Noosa Council Watch

An independent, unofficial record of Noosa Shire Council. About this site

Noosa Council meetings since 2014: papers, decisions and recordings, and from April 2023 the video cued to each item.

General Committee Meeting - 13 April 2026 Transcript

Monday 13 April 2026 · 2 hours 20 minutes of recording · 1,350 lines · 11 voices, 8 named

This is a machine transcript of council's recording, produced by automatic speech recognition and not checked line by line against the video. Councillor and place names are corrected where a human has approved the correction; everything else is what the model heard. Quote the recording, not this page — every timestamp below opens council's own video at that second. Recording © Noosa Shire Council; the transcript is ours, made from it so the meeting can be searched and read.

Speakers: the machine separated 11 voices and names 8 of them — only where the recording itself establishes who it is (they introduced themselves, were called on by name, or their voice matches meetings where they were). The others stay “Speaker N”. Hover a name to see why it is there.

Before the first item

00:00:00

00:00:00 Deputy Mayor Stockwell: We pay our respects to the thousands of years of leadership of the elders in the past, in the present, and those emerging who are always keen to work with Council to look after and care for Country. We don't have any apologies, but we do have a set of minutes from last month's General Committee meeting, meeting tool, moved by Councillor Wilkie, seconded by Councillor Finzel, presuming there's no discussion. All in favour? That's unanimous. There's no presentation, no deputations, no matters referred from Committee, so we move on straight to Section 8. And the first item in that section is a General Committee meeting schedule of Chairperson. And we have the Executive Officer, Yanchi, to come and give us an outline.

3 ATTENDANCE & APOLOGIES

▶ 00:00:07

Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.

2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COUNTRY

▶ 00:00:10

Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.

4 CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES

▶ 00:00:21

Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.

4.1 GENERAL COMMITTEE MEETING DATED 16 MARCH 2026

▶ 00:00:26

Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.

5 PRESENTATIONS

▶ 00:00:46

Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.

6 DEPUTATIONS

▶ 00:00:48

Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.

7 ITEMS REFERRED FROM COMMITTEES

▶ 00:00:51

Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.

8 REPORTS DIRECT TO GENERAL COMMITTEE

▶ 00:00:54

Nothing was transcribed under this heading — a stretch of the recording with no speech the model could make out.

8.1 GENERAL COMMITTEE MEETING - SCHEDULE OF CHAIRPERSON

▶ 00:00:58

00:01:00 Good afternoon, Councillors. Speaker 2: On 19 March 2026, Council resolved to amend its meeting structure, reducing formal meetings to one General Committee meeting and one Ordinary meeting, effected from the 1st of May 2026. As part of the change to the meeting structure, Council endorsed the implementation of a rotating schedule, for the Chairperson of the General Committee meeting, basically to provide all Councillors the opportunity to act as a Chairperson. Participation is not mandatory, and rotations were assigned by random draw. This report before you presents the schedule of Chairperson, as agreed by Councillors, for the period 1 May 2026 to 28 February 2028, when the next Liberal Government election is anticipated to occur. It is therefore recommended that Councillors note this report, and adopt the schedule of Chairperson before the General Committee meeting,

00:02:00 as provided in the report for the period 1 May 2026 to 28 February 2028. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Very good. Councillors, we will be involved. Does anyone have any questions? Ansel Larson. Councillor Lorentson: Just a question in terms of clarification. Are you happy that Section 8 of the General Committee meeting, Section 36.2 of the Standing Orders, which states if the Chairperson of a Standing Committee is absent or unavailable to preside, a Councillor chosen by the Councillors present will preside over the Standing Committee meeting? Are you happy that that cause doesn't need to be stated as part of this recommendation? My concern is John sees, for instance, if I'm going to take holidays in 2028 and when that period happens, just do we need any clarity around that situation in terms of leave, absence or illness?

00:03:00 Or are you confident that Section 36.2 of the Standing Orders covers that situation? Speaker 2: Yeah, I'm very confident that that section covers that point, because it basically provides that if a Chairperson is unavailable or absent, which obviously is very, very broad and can cover quite a few different scenarios, including private arrangements, so that section probably covers for the appointment of proxy as outlined, that all remaining Councillors present in the meeting can nominate a Chairperson as a proxy in that instance. Councillor Lorentson: Thank you very much. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Any others? Would someone like to move? I'm happy to move, Mr Chairman. I'm happy to second. Moved by Councillor Whoopi, seconded by Councillor Finzel. You're over the floor, Councillor Whoopi. Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: As discussed last month, this change to the two-meeting schedule is intended to be a more efficient form of decision-making

00:04:00 for the community and also this Council, and the rotating Chair idea was something that was being discussed and will give all Councillors an opportunity to hone their skills of chairing in the more robust forum, which is the General Committee. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Anyone else wish to speak? No? I'm presuming you don't want to argue with Selkirk. No, thank you, Mr Chairman. I'll put the motion in those in favour. I can't stay. That's unanimous. We then move on to the second item in Section 8, which is the Tourism Looser Funding at Palmerstead from 2026 to 2029, and we welcome Kim Rawlings, the Director of Sustainability and Environment, to the Chair. Kim, if you can give us an overview, please. Director Rawlings: Thanks, Councillors, and good afternoon. The Council report follows the Council meeting and decision in December, 18 December,

8.2 TOURISM NOOSA FUNDING AND PERFORMANCE DEED 2026–2029

▶ 00:04:40

00:05:00 where Council adopted the Tourism Looser Roadmap and endorsed what was known as Option 2 to evolve Tourism Looser to align with the Destination Management Plan. Also in December, Council adopted its Destination Management Plan. So this report... Sorry, that resolution required the CEO to bring a report back to Council with the final terms for the multi-year funding deed and to ensure that there was procurement guidance and support of the development of that process. This report responds to that resolution and brings back to you for consideration the detailed Tourism Looser Funding and Performance Deed. The adopted DMP... The DMP in December requires a shift towards destination stewardship, embedding community values, sustainability, behaviour change and measurable outcomes across the services that Tourism Looser deliver, including marketing, visitor services and industry capability. The funding deed, as attached, gives effect to this shift.

00:06:00 It seeks to preserve their service continuity but strengthens accountability, aligns programs and reporting to the DMP and clarifies roles and governance between Council and TN. The deed introduces a ranked KPI framework supported by a points-based performance adjustment methodology enabling Council to assess performance against KPIs and importance of. The deed was developed through a joint Council and Tourism Looser working group. It was guided by and reviewed by Council's internal legal council. It also has undergone independent external legal review. And as per Council resolution, Council procurement has advised on compliance with the local government framework and the principles. Councillors have been briefed on a number of occasions and received drafts and provided valuable input into the development of the process. So the report recommends the funding deed as attached

00:07:00 for Council consideration with Tourism Noosa for a term of three years commencing on the 1st of July, 2026. There is provision for the KPIs to be reviewed on an annual basis and it seeks authorisation for the CEO to finalise and execute the deed and administer the deed in accordance with the greatest terms. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Do we have any questions? Councillor Wilkie. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you for the report, Kim. Could you tell us a bit more about the external legal review, what they were looking at and checking for, please? Director Rawlings: Sure. We had... After the December meeting, we engaged with Procurement immediately and said provide Procurement all of the documentation. Procurement recommended an external legal firm to get involved. I can't think of the name, but I've been working with it.

