrict access for emergency vehicles any further than the current situation. Speaker 7: Okay, thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Other questions or would like to talk to the motion?
02:18:00 Councillor Wegener. Councillor Wegener: I'd just like to confirm that the pedestrian path is 1.5 metres. That's been... That's correct. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Lorentson: So in terms of the 1.5 metre pathway, again, these are questions that have been put to me early this morning. How do cyclists travelling in both directions, how are they going to be safely accommodated if the footpath is only 1.5 metres wide? Is that right enough? Speaker 4: The proposed 1.5 metre wide pathway is designed for pedestrians predominantly. That's right. The original scope for the active street included local area traffic management and other devices to slow vehicles down to encourage bike riders to use the road.
02:19:00 In Queensland, unless signed otherwise, it's legal to use a road bike on the footpath. The proposed design does not include any signage to restrict people from using the pathway. So bike riders could continue to ride on the pathway. And that decision has been made to allow children on bikes and less confident bike riders to continue on the pathway. It is expected that confident bike riders would continue to use low repeat drive as they do now. The 1.5 metre wide pathway is not sufficient to be considered a shared pathway. And bike riders would need to slow down. To navigate around pedestrians, crams or paths otherwise. Councillor Wegener: Thank you. Trevor Butler: Anyone else? Councillor? Councillor Phillips: I just want to make sure that I don't address either of you at the time.
02:20:00 And that's because this really isn't about you. You've done both exactly what has been requested of you. And in fact, thank you for the work that both of you have put in. And thank you for aiding you especially through the project the entire time. It's absolutely amazing. So the community should be really impressed with how you've handled this project. So I'm going to address the councillors because actually I think if I go back now, the original design probably made a lot of sense. And we sort of got involved and it just, I don't know, it's got really complicated and not really where I think it should have landed to begin with. So done some reflecting. And I think as positions that we hold here when we set plans, and we go back to the 2020 Coastal Pathway Corridor Study, which I wasn't here for, maybe when we set a plan,
02:21:00 we should make sure the organisation has the right staff, it has enough staff, has enough FTEs, it has enough budget to actually deliver a really good outcome. So I think it's the cart before the horse. Again, when I've seen projects get to this point, and maybe it's because some of them started pre-existing our term, but I've tried to catch up really quickly. But I've often felt that in the initial stages of an intention of a plan is great. And we think, okay, this is why we're starting it. We've got this feedback and then it morphs into something that I don't even know if any of us can really sort of get at, grasp our hands on. And then community come late to the party because the internal stuff has to happen first. And then by the time it goes to the community, there's already a position or there's already work done. There's already resources, funding.
02:22:00 And then we're at a pinch point where we haven't met maybe the needs of the community. We've spent money. And so I feel like we're almost in this catch 22 position where I'm not comfortable. So I'm going to make a commitment today that every time we're sitting in a workshop, we start with when there's an original plan presented to us, that we start then with have we given the organisation, the FTEs, the financial commitment through our budget to deliver it. Because I think there'll be councils in the future that will sit here and be in a position the same way we are, where I'm just not comfortable where it landed. And I think that's why I said I can't get to start because they've done everything they were meant to do. It was the time delay and the different inputs
02:23:00 and influences that ends up being something that the community aren't happy with. And maybe none of us could, I can speak for myself, I'm not satisfied with it. The community aren't. But that's why I said maybe the original design made sense. And what happened there? Why did it break down? Usually communication, usually rapport with our community. It starts with listening first. So as a police negotiator, the one thing, a key part of police negotiating is to listen before I do anything else. And I think sometimes we have to stop before we progress and just check. Because there's lots of talk about a highly engaged community and we know that. And I don't know whether they just want us to do the basics and we're starting with the plans and then we present it to them and they're like, that's not what I asked for. There's obviously a pinch point that is not working.