00:08:00 It doesn't matter. And they have been involved right through the process. So they firstly reviewed the deed before the KPIs were developed and provided some great feedback, which has all been incorporated. I think they did that maybe twice, possibly three times. And then as the KPIs were being developed, versions of those were sent also to the legal firm to see that they were measurable, that they, you know, aligned and feedback was also given from that perspective, noting that they didn't provide feedback really on content, more structure, alignment, drafting, those sorts of things, in relation to the KPIs. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. OK. Any other questions? Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Lorentson: Can you confirm whether Council is legally committed to the three-year funding arrangement, is already legally committed, or is the funding still subject to Council endorsement of this report

00:09:00 and the attached funding deed? Speaker 2: Can you answer? Speaker 3: Oh, I'm happy to answer that. My understanding is that we've agreed to a three-year funding agreement. This deed is pursuant to how that funding is allocated in terms of KPIs and all over the term. So we have, in December this year, or last year, we agreed a three-year funding agreement that was in motion with the terms to be agreed, and this is what the terms are now before we program it. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Do you have a question, Councillor Wilson? No. Councillor Wilson: There's the advice from Governance on that. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: You haven't got a question? Councillor Lorentson: Can I rephrase the question? Can we perhaps, on notice, can you please come back to me with that?

00:10:00 Sure. Sure. Speaker 3: I'm happy to come back on that. My information differs as well. I haven't seen any information this morning, so. Councillor Lorentson: Thank you very much. Speaker 3: And as I said, that's my understanding. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Okay. Any other questions, Councillor? Councillor Phillips: I have a question. Just, I don't know if I can ask it. I was working here on the 18th of December, at the ordinary meeting I had leave planned, four months prior. Question to the CEO around that coming to the December meeting. Could you maybe explain to me, because I felt like I would have really liked to have been able to vote on that. No, Councillor. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: I'm not going to allow the question. It doesn't relate to the matter in front of us. It relates to history. Councillor Phillips: Okay. Can I rephrase the question? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: If it relates to this report and what we're dealing with today. Councillor Phillips: Oh, okay. Thanks. Yeah. Councillor Lorentson: I have a few questions that were sent to me by residents.

00:11:00 One was in reference to the council resolution in 2025, which required consultation with industry stakeholders and residents before any future funding decisions. My question is, how does the proposed three by $2 million per annum funding comply with that resolution? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Who are you all? We'll take it for the CEO. Speaker 3: I'm going to have to take that question on notice. Sorry. I'll be aware of that. Councillor Lorentson: It's part of the report. I'll just pull out the report. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: The CEO said he's taking it on notice. Sure. Any questions? Councillor Finzel: Yeah, sure. Thank you for the report. Firstly, on page 3 of 12, TN is, TN is, Council's longstanding LTO and key delivery partner.

00:12:00 I've raised this in the past around the funding. We've talked about evolving tourism NUSA. I feel like I haven't got an explicit answer in terms of- Deputy Mayor Stockwell: The question, please. Councillor Finzel: The question is, is L, is tourism NUSA continuing to operate as an LTO? Director Rawlings: So tourism NUSA is a local tourism organisation. Yes. In the hierarchy of tourism organisations, there is a regional tourism organisation which is Visit Sunshine Coast. Visit Sunshine Coast covers Sunshine Coast Council, NUSA Council and King Peer Council. And then there are local tourism organisations. Not all destinations have local tourism organisations. But destinations like ours that have a strong tourism industry do tend to have local tourism

00:13:00 organisations. And that's what tourism NUSA is. So in terms of structure and governance, yes, they are a local tourism organisation. If you were asking whether they operate from an influence perspective, they definitely have impact. You know, beyond a local tourism organisation. But in terms of governance and structure and hierarchy, they are an LTO. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: And then the question, Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: Yes, certainly. Sorry, it's on notice. Are you able to tell me, the LTOs, what sort of funding amounts do they receive? Director Rawlings: So I don't have that at hand. But Council have been provided that previously. As part of the benchmark. Yes. As part of the benchmarking that was done for the roadmap in December, we provided that information to Council. So happy to recirculate that.

00:14:00 Thank you. But it does, it varies. You know, most LTOs have a level of funding provided from their local council, local governments. LTOs do not tend to get state funding. State fund the RTO bodies. So most LTOs get funding from their local governments and also their membership base. Okay. But in terms of what each of them get, yeah, there was a schedule and a benchmarking process done and provided to Council in December. So happy to recirculate that. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Any other question? Councillor Finzel: Yes. Just from memory, was that confidential or open to the public? Director Rawlings: That's a great question, Councillor Finzel. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Can you take that on notice? I can. It's not really related to the matter in practice. It's related to the history of the matter. I think there was a version that we made public. Director Rawlings: But I'm happy to check that.

00:15:00 Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Any other questions? Speaker 2: No? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: I'll move to staff recommendation. Speaker 2: Oh, thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So, Councillors, we have agreed to enter into this agreement through the roadmap process and the staff have actioned the motion from December. So I'm happy to check that. Next, I would like to introduce a deed that has been negotiated both with councilors and involvement of councilors and with the relevant working group, Op Tourism Noosa. The deed does reflect what was expected from the roadmap and what was adopted as actions in the Destination Management Plan. It sets out the transition to an organisation that is a partner in delivering the Destination Management Plan with enhanced accountability measures, enhanced key performance indicators, and a changed payment structure that overtly includes a payment in second and third year related to the satisfactory completion of the previous year's work.

00:16:00 So in that regard, the agreement before us is completely consistent with the adopted position of Council and therefore I urge your support. Others wish to talk? Would you like to read out what the change is? Councillor Wilson: Yes, so it's clause 4.3 in the deed and I assume you want to delete some of the content there.

00:17:00 So we will just read as parties may review and adjust the funding whether an increase or decrease in the next general grant occurs at the end receiving this substantial sustainable alternative source of funding. Any adjustment to the funding under this clause must be reasonable. Reasonably proportionate to the financial impact of the alternative funding resource and must be agreed in writing by the parties that are setting that funding apart. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: We have a seconder. Seconder, Councillor Phillips. Talk to your amendment please, Councillor Phillips. Councillor Wilson: This agreement is between Council and TN with a commitment to debugging TN for three years via general rates collected through differential rates on businesses. We've talked about how that applies. It applies to the general rates many times over this process. At this point, we do not expect this to change. TN needs certainty and we need to be able to commit to using general rates to fund this agreement.