02:24:00 So the only outcome that I really want from today is a review of this particular project from a really honest position of what actually went wrong. And that means we have to look at ourselves and go, what influence did we have at what point back at the 2020 plan? I can't go back to the corridor study because I wasn't here. But I do think we have to review processes. And wonder if we've negatively influenced a project. Have we brought community on board at the start and actually asked, what is it that you want? If we were looking at your street, you know, and maybe just start with that with a scrap piece of paper and really a blank canvas and get ideas instead of, you know, maybe making it too complicated, I think. And then community are busy. I just think they take time. They take time to get involved in it. And then it's only until when they realise
02:25:00 that it's really going to impact them, then they come to us and say that they're not happy. So let's avoid that to begin with and start the engagement well and truly early and find out what the actual, you know, top three priorities of each area is and start with that. But, yeah, it's a bit disappointing really because I know that the work and the funds and everything that's born into it, it's definitely not where I want it to be standing today. But I feel like I have to go home tonight and sleep well, knowing that I've made the right decision. And today it just hasn't landed. But it isn't because of the work that's been put into it. Not at all. So, thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor Lorton. Councillor Lorentson: I'm going to speak and I won't be supporting the recommendation in front of us. I would also like to just foreshadow a potential alternative motion in case this one doesn't get supported, that we potentially look at the South East Queensland Living Fund
02:26:00 and reallocate it to shovel-ready projects within the Shire so that we don't lose that opportunity for funding. So, thank you. I'm not supporting the recommendation and it's not because I've closed footpaths, active transport or external funding. It's because I just don't believe this process has earned the community's confidence and I don't believe Council or myself has enough information to make the right decision today. Over the past week, I've spoken with many, many residents who are genuinely confused about what's been proposed and what it will mean for their daily lives. They're asking questions that I still can't answer even from the report that I've got today. The question that keeps getting thrown at me is where's the master plan? How does this fit into the broader vision for Peregian? Why has the western side of David Lowe not been properly assessed?
02:27:00 I know it has, but they don't feel they understand that reason sufficiently. They've also raised specific concerns. They raised there was no real notice of the revised design, only found out about it a couple of weeks ago. There was no online announcement and very little time to respond. Concerned about yellow lines and lost parking, especially between Victory Park and Penn Street, which are the pinch points. In places, pedestrians are diverted onto the road to avoid trees. There's a 1.5 metre path that can go around them. Some residents have asked for the more permeable materials to protect tree roots and seek regions peach-like character. There's safety questions too, which I've just raised before. How the cycle is travelling in both directions. Share a footpath that narrows to 1.5 metres beside a roadway of just 3.4 to 3.8 metres.
02:28:00 And this morning, on the day of this vote, again, I received another two-page email full of questions. And that tells me we are not ready. I also thank staff for contacting impacted residents in recent days. I also acknowledge this has taken its toll on staff and there's been an enormous amount of work that's been done in terms of consultation. Some of the residents have told me that not everyone was at home during the last week. And you mentioned that also in your talk. I think 56 homes, of which 52 properties were contacted, of which 26 were actually at home. Five months ago, residents told us simply they didn't feel heard. And today, I feel they're still telling us the same thing. Heard a lot about funding. Funding is important.
02:29:00 The community trust is more important. This grant may not come from rat payers, but it's still, as we've heard it on the table, it's still covered money. Funding alone should never be the reason we approve a project the community doesn't understand. And we can't forget there's been a cost to this process. Start time plans, revised plans, consultation, more consultation. That cost is actually very high. And it's gone by our community, our rat payers. And to me, that's one of the most important lessons here. When we don't bring the community with us from the start, it costs us. It costs us in rat pay money, it costs us in time, and it costs us in trust. Our job is to serve our community and protect their money, their interests, and their lifestyle. Residents didn't ask for this project. Peregian will get its full parts. But to me, not now, and not with this funding.
02:30:00 It should happen with a clear plan and the community's support. And this funding, as I said just earlier, hopefully doesn't disappear from NESA. It can go to other worthy projects across our Shire. For me, too many unanswered questions. Community hasn't been viewed in all the ways, the information it needs. It might be like. So for me, for a good outcome, we need a clear vision. We need community understanding, community support, and community trust. And I don't believe we have those things now. So I'm not going to be supporting the recommendation. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Anyone else wish to talk? Councillor Wilson. Councillor Wilson: Thank you for all the work on this and particularly for going back in as last week. And talking to residents. From my point of view, I think most of the issues have been addressed. The reduction of parking only now being 14 to 20.
02:31:00 I think it's a really good outcome based on where we were and also based on the utilization studies that were done earlier in the project. I do acknowledge that there are still questions and issues outstanding, but I hope that they can be addressed through the design and construction stage. I also agree with a lot of what Councillor Phillips said in terms of the process here. It was always a concern to me that the funding became the driver of this project and not the need of the community. And this project got prioritized above many others that got raised from something like number 283 to the top of the pile to just because it met the funding criteria. And I think that's something we really want to avoid in the future. But also has a bit of PTSD of the Noosaville foreshore plan as well, where we went too far and then had to rein it back. But I think this time we have reined it back
02:32:00 to something that hopefully can be successful. And I am still getting messages from residents too, but it is getting to be a smaller number. And I hope that those individuals can have their concerns addressed as it proceeds. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Councillor Finzel: Yep. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: Thank you. I just have a question. When we went for the walk with the community and broke up into the groups, there was some really significant ageing infrastructure that needed to be repaired. And that, I think, falls in under this remit. If this doesn't proceed forward, where and how are those ageing infrastructure costs that are pre-existing? As part of our general, you know, to community. How will that be addressed? Speaker 5: Through the Chair, you know, with that understanding of the specific infrastructure we're referring to,
02:33:00 if there is an ageing asset, whether it's, you know, footpath, road, stormwater infrastructure, if that is a council asset and it has aged or deteriorated to an extent where it is causing, you know, a safety issue to our community, you know, then, you know, that is a renewal expense, you know, that would be met by council general revenue through the capital program. Speaker 4: Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor Wegener, did you wish to talk? Councillor Wegener: I've been in a lot of coastal communities over the last couple of months, and I think a 1.5 pathway is just not wide enough. I'm with Councillor Phillips that I think we can do better, and I would rather wait and do it really, really right because it's an amazing place. And I think, to me, this is a decision by a committee
02:34:00 which just kind of lost its way. And I would like to start with a much more grand vision. Because we can do better, I believe. And I think we can do better. And I think that that opportunity will come in the future for us to really make something spectacular. Councillor Finzel: I'm just thinking, Trevor Butler: Councillor, Councillor Finzel: you've only asked a question. Yeah. I guess this is to, I'm not sure who to direct it to. It was raised by Councillor Lorentson with regards to potential funding. What was that funding called? Councillor Lorentson: South East Queensland with the building funding. Councillor Finzel: Okay, thank you. So who can respond to a question around that? And does this fit into the scope of this job? Or does that just take us right back to basically redoing the entire project? Speaker 5: Through the Chair, I think firstly, I don't wish to preview the outcomes
02:35:00 of the conversation that you're having at the moment. But to be clear, if the outcome of this recommendation before you today was not supported by Council, then my advice to you would be that the funds that we have been received from the Australian Government through the ATF, we would be returning. That the funds that are available to us through the SEQ Livability Fund, the potential scope of use for those funds is broader. And there is the potential for those to be, for a conversation with the administrators of the SEQ Livability Fund to seek a reallocation of those funds within the Council area. They, given the timeframe that we have available to us, we would want to be ensuring that we are identifying existing priority projects that have a level of approval within Council and can be delivered within the timeframe of the grant
02:36:00 that's available to us. There are projects of that nature. But again, I don't wish to preempt the outcome of this discussion. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor Osden. Councillor Lorentson: So if the funding were reallocated, could we then still get a footpath in the future through either another round of funding or through just our capital works program? Speaker 5: Indeed. Through the Chair, Councillor, I think the conversation that I'm hearing around the table is, you know, let's not prioritise based on grant availability. You know, let's prioritise footpaths and, you know, cycle networks based on their priority within the region. You know, listening to the conversation and, you know, my understanding is that that's exactly how we arrived at this position in the first place. You know, that our coastal path is our primary coastal network footpath within the region. And, you know,
02:37:00 Peregian is a key missing link for want of a better description. So for me, if from a council and a community perspective, we haven't satisfied sufficient strategic direction and understanding around what our priorities are, I believe that information is largely there. But, you know, we'll have another look at it. But, you know, it is really important, you know, to make these decisions based on the priorities and strategic documents. Speaker 4: You know, Speaker 5: the cycle, strategy and everything else that goes with it is there to give us guidance. You know, there is a coastal pathway and that is there to give us guidance. And the alignment that has been selected for Lorry Peak Drive is an exact alignment with that documentation. You know, so it hasn't been selected because it is an available street. It was identified through due diligence, through evidence and the strategic directions from this organisation around how we establish cycling networks and pedestrian networks
02:38:00 within the region. And that's how we arrived at Lorry Peak Drive. I would hazard a guess if we ran and re-ran the process, given the limited number of options that are available in the region itself, I would be surprised if we arrived at a different option by way of alignment. The conversation then comes down to what is the standard? And if I may, if, you know, the standard that has been sought for a wider footpath, then that is a very different conversation. You know, we are dealing with a narrow footprint. You know, we are dealing with an existing narrow footprint. It is compromised. But what we are endeavouring to do is to find a workable balance and a workable balance that delivers an outcome within the space that we have available to us. We're trying to deliver a walkable, safe footpath for residents to access the shops, coastal paths, connections. We're trying to, is it wide enough? Possibly not.