00:18:00 If Council finds a new income source, it's not relevant to this agreement. If TN finds a new income source, it's meeting its revenue diversification goal and of course we would have a discussion about that source if it happens. Having said that, we shouldn't reference the bed tax. It doesn't exist in Queensland. It is pre-empting a council position that we haven't reached yet or may never reach. If the source of income becomes so great that TN isn't reliant on council anymore, then both parties have the option to end the agreement. But we should not pre-empt the types of income that may occur to a third party, particularly when they are not currently legal as there is no council position to refer to. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: I just wish to talk to the bill. I will. Councillor Phillips: I'm happy to support the amendment. Bed tax is not currently lawful for local government in Queensland to implement, either directly or indirectly.

00:19:00 And the Local Government Act does not expressly authorise a bed tax. General powers under the LG Act are unlikely to support the creation of a new tax already. And so my thoughts are that this takes, I was taking away some risk that I believe that would be included if we had it. So I'm looking to support the amendment and the changes. Mayor Wilkie: Chair. Councillor Woolley. The council is quite right. It is not, there is no bed tax in Queensland currently. There are other councils that are working in collaboration with us. They are working with each other and the State Government to bring one in as an option for councillors to consider. But my understanding is that was only introduced in this clause as an example of something that may happen. I don't think it substantially changes the intent of this clause.

00:20:00 And as Councillor Nicola Wilson said that we do need to give TM some certainty and removal of this clause in here in no, in my opinion, in no way affects the intent of this clause or the certainty that the funding deed will deliver to tourism and the industry. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Chair. I just wish to talk. Just a question to staff. You've had this in advance. Are you happy that it doesn't materially affect the agreement? Director Rawlings: Yes, absolutely. It's just an example. So nothing else. Yes. Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Anyone else wish to talk? No. Councillor Wilson used to close. Councillor Wilson: No. I've said it so many times. It would have stopped there. Okay. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: I'll put the motion or the amendment. That's unanimous. So the amendment becomes part of the substantive motion.

00:21:00 Councillor Lorentson: I'd like to move an amendment, please, through the chair. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Lorentson: That clause for be amended. That clause for be amended. To include a new provision requiring that the funding deed and associated deliverables may be reviewed and adjusted where a material external shock occurs that significantly impacts the visitor economy, including but not limited to sustained increases in fuel costs, significant changes to aviation capacity or routes, natural disasters, or a sustained downturn in tourism demand. Any such review must allow Council and the parties to jointly consider whether funding levels, priorities, KPIs, or delivery expectations require adjustment to ensure the agreement remains realistic, fair, and aligned with prevailing economic, aviation, and market

00:22:00 conditions, and continues to deliver value for money and effective outcomes under changed circumstances. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Do we have a seconder for that? Councillor? Councillor Wilson. Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Lorentson: The amendment ensures that the funding deed remains flexible, practical, and responsive to changing economic and global conditions that are outside the control of either party. The tourism industry is highly sensitive to external factors such as fuel prices, aviation capacity, route availability, natural disasters, and broader global economic conditions as we're currently seeing. These factors directly influence visitor demand, market access, and the effectiveness of destination marketing investment. In periods of significant change, including sustained downturns in demand or reduced aviation capacity, it's important that our funding arrangements remain aligned with what is realistic

00:23:00 and effective in prevailing conditions so that rate-based funds continue to deliver genuine value for money and measurable outcomes. This amendment ensures that there's a clear and transparent mechanism for Council and the parties to jointly review whether there's adjustments needed in response to materially changed circumstances. Basically, threw it in there to strengthen the deed by ensuring that the agreement remains adaptable, accountable, and capable of delivering effective results for the community over the term of the agreement, even in periods of significant external disruption. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Anyone else wish to talk to the amendment? Councillor Wegener. Councillor Wegener: Question. So what I worry about is if all of a sudden, TN has contracts, has employees, has their budget set.

00:24:00 And what I worry about is if all of a sudden, TN has contracts, has employees, has their Councillor Lorentson: That is the intent of the cause that we have the agility and flexibility to consider how much we're funding, to review KPIs, to review our performance measurements, to align. So, yes, that's the intent. Councillor Wegener: I'll speak to it. When we first became councillors, I think about six years ago, Noosa was facing the pandemic, and one of the most heartening things I ever felt from Noosa Council was when Brenda Chastel says, we will not fire anybody, everybody on our team, and never are we going to buckle and worry and panic and cut employees.

00:25:00 I thought that was a really proud moment. I just thought, I'm joining a good team, and this is so solid. So, I worry about the legalities, first off, of this cause, whether it's legal or enforceable, and two, I like to, you know, we make a strong decision on something, we commit to it. We've committed to so many things, we commit to this. So, I'm not sure if I'll support it. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Question? Yes, Lukey. Mayor Wilkie: The intention of this, is the intention of this amendment, that is, there being capacity to review the defunding deed, if there is an external shock, already catered for in the wording of the defunding deed? Director Rawlings: Not really.

00:26:00 So, there's a clause for, which is the clause that councillors have just filled an amendment for, which does talk about an opportunity to review, based on an external event that relates to revenue, more broadly, no. So, councillor Lorentson did circulate this, and I did provide some initial feedback, but I've since got some feedback from our legal counsel, and apologies to councillor Lorentson, only just recently. But, essentially, she has advised that, potentially, what this could be is a force majeure clause, which would be a standard clause, to go into a deed. Councillor Lorentson: Which I did request during the workshops, Kin. Director Rawlings: Okay, so. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Yes, councillor, the director's got the floor, but he's no communicator. Director Rawlings: We can draft a force majeure clause, and bring that back, maybe, and for inclusion, that would be a standard process. But that's essentially what this is about. If there are external events that are outside the control of parties, that affect, like pandemic, like war, like shortage of supplies, essential, you know, natural disasters,

00:27:00 then there is a clause by parties to be able to review the clause. So, yeah, that would probably be the better way to do this, which would pick up all the things that you're looking to achieve. Councillor Lorentson: So, through the chair, in that case, I'd like to withdraw this amendment, and then come back at the ordinary meeting with the clause that was recommended, the force majeure clause, recommended by our in-house counsel. I'm happy with that. It achieves the same result. Thank you. Sure. Director Rawlings: If the council has drafted something, then I'll circulate that to councillors. Councillor Lorentson: Thank you very much. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So, councillors, up to the whole council to agree to withdraw a motion. We'll do it by a show of hands, those in favour of withdrawing the motion.

00:28:00 That's unanimous. Okay. We have only had councillor Stockwell talk to this. Have we got anyone else who wish to talk to the motion? Councillor Wilson. Councillor Wilson: In May last year, council was presented with a report at a special meeting. Councils had signalled they were not comfortable extending the existing agreement with TM for over two years. The report at the special meeting presented the option of a 12-month agreement. Thank you. In that 12 months, council would determine the future of the relationship with TM. However, the recommendation also included an instruction from the council to co-create a roadmap for TM, detailing council's future expectation of TM's role, structure, future focus and actions, and further funding arrangements. TM's second payment within the 12-month agreement was conditional on delivering this roadmap.

00:29:00 This clause gave us no opportunity to end the agreement after 12 months. It pre-empted an ongoing relationship. Having TM involved in writing the roadmap did not allow us to objectively review council's needs and alignment with TM's services. It was just a tweak of the status quo. Notably, while council was to co-create the roadmap, councillors were not involved. That 12-month agreement has turned into a four-year commitment by itself. The decision should have only been on the 12-month agreement. That meeting was made- Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So, councillor, I'm pulling you up. Thank you. Okay. Councillor Wilson: The meeting was made also committed council to consult with industry stakeholders and residents regarding any proposed funding decisions for TM. That never happened. Councillor Phillips: Suggesting that consultation with the DMD cover this specifically, industry stakeholders

00:30:00 Councillor Wilson: and residents need to be specifically consulted about the dollar amount, the length of agreement, and its funding for our community. The questions in the DMD cover the following three points. The DMD survey was not enough to get a reliable response, with questions about funding being mixed in with questions about the types or levels of marketing. However, we did get some level of sentiment towards destination marketing in the community insights report. 55% wanted to review public funding of tourism. 47% to implement values-based marketing. 35% to diversify destination marketing. 87% wanted to maintain the current level of public funding of tourism marketing. 31% wanted to stop public funding. And 35% wanted to stop promoting news to Shire to visitors altogether. How does this see reflected to the community's wishes? The ordinary meeting of December 25 asked council to approve the roadmap in accordance with the requirements of the current 12-month deed, prior to us ever receiving these insights, and with the most specific community or industry engagement. The 12-month deed should never have committed us to anything beyond that 12 months.

00:31:00 When councils only have two days to prepare for these meetings, it's not always clear that the support is made up of unintended consequences. At the December meeting, I repeatedly asked what we were committing to, whether it was a preferred option, roadmap, the $2 million per year, or the three years, and could not get a straight answer. Councillor Phillips: I'm going to request a legal process review to examine this process. Councillor Wilson: The process leading to last May was delayed due to significant delays in producing the TMP. The preferred option was for the tourism news to evolve in alignment with the TMP. Therefore, we would expect the goals and KPIs in this document to align with the TMP, Councillor Phillips: but there are no clear KPIs in the TMP to align to. Councillor Wilson: The priorities, KPIs, and metrics referred to in Schedule 1 are not KPIs, and I've made this clear many times, and even offered to run a training session on KPIs since I used to teach this as a form. Similarly, KPIs must meet the SMART criteria, Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Timely.

00:32:00 They are aligned to strategic goals, not everyday tasks. KPIs are numerical measures, and you set improvement targets year-on-year or quarter-by-quarter. The completion of routine tasks is not a KPI, nor should it form part of an incentive program for financial reward. Delivering full marketing campaigns a year should be core business, but the performance aspect is the success of those campaigns. The performance adjustment of $350,000 means that TMP can achieve fewer of these core projects, and can still receive $1.65 million in ratepayer funds. Revenue diversification. TMP can meet the KPI that defines $1.00 revenue. It does not have to achieve a particular figure, only to report on it. Business cases must be presented. There is no requirement for them to be implemented, or anything about the quality, just deliver the report. The website must be refreshed, but there are no metrics on how it performs. Deliver final quotes for corporate events, but no metrics on whether those events go ahead, or their success. None of these KPIs are measuring TMP performance in its core business for any stretch to deliver

00:33:00 aspects of the TMP. The TMP does not specify that the TMP will receive funding to deliver any specific initiatives, if the TMP's identity policy on tourism is lacking on its key relationship. I can't support a TMP that is lacking in accountability to our community, and does not have the required consultation. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Anyone else wish to talk to the motion? Councillor Phillips: I'll speak to it. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor Phillips. Councillor Phillips: Thank you. My concern with the deed is governance. It's not the intent, not effort, it's just governance. Because the deed does more than allocate funding. It embeds the DMP into housing. And it does that before the strategy itself has been properly tested.

00:34:00 And that's where the problem starts for me. Because once you link funding to a strategy in this way, you're no longer just supporting it. You're locking it in. When we're being asked to commit $2 million per year of rate pay and money, that comes with an obligation to be certain, not hopeful, that the strategy we are funding will deliver to the TMP. And at this point, for me, that doesn't exist. There has been no demonstrated modelling that shows the economic impact across the Shire. There is no clear evidence of how this will affect different sectors, including the small and local businesses. And for me, there's been no meaningful assessment of unintended consequences. In a community as diverse as ours, that matters. Because what benefits one part of the economy does not automatically benefit all. And that needs to be tested. Not assumed. Instead, the framework does... What it does is measure alignment to the TMP.

00:35:00 Not outcomes. Not impact. Alignment. And that has created a structural problem, in my opinion. Because once alignment becomes the measure of success, the system begins to reinforce it. The TMP sets the direction. The deed requires alignment. And the KPIs measure alignment. And the reporting confirms the alignment. But nowhere does the TMP set the direction. Nowhere in that process is a clear, independent mechanism that asks, is the strategy actually working? So for me, it's a closed governance loop. And a closed loop carries risk. It creates a situation where funding can continue regardless of outcomes. Where strategies can continue without being properly tested. And where issues are identified too late, not early enough, to correct the course. The consequence of this doesn't sit in this room. It will actually sit in the community. And there is also a second layer for me that relates to Tourism Noosa. They are being funded to deliver council-aligned outcomes while also operating with constraints

00:36:00 that limit public criticism of council. And that matters because it affects independence. If the organisation responsible for delivering a strategy is not in a position to openly challenge it, then one of the key safeguards in good governance is weakened. Effective governance relies on independent challenge. It relies on the ability to test assumptions, to raise issues early, and question direction when needed. This structure will reduce that. I've also been told that the TMP can evolve over time. But when funding, KPIs, and reporting are going to be built around alignment to a strategy, that becomes difficult in practice. You're not just updating a document. You're then trying to shift an entire performance and funding framework. That's why I've been told that the TMP can evolve over time. That's not flexible. It's going to be constrained. So when you step back and look at this as a whole, the issue has become clear to me. We're being asked to commit significant ongoing public funding to a strategy that has not

00:37:00 been independently tested within a structure that reinforces alignment rather than outcomes and that limits the mechanisms that would normally challenge to improve it. This is not whether tourism is important, because it is, and this is not to me whether Tourism Noosa is capable, because I believe they are a professional, experienced and credible organisation. This is where we are as Council. I have met the standard required to allocate public funds in the best interest of this whole community, and that standard for me is very clear. Decisions must be evidence based. They must be transparent, and they must be accountable. And right now, we're in the middle of a crisis. And right now, that threshold has not been met. Because without clear evidence of whole or Shire benefit, without understanding sector impacts, and without testing unintended consequences, this is not evidence based decision making. It's assumptions. I do not support walking in ongoing funding based on assumption, so the position is straightforward

00:38:00 for me. The deed funds the implementation of a strategy, and the question is not whether Tourism Noosa can deliver it. The question is whether there is sufficient evidence that the strategy they are being asked to deliver will benefit the entire community. And at this point, that has not been demonstrated. Without that, it is not appropriate to link ongoing ratepayer funding to its success. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Who else would like to talk to the motioner? Councillor Wegener: With Jess, just to answer my question. I would like to take on that is we voted the DMP in. And so that status quo that we have. And the DMP absolutely depends on Tourism Noosa for its success. So they're one and the same in a way, that they actually need to work on each other.