02:39:00 But will it achieve a functional outcome? Yes, it will. We're trying to minimise the disruption to traffic flow and we're trying to minimise the loss of car parking. That's not an easy outcome to do. You know, if we were prioritising a larger, wider coastal pathway and if we were prioritising emergency access, there would be far greater loss of parking than what is on the table in the current proposal today. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Any other questions? Councillor Wilson: Do we need to do an amendment to D? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So, the question then to Aidan, are you suggesting we've now been formally advised in regard to the Act of Transport Fund? Speaker 4: That's correct. Councillor Wilson: In that case, do we need to move an amendment to D that says pending successful outcome?
02:40:00 Mayor Wilkie: We received Speaker 4: a formal letter on Tuesday. We would have to take it on notice whether we actually need to sign a renewed funding agreement. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So, the pending is probably still fine. Yeah. Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: Yeah, I just have a question. If it's not supported and there's a return of the Act of Transport Fund, I guess Deputy Mayor Stockwell: the question is, will there be cost borne by rate payers for the broader design process? Councillor Finzel: Yes, thank you. Speaker 5: Through the Chair of Council, yes, there will be cost borne through general revenue. We are currently in a design phase with the view to construct. That being the case, it is a capitalised project. A capitalised project
02:41:00 requires an asset to be constructed at the end of the day. If we do not proceed with this project, we will not be constructing an asset. And therefore, it won't be a capitalised cost to Council. It will be an operational cost borne by general revenue. Yeah, Councillor Lorentson: thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor Councillor Lorentson: Finzel, do you have any Speaker 4: verbal advice? We did know, we did in discussions with them, let them know that we had received verbal advice that would be accepted. But at the time of our meetings, we didn't have the written confirmation. Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Okay. I think Councillor Finzel, you may now have questions if you wish to talk.
02:42:00 Councillor Finzel: Oh, I'm still contemplating. I mean, I'd like to call for a break. It's 12.45. Oh, Deputy Mayor Stockwell: we normally finish an item before we Yeah, Councillor Finzel: I know. That's the chance. Speaker 2: It's the final item. Councillor Finzel: Yeah. Councillor Wegener: I would, I would, I would second that. Have a break. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Now, unless there's a procedural motion, I won't, because it's normal. We don't break until an item's been decided. And this is normal. Speaker 2: It's normal. I'll put a procedural motion for adjournment. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So, Councillor Phillips: is that what's Deputy Mayor Stockwell: We adjourned. If you can say till when? Councillor Phillips: I just need 10 minutes. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Is it 10 minutes or are we having the luncheon break? Councillor Phillips: Oh, I didn't think about that before I stood up. Um, just five minutes.
02:43:00 Oh, no, Councillor Lorentson: that doesn't work. Councillor Phillips: I actually just need a break. Councillor Wegener: I'll Councillor Finzel: second. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So, five minutes. Councillor Finzel: Okay. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So, yes. Councillor Finzel: So, Deputy Mayor Stockwell: it's been moved. It's been moved by Councillor Phillips and seconded by Councillor Wegener that the meeting be adjourned for a period of five minutes. Mayor Wilkie: Um, Deputy Mayor Stockwell: the Councillor Phillips can talk now to that motion. Councillor Phillips: I'm just getting a sense it probably should have been longer, but I think it has been a morning and, um, I have finished reading a book on making decisions during, um, war and times and they talk about silence and I think that's potentially where I was headed with a moment to pause and think. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Certainly. So, we're all happy. If anyone else wish to talk to it, uh, those in favour of the adjournment, um, since there's three old ghosts,
02:44:00 as I happen to use the casting vote. So, we'll be back at 12. Oh, sorry. The Chairman's done the, the, uh, four was Stockwell, Wegener, Lorentson Yeah, 12.
02:52:00 Speaker 1: Thank you. Councillor Finzel: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. And my understanding is everyone has talked to the motion other than Councillor Finzel. I think you have only asked questions. Would you like to talk to the motion? Councillor Finzel: Yeah, I've got a lot to say, but I know that's been okay. Yeah, good morning, afternoon. Thank you for the opportunity to speak to this. There's a lot of learnings in this. It's been a complex, convoluted and challenging project. I acknowledge the work of all the staff and the over and above that you've all done and the team I want that to be passed on.
02:53:00 I'd also like to thank the community for being involved and for making the time available to speak with staff, email each one of us and be proactively involved in what's happening in their street. I'd also like to thank my fellow councillors for the amount of time and effort that everyone has put in. I guess we all know that there's going to be losses and there's going to be wins. I guess in the role of leadership, it's about how do we challenge and question and eventually make decisions around ultimately where they fit. I acknowledge the strategy. From the walking and cycling strategy as the higher document speaking into this. There was a broad community engagement.
02:54:00 Everything in that strategy supported higher level decision-making. I like the idea that through this process and the extra work from the staff that there was a compromised position reached with the extra work and the further engagement. So I value the time spent regarding that matter and I do give that a lot of weighting. However, I do think I've got to as a leader in the space and make a very challenging decision rise to more those higher levels of what will speak to informing this decision. As we know, there's always risk, there's always wins. I'm standing at an intersection today that, you know, in hindsight, perhaps things could have been better navigated. And I think as a group, it's good to pause and review.
02:55:00 And I think this is a very good opportunity to look at like how we could have done this differently and inform how we move forward into the future. I understand that the pedestrian pathway at the 1.5 is not probably the higher standard where we're going in that higher level. Because we talk across the Shire, the whole of the Shire, about our health and well-being, access to, you know, connectivity, access for, you know, people on wheels. Access for mothers with prams, people on bikes. So I guess with all the things before us today, I think we can do better in terms of delivering what will become an asset of Noosa Shire Council now and into the future. We all know those assets like project about a 25 year forward.
02:56:00 I certainly do not want to support an asset that may not serve us effectively for the next 25 years forward. So based on the decision here before us today, I will not be supporting this Peregian Active Street update with the hope that we can diversify the funding to other projects within the Shire. Understanding also there is a cost back to Council with regards to monies that have to be re-delegated. Understanding also that there will be returning funds. And this is where the challenge lies from an economic perspective. But in the terms of the role of a leader, these are the challenging decisions we have to make. So following also strategic directions that have been ratified by Council that have included vast community engagement in the broader sense, but also acknowledging those technical expertise of our staff.
02:57:00 You know, I am not an infrastructure minister. I do not know those technical details and I rely on our well qualified staff to provide that information. So there's a lot of challenges again about prioritisation of projects. I have repeatedly brought this up in my two terms that I've spent from day one. I've asked repeatedly that we look at how we do this better with prioritisation of projects. I will continue to raise that matter because I think somewhere in all of this that has somehow also played into that. Yeah, I guess that's all I have to say right now and I guess thank you to everybody for listening. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Okay, I'll close.
02:58:00 I think I'm going to start with reiterating what the Acting Director told us. That we go back and we could start the design process again and look at this from new eyes and we're unlikely to come up with a different solution than what was put up initially. And I've heard the concern about a 1.5 metre footpath. And I just, there is a reason why it's only 1.5 metres. That's the reason why we didn't go for a shared pathway initially, is we're dealing with a highly constrained environment. That has to provide local services to people who live there and Shire-wide and regional services to the rest of our community. There is no win-win solution in this case. There was a statement made that the residents didn't ask for this project and I wholeheartedly disagree.
02:59:00 The local residents immediately abutting the project. Our Shire residents as a whole for many years have identified connectivity like this as the highest priority, not once, not twice, not three times, every time we've asked them since 2017. Highest priority is improving our cycle and pedestrian network connectivity. So when I think about leadership, I think about the challenge of having to represent the local community. So when I think about leadership, I think about the challenge of having to represent, sit here as a representative of the whole Shire and make decisions that may make some people worse off. And in this case, there are a few people who will think that they're worse off. There's no getting away from that. I understand it. And I also understand the question from Councillor Lorentson about will this proposal currently in the revised format address all the safety issues?
03:00:00 I think it's really clear, but I also hear the argument, and I know it's a real one in the community, that the community wants to see the whole connection into town. And it's a desirable aspect, but it shouldn't preclude you thinking about this in its current state, because there's nothing within the current proposal that prevents or precludes any of the projects. There's nothing that you'd redo. We can't redesign it and put in. It's a shared pathway. Because then we would be wiping out lots more car parking or trees or both. So what's in front of us is something that ostensibly provides safe pedestrian access and safe carriage for young children, people who are unconfident of riding on the road. So we have to think about that.