00:39:00 This is my understanding of Tourism Noosa. Because in order to achieve the goals of the DMP, we can't do it. Council can't do it. Council press can't do it. We know we can't do it. We actually need the groups around us marching shoulder-to-shoulder as it is. It's almost like we're coming out of the trenches shoulder-to-shoulder, ready to face the future. That seems pretty dim in this world. So I kind of go back and step back and say the DMP is here. We have a new vision. This, and Tourism Noosa has fantastically done a great job over the past 20 years. Overall, they do a really good job. This is, the deed here, is the deed which changes the direction, changes how Tourism Noosa is going to work in order to supplement, implement the DMP. Because without it, we're not going to go anywhere with the DMP.

00:40:00 And that's why I support it. We just, we've made a decision. We've set our end. We've taken off. We have to follow through. And it's a good vision. The DMP is a positive vision for the future. And that's what this Council has committed to. So I think that I'm going to follow through with our commitment to implement the ideas and the thoughts put forward in the DMP, because they are genuinely good. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Do you wish to talk? No? Mayor Wilkie: May I wish to close, Mr Chair? I shall. Councillor Lorentson: Today, the question for me is not whether we can enter into this funding arrangement, but whether we should commit to it in its current form. We've been asked to commit $2 million of public funds per year for three years.

00:41:00 A total of $6 million of ratepayer money. This is a significant long-term commitment that demands long-term commitment. It's a very, very high standard of clarity, certainty and assurance around outcomes. The key issue for me is the KPIs. KPIs must be strong enough, measurable enough and enforceable enough to justify this level of public investment. I have concerns that they are not sufficiently outcome focused and may not provide a clear or objective basis to assess value for money over time. I don't think we can do that. Further, funding is largely guaranteed with only limited performance adjustment mechanism. Year one is paid in full regardless of performance and KPIs can be reviewed and amended annually by mutual agreement. This raises a fundamental concern as to whether we're dealing with a fixed accountability

00:42:00 framework or a shifting set of measures over time. That matters because this is public funding. Regardless of its source, once it's committed through council, it becomes public money. And the community expects transparency, accountability and clear, measurable outcomes. I have also concerns around the consultation. And I'm going to reference, I think it's page six of the report in front of us. G. Ensure any future proposed funding decisions for tourism and tourism. NUSA include consultation with industry stakeholders and residents, ensuring transparency and input into strategic investment in NUSA tourism's future. I'm not convinced that this has occurred in a meaningful way for this specific three-year funding commitment.

00:43:00 While there has been broader consultation through DMP process, that's not the same as the community being asked to consider a clear consultation process. I'm not convinced that there has been a clear and explicit six million dollar funding decision over three years. That distinction matters because it goes directly to public trust and confidence in how council makes decisions of this scale. We're also operating in a period of global uncertainty with rising fuel costs, aviation volatility, and shifting demand continuing to impact local businesses. In that environment, council needs funding arrangements that are robust, flexible, and capable of reaching the needs of local businesses. The funding agreement locks council into a fixed three-year commitment without, in my opinion, adequate safeguards for changing conditions, without sufficiently strong performance measures, and without the level of consultation I would expect for a decision of this magnitude. This is not about intent, and it's not about any organisation.

00:44:00 It's about whether this deed as a governance instrument meets the standards of the NUSA standard I require as a councillor when committing significant public resources. The question to me, again, is not whether the arrangement is possible, it's whether it's responsible. Good governance requires confidence in the detail, clarity on performance, meaningful consultation, and a clear demonstration that public funds deliver value for money over time. The KPIs are not strong enough. The accountability framework is not clear. And we do not have the level of certainty required for a commitment of this scale. When there is that level of uncertainty around performance measures and governance settings, it is appropriate and it is responsible to pause and reconsider whether the current framework is the right one going forward.

00:45:00 In that context, in my opinion, the best course may be to step back and reset to ensure that we get the governance framework right. If today the decision is not to approve the funding deed, then that is what it is. That is part of responsible decision making. Arrangements evolve when they are no longer the right fit. And sometimes the most responsible path forward is not refinement of what exists, but the opportunity to design something clearer, stronger, and more fit for purpose for the future, and one that truly meets the expectations of our residents and our local businesses. I therefore cannot in good faith support the report and the deed in front of us. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Any others? Mayor Wilkie: Mr Chairman. Councillor Willey. Councillors, what we have before us is following through on the commitment to deliver on the

00:46:00 outcomes of the destination management. This was a ratified decision of the Noosa Council. This local government has endorsed the destination management plan. This Tourism Noosa funding and performance deed is a key part to delivering on some of the key actions and outcomes of the destination management plan, as promised to this community by the decision we made as a local government last year. It is easy enough to say to a local government that this decision was made by the local government on whether or not the KPIs are adequate enough, or the process has been robust, or the governance has been sufficient. That's one thing. It's another thing entirely to read this report and be assured about the governance and the reviews and the partnership and the integrity that has gone into putting this funding deed together. I hear a lot of people say that they support evidence-based decision-making.

00:47:00 The evidence before us is that the process that has gone into getting us to where we are has been robust. We've had internal legal review. We've had external legal review. We've had procurement support the whole process and assess this deed in terms of its relevance to the Local Government Act, specifically in relation to transparency and good governance. There is more than enough opportunity to amend the process. We need to review this funding deed as we progress through the three years. Councillors, do not gamble with the future of this community. This funding deed is integral to ensuring that the things we love about Noosa withstand the pressures that we're going to be facing through increased massive population growth

00:48:00 in South East Queensland, influx of visitation in the lead-up to COVID. It's the cost of the 2032 Olympics. To say we need to delay and rebuild from ground up, in my opinion, is obstructionist and irresponsible and doesn't give the community and the industry the certainty that they deserve. We're here to make decisions. We've got, I don't recall any instance where there's been so much governance, internal We have internal and external legal review, procurement involved around any funding deed that Council has entered into before. Councillors, you've had your input into this, you've attended workshops on this. Yes, just because our input during these workshops, all of it isn't reflected in the documents that come before this Council, does not in any way diminish their value or the integrity of the process. We have excellent staff who are community members who are just as invested in this working as we are,

00:49:00 as the industry is, as the residents are. Councillors, don't gamble with the future of this community. Let's not delay anymore. Let's not give anyone cause to think that there's an obstructionist game being played here. Let's just get on with this. Make the decision with the community. Expect us to make. Endorse this because we have endorsed the Destination Management Plan and this is integral to the delivery of the Destination Management Plan. Thank you. Councillor Finzel: I just have a question. Given the uncertainty around the table and comments and questions that have come to the table, this process has been increasingly categorised and characterised by complexity and rapid change externally and locally and abroad.

00:50:00 So my question is, to address that changing landscape and uncertainty around future at so many levels of which we're all aware, is there an opportunity to provide some assurity of being able to progress this forward and perhaps instead of, can we amend it instead of for three years, could we make it for one year? Can we test an amendment on that? Speaker 3: So who was that question? Councillor Finzel: So number A, like could we explore or debate the idea of approve it for one year as opposed to three years?

00:51:00 Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Is that Luke's question or is it Ruth's question? Councillor Finzel: Through the Chair and the CEO. Speaker 3: I think we have to look back on three years. I think we have to look back on why the decision was taken for a three year agreement. It's to give certainty to the organisations, both organisations. So to take it back to one year and we have, I've looked at the documentation, we have in December last year we made a commitment for a three year funding agreement with the intent then to work through and develop a feed which is then before you decide today. But it's based on, we based it on a three year agreement. Again, to take it back to one year, I'm not sure that that would be acceptable to Tourism Noosa

00:52:00 because they are reliant on funding, as we know, for their ongoing business operations. So I just think that to take it back to one year at this point, would be quite, quite regressive and difficult and would take some time for us to go back and I'm not sure that we would get to a point where we're able to provide certainty for any organisation going forward. Councillor Wegener: Thanks for the question. We've talked about the abomination that Councillor Wegener went through at the CIO. Okay. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: A question then to Councillor Wegener. Would you like to make a comment around the idea of making an amendment on item number A as per your previous question? Councillor Wegener: We, one of our things that we did was we hung the Tourism Noosa and other groups out so

00:53:00 badly at one time in our term that we need that security, I think that they really need that security in order to do what they need. They need the deal or else we're right back to where we are. Councillor Lorentson: Point of order. Councillor Wegener: Yes, what's your point of order? Councillor Lorentson: Point of order is there's commentary, not a question being asked and Councillor Wegener's already spoken. I'm confused as to this process. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Yes, it is difficult, but he was asked a question and his response related to that question is unusual. It did take the form of an additional argument, but it was a question and he did answer it. Anyway, thank you. Thank you. Councillor Phillips, I saw your hand up. Councillor Phillips: I think it was just a question for the CEO around if it goes to one year, the KPI's tied to DMP.

00:54:00 Would it be tricky because DMP is meant to be a 10 year ongoing? Absolutely. Speaker 3: We have to get back and readjust and re-look at all of that. Councillor Lorentson: And I would also, through the CEO, would a one year amendment also possibly be ultra virus? Not ultra virus, but would it be not in keeping with the intent of the report in front of us, which is tied to three years? Speaker 3: Absolutely. Councillor Lorentson: That would be my opinion. That would be my opinion. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Okay. So I think you've got several questions for Councillor Finzel. Thank you. Would you like to talk to the motion? Councillor Finzel: I know. Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Okay. So I'll close. So Councillors, there's been a range of matters raised which are only marginally related

00:55:00 to the decision in front of us. The assertion that we need more information is highly contestable. Never in the history of Noosa, and probably in Australia, has as much research been done on the local tourism industry as what we've done since we started the destination management plan process. The information that Councillor Phillips seeks is very well covered within the first draft paper that went out to the community and had huge response, which gave Council a very clear idea of where to go. We have a concept that strategies shouldn't lead agreements with co-deliverers, which is the opposite of the real world. I can recommend a very good book called Network Government, and that's what we're doing here.

00:56:00 We recognise that to do the destination management plan, we have to have a network of co-deliverers. With any complex sustainability problem, if you don't bring the key stakeholders and the key industry along with you, you are doomed to failure. Now, it's not a surprise to me that three Councillors who didn't take part in the decision both for the destination management plan have talked about this notion. But that's not the decision in front of us. The decision in front of us is, are we agreeing to the deed that complies with what was requested by us in the road map? And the answer is yes. We've had talks about KPIs and what KPIs should be, and what Councillor Wilson pointed out as what, in her world of financial management and business, what KPIs are, it may be perfectly legitimate. In different worlds, key performance indicators mean different things. And as a person who teaches at university level and has paid as a consultant to do these

00:57:00 things, they can be very widely interpreted. Yes, we can look at the KPIs in this agreement and say, there's not a whole lot of outcomes specified. But that is, once again, linked back to the point that we're looking at Tourism Noosa to collaborate with Council. And their industry and our community to drive forward to achieve these outcomes that can't be done by one individual organisation on its own. To suggest that we don't, as councillors, have enough knowledge of what the community and stakeholders desire and don't desire in this means you haven't been doing your job. There's been no other issue prosecuted as much as this one, and we know there are upsides. But what we're certain of is that this organisation, historically funded by a specific levy, which

00:58:00 was transferred into a rate of the dollar for businesses and tourism enterprises, is still funded by businesses and tourism enterprises. Okay? So, councillors, to me this is a really straightforward suggestion. We have had a subcommittee of tourism nurses. They're working with our staff and their expertise. But we as councillors have been involved in numerous workshops in every step of the way. Our access to these reports and providing input is unmatched in Queensland. Unmatched. The level of consultation that staff have with councillors. So don't use that as an argument because it's a fallacious one. Councillors, very simple. Improve the roadmap and honour the agreements that we've made over time. Or, if you don't support it, it brings council's reputation into disrepute.

00:59:00 I put the motion. Those in favour? That's councillors Wilkie, Wegener and Stockwell. Those against? It's councillors Wilson, Phillips, Lorentson and Finzel. The motion's lost. We move on. Do we have an alternative motion that someone wishes to move? Councillor Wegener: Sorry, an alternative motion to... Deputy Mayor Stockwell: I'll move it. That the matter of the tourism noose funding agreement be referred to the ordinary meeting on Thursday of this week. I'll second it. Thank you. Thank you. Does anyone wish to discuss the motion? No. It's just a deferral motion. Mayor Wilkie: I support the motion because I think it gives this local government an opportunity to have

01:00:00 an internal workshop on the repercussions of not approving the tourism noose funding deed and what that means for the industry and the future of this community. Councillor Wilson: Point of order. This sounds like you're trying to influence our votes. We've already voted here to the next lot. Oh no, no. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Yeah, that motion's lost. It's now the items. There has to be a motion on the item. So this is a new motion. The motion is a procedural one to refer it to the ordinary meeting. Councillor Lorentson: Can I exceed, please, some governance advice on that? Sure. And can we maybe adjourn until we get that advice, please? Sure. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Yep. I'm happy to. I'm happy to. Because you're doing it without a... Yep. Councillor Lorentson: Happy to move for it to adjourn after Councillor Finzel's question. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Don't have to move it. I'm happy as a chair. The chair's put it on adjournment? Yeah. Speaker 1: I didn't do it on adjournment. Councillor Wegener: Thank you.