03:01:00 Are we making our decision based on all that Shire-wide input, all that moves to progressively improve our cycle and pedestrian network? And then there's the next aspect that was raised. If we don't proceed with anything, we are basically saying we have to review our budget and cut out something. Or potentially, if we don't want to cut it out, and we... You know, operational budget is going to be 100% that we agreed to have a deficit budget this year. So by not doing something, we're actually maybe killing two projects because the investment in the design of this process is not small biggies. It's extensive investment. Probably two or three of the projects that councillors put up combined sort of investment. So let's make this decision.
03:02:00 Let's make this decision on what's in front of us, understanding that, yes, we have already learnt the lesson that engaging the local residents more meaningfully earlier on is what's required, and we've put that into practice locally in Hilton Esplanade. But let's not make our decision based on what we would have liked to have happened. Let's make it based on a responsible decision about using the existing funds available to us that won't adversely affect other projects. And that makes an incremental step in connectivity and safety. And to me, the leadership required for that is to vote in favour of this motion. I put the vote. Those in favour. Councillor Wilson and Councillor Stockwell. Those against is Councillor Finzel, Wegener, Lorentson and Phillips. The motion is not carried. We had a foreshadowed motion. Councillor Lorentson: And I'll stand by.
03:03:00 But I'm seeking advice with wording from our director that council one not proceed. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: This is perfect. Are we happy that that's what you're after? And I'm just seeking guidance of councils, are you happy to do this one before we go for lunch? Or would you like. Councillor Wilson: I just want to ask a question. What happens with the active transport fund? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: OK, so because there are questions, I'm going to call. I'm going to call lunch and we'll deal with this when we return. Speaker 5: How long for? 20 minutes. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: 30 minutes.
03:36:00 Thank you. There was a motion that was moved but as yet seconded and Councillor Lorentson because it's fresh could you read your motion out please. Councillor Lorentson: That council A, note the report by the project manager to the general committee dated 10th of November 2026 and a further report to the ordinary meeting dated 19th of November 2026 regarding an update on the Fridgham Beach Active Street project and B, not proceed with coastal plant by stage 1 Fridgham Beach South and seek that the South East Queensland liveability funding be re-lapped 3 times.
03:37:00 I'll keep this really brief. We've had a lot of conversations, it's been a really long morning. I think, I just believe the decision that the motion in front of us is the right decision for Noosa and for Fridgham. The motion simply keeps the funding working for our community so rather than risk losing it we redirect it to another shuttle ready project, priority project. within our Shire. So the money stays here in Noosa and our residents still benefit and I'm going to just jot some stats that were given to us early in this debate.
03:38:00 52 properties were contacted during the week, 26 were home and the overall sort of consensus was 46% in support of the original proposal. 23% was cautious and then there was the rest, 31% that had hesitations or didn't respond. So I think the data alone, and also just the questions that have been raised by councillors and residents over the last week to me supports the motion that We've got in front as the responsible pathway. And I want to reiterate just what was raised by Tom and Jess in terms of that we need to give
03:39:00 Peregian essentially the time that it needs. Again I keep coming back to understand there is a transport cycle plan but the residents still are not clear in terms of how stage one connects to the village. They're not sure how all this is connected. Too many questions remain unanswered so this motion gives us the opportunity to get that part right and just reflect on the process over the last six months. I just ask everyone to support this alternative motion. I think it's just the right decision for Noosan and for the Peregian residents. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Anyone else like to talk to the motion? Councillor Wilson: Question please. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Sure. Councillor Wilson: Through the Chair, do we believe that the active transport fund that we've just had confirmation
03:40:00 that we could use for the scope variation? Would we be able to reallocate that as well? Speaker 4: I think it's very unlikely that the active transport fund could be reallocated. The process of getting the extension of time and change of scope through the Administrator was difficult and they were hesitant to put it further up the chain to the Truth Administrator's Office. Certainly we could ask the question before handing the money back. But it gets out more quickly. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Okay. Other people wish to talk? Who would you wish to close? Those in favour of the motion? That's Councillor Finzel, Wilson, Wegener, Lorentson and Phillips.
03:41:00 Those opposed would be Stockwell. The motion is carried. You can invite the Mayor back into the meeting room. Thank you. Thanks. Speaker 9: Thank you. Thanks. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you, Councillor Stockwell. This brings us to item 14, which is the confidential session. We have no items for the confidential session. Item 15 is the date of an extraordinary meeting. The extraordinary meeting will be at the Koran Memorial School of Arts Hall at 14 Kim Street,
14 CONFIDENTIAL SESSION ¶
Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.
15 NEXT MEETING ¶
03:42:00 Koran, at 12pm on Thursday 17 December 2026. I hope we'll see you all there and I declare the meeting closed.