01:17:00 Speaker 1: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Okay, welcome back. During the adjournment, the CEO had a chance to discuss the matter with governance and the question was whether the motion to, procedural motion to defer to the ordinary meeting was in accordance with standing orders. So, Mr. CEO, do you have a view on that now? Speaker 3: So, the process, and we've just had an adjournment to discuss this with our governance team and to look at the standing orders. The process is that the motion went forward. It was lost. So, therefore, there's still nothing to take forward in terms of going, so we need to have another motion.

01:18:00 Now, whether that's a procedural motion or an alternate motion is by far acceptable in my understanding. And, the Chair has put up a procedural motion as the first. Now, it hasn't been, has it been, seconded? Seconded, yes, it has. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Seconded, yes. Speaker 3: Before we then went into adjournment. So, that's the position currently, is, because it was lost, it then goes into a, into a, we still need a motion that's, that's to take forward to our ordinary meeting, because it's a general meeting. Remember, this is not the final deciding, deciding, decision, last decision. Councillor Lorentson: Through the CEO, just for clarity, what section in the standing orders states that a procedural motion can be moved after a decision's made?

01:19:00 My understanding, it has to be done during the debate, before a decision's made. Can you just state what section in the standing order you're referring to? Speaker 3: Yeah, because there was no decision taken, that's the advice I've been given, there's no decision taken, so the procedural motion is 31, but there's no decision taken so it's open to consideration. Councillor Lorentson: Can I have a reference please, what section in the Standing Orders states that a procedural motion can be moved once a decision has been made? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So I'll answer it as the Chair, and this will be my ruling, and you can vary from it. My ruling is the decision hasn't been made. A motion was put up which was lost, so there is no decision on the books in regard to the item in front of us.

01:20:00 Mayor Wilkie: If there was a motion that Council not approve the Tourism Noosa Funding and Performance Deed as read, that would be considered a motion? Yes. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: So the Council could have considered any motion, I put it around, there was no one at hand so I did the ontological thing. So at the moment we are proceeding on the basis that the motion to defer to the ordinary meeting is a legitimate motion, it's open to the meeting to either vote for it or against it. Mayor Wilkie: But the point is you're making Mr Chair is that, whether it's this one or another motion, some sort of motion needs to be ratified by this, the majority of these councillors to go to the ordinary meeting and appear on the ordinary meeting agenda. That's correct. Councillor Wegener: Sorry.

01:21:00 Question. Yes. So could it be that to say, we say that nothing was decided, we're not going to fund that, we don't want to pursue the deed, and would that be the motion? Is that an example of a motion that would be made that confirms, basically you have to confirm that you did not vote for the deed? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: That would be an option if the current procedural motion falls. Councillor Lorentson: I'm not going to support the procedural motion in front of us because I have an alternative motion that I would like to test. And I've circulated it to all the councillors some time ago. Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Anyone else? Oh. I just, the, I'll get, I don't, I'm sorry.

01:22:00 It is a procedural motion. They all can talk to it. Anyone else wish to talk to the procedural motion? Councillor Phillips: I'll speak to it. I won't support this because I would prefer to see if there's an alternative motion. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Sure. Thank you. Okay. Councillor Finzel: Well, just to clarify, we're voting now on the procedural motion to take it to. Yes. I have a question just for clarification for the Chair and the CEO. In terms of the standing orders, can you confirm that we are unable to pull it out of the ordinary meeting? If it just moves forward today without the motion? Speaker 3: We need to have, my understanding, and this is with respect to what you just said, we still need to have something that we take to ordinary. So whether that's the procedural motion or whether it's an alternate motion, that then goes to ordinary. At ordinary, we've got the ability then, you've got the ability, to pull it back out and read

01:23:00 it again or discuss. Councillor Lorentson: Yeah, that's fine. Thank you. Speaker 3: Okay. But we need to have something to take forward. This, the standing orders are quite silent on this, but because there's nothing on the books, it's open to a motion. And whether that's a procedural motion or an alternate, it's available to us. So this is my advice that I'm going to provide. Councillor Wilson: Question. Speaker 3: Can I have a council person and council member? Councillor Wilson: Just a correction. It says general committee. To vote to the general committee. To the ordinary meeting. And then we'll meet up to a date, don't we? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Yeah. And if you can. Councillor Wilson: Sorry. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: And it's April 16th. Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Lorentson: I have section 31.1 of our standing orders in front of me. It states very clearly, 31.1 procedural motions. A councillor at a meeting of council may, during the debate of a matter at the meeting, move as a procedural motion, following motions.

01:24:00 That's the procedural motion. I think it's very clear that I'm still challenging whether a procedural motion can be moved after the debate. It says very clearly during the debate of a matter. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Okay. I'll take that as a point of order. And I've given my ruling on it before, which I disagree with that view. Okay. So I'm just going to put the motion. Those in favour? Councillor Finzel: No. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor Wilkie. Councillor Finzel: Do we get to have a moment? No. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor Wegener. So that we still have not got the resolution. Against. Against. Yes. Sorry. Better not put my hand up both ways. Councillor Wilson. Councillor Phillips. Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Finzel. And do we have a further motion? Councillor Lorentson: I'd like to move an alternative motion. Thank you. That council A notes the report regarding the proposed funding arrangement with Tourism Noosa.

01:25:00 Director Rawlings: Can you just give me a moment to catch up? Councillor Lorentson: Sure. I've sent it in an email 10 minutes ago. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Is this the right one? Councillor Lorentson: That's correct. Yes. That council A notes the report regarding the proposed funding arrangement with Tourism Noosa. B does not adopt the proposed deed in its current form. C requests that the chief executive officer prepare an interim funding arrangement with

01:26:00 Tourism Noosa to ensure continuity of core destination marketing services. And F notes that the intent of this resolution is to ensure continuity of tourism promotion services while the council undertakes a full review of governance, funding arrangements and community consultation. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Do we have a seconder for that motion? Councillor Phillips: I have a second. Councillor Lorentson: Councillor Phillips was seconded. Seconder, Councillor Lorentson. I just think this is the correct way forward. It acknowledges the decision that's been made around the table today and also ensures that a short, there's some continuity while full review is undertaken. I'm surprised that default position for funding for Tourism Noosa had, or a contingency planning

01:27:00 hadn't been put in place. I don't think it was put to us in case this didn't go through. So I think this gives us the opportunity to provide some continuity, ensure that there is continued core destination marketing services delivered and that we have the opportunity to review the agreement, the funding arrangements and most importantly ensure that we deliver on our May 2025 resolution. Thank you. Councillor Wegener: I think that we have voted to not support tourism, to continue on, I just don't support

01:28:00 this, say that we're going to, including community consultation and a floor review of governance, we've been doing that for two years now, but kind of over it, like cut the head off the snake, we did it, so that won't support it. Mayor Wilkie: Look, I'm really surprised that a plan B for something that has been in the making for such a long time, that is inextricably linked to delivery of the destination management plan, has just been conjured up in the last ten minutes. Certainly we need something to go forward to Thursday, because by that time we may have some legal advice about what tourism Noosa may do with their next step, and how we've left them exposed.

01:29:00 Look, I'll probably be in a minority. I'll probably be in a minority. And this, we'll have something to go to Thursday's meeting, but I can't support this resolution because it's a hastily cobbled together plan B that pales into insignificance when compared against the rigour and the governance and the partnership and the good faith that has gone into preparing the deed, which as we know, internal, external funding, internal legal advice, procurement advice, clear KPIs, and part D is a full review of governance, funding arrangements, community consultation, it's so broad, Council's governance, Council's

01:30:00 funding arrangements, community consultation. Look, I can't support it in principle, but at least we'll have something on the books to go forward to Thursday's meeting. I wish time will, I hope all Councillors will be fully aware of what their, the implications of their decision. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Others wish to talk? Councillor Finzel: Yes, I'd like to speak. Just in response to the no plan B. I mean, this was discussed very early on around if this came to the vote to councillors, it would fall either way. So, you know, it's nothing new, it just is we didn't have, through the negotiations, and everyone working hard for the partnership, we never found agreement in my opinion, and this is where it's landed.

01:31:00 So, I'm just fine with that. I'm not going to put that comment forward in terms of rebutting what the Mayor said with regards to that, because there has been discussion along the journey around that potential to happen. Yeah. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Other hesitate to talk? Councillor Lorentson: Councillor93 was to close. No, I will, I'm just going to just draw everyone's attention to the 18th December 2025, decision where there were only six councillors, and it was a split vote, and the decision was made with the casting. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor, you're raising new Com respectively.

01:32:00 Councillor Lorentson: I will close by acknowledging what Councillor Finzel said in terms of this should come as no surprise. There has been discussions during the workshop and a split decision made on the 18th of December 2025 split 3-3. One councillor was away. This, to me, should not be a surprise and, if anything, we should have had some contingency planning in place, understanding that this was very contentious both around this table and also in community. I think this is a responsible way forward. We have also the opportunity between now and Thursday to understand what the legal, financial and operational consequences of this decision are. And, once again, possibly would have been great to have this information knowing that it was going to be contentious before it came to a meeting today.

01:33:00 Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Okay, I put the motion. Those in favour? That's Councillor Lorentson and Phillips. Those against? That's Councillor Wilson, Wilkie, Finzel, Wegener and Stockwell. So we have yet to have a successful motion on this item. Does anyone else have an alternative motion they wish to move? Councillor Wilson. Councillor Wilson: It's the same as what Councillor Morrison just raised but without part C and D. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Thank you.

01:34:00 So the council's, are you clear about this one? It is, while it's waiting, it'll say that council notes the report regarding the proposed funding agreement arranged over the Tourism Noosa, and V, does not support the proposed deed in its current form. Have we got a seconder for that? I think she's second. Councillor Lorentson, Councillor Wilson, you have the floor. Councillor Wilson: I think this is a position that we've arrived at through the vote, the previous motion, but to put it into, turn it around into an action that we can take forward to the ordinary meeting. Also I think maintaining that, the deed in its current form still is potentially the option open to amend the deed. Thank you. Or still have conversations. Mayor Wilkie: Yep. I'll support that, Mr Chair. It's a sensible way forward.

01:35:00 Gives us opportunity to actually get an understanding of how the deed can be amended, to take on board concerns that councilors do have, and even dare I hope for a consensus. I've been called an optimist. I hope that we can reach a consensus. But it at least leaves us. It leaves that door open. Thank you, Councillor Wilson. Councillor Lorentson. Councillor Lorentson: I'm also happy to support it. I think it's again one of our obligations that we come to meetings with open minds and final decisions made at ordinary meeting. I think removing A and B was the correct way to go ahead. So thank you, Councillor Wilson. And happy to support the amendment. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Anyone else wish to talk to the motion? Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: Yes. I'm happy to support the amendment. I do believe we need to leave it open to move through this because this is, you know, a partnership involving not only Tourism Noosa.

01:36:00 This is a partnership between the organisation and our community. It's a partnership between councillors and our community and the people we live and work amongst every day. This is a really major decision. This came up in our previous election campaign. In my opinion, communities strongly raised their concerns around continued funding in its current form around tourism. And we're all aware of that. We've read the reports. We've discussed it around the table at workshops. And we have actually done our jobs, I might add. And we have worked diligently. And we represent a modern-day leadership group with diversity around the table, understanding that we need to respond to changing expectations in our community and abroad, given the current circumstances that are beyond our control.

01:37:00 What is within our control today is to continue this debate to try and reach a consensus that actually gives fair evidence. We need to bring a clear and equal representation to all our partners. It is with diligence and with code of conduct that we as councillors move to this position. And I do take a front at being told or insinuating that we have not done our jobs. The councillors have worked hard. The staff has worked hard. External community has worked hard. The voices of our people have clearly been indicated. We need each of us as councillors within our areas of influence. We have respected Tourism Noosa, their board, and what they've come to the table with in good faith. So I'm happy to support this because we need the rise of we leaders, that we come together with diversity, but collectively we make those decisions for the best outcome at that given time for all the people that I've just mentioned, that we represent the diversity.

01:38:00 I'm happy to support this. I believe that successful leaders are able to move forward and take on board the ever changing environment, the diversity and the complexities, just as we did in COVID. So I'm confident that this going forward gives us opportunity to further give extra time and expertise rather than just going, oh, I'm going to do this. We have been given enough. Clearly the outcome here today supports that that is not necessarily the case. So in closing I would like to thank each and every person that has worked on this

01:39:00 in good faith to try and achieve a fair and equitable outcome for everyone that we represent in this community. Thank you. Councillor Lorentson: Through the Chair, I think the amendment's not correct. It's C and D that was... Deputy Mayor Stockwell: That's what you were intending to do? Councillor Wilson: Oh, so not A and D, remove A and D? Deputy Mayor Stockwell: No, no. Councillor Wilson: Oh, that's good. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: I think Councillor Lorentson has misunderstood. Councillor Lorentson: He does not adopt the proposal. Oh, okay. Councillor Phillips: I'll speak to it. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Sure. Councillor Phillips: I've been talking to my kids a lot about integrity and honesty lately and for me it just circles back to the way we make real decisions. It's by being really honest at the table and in workshops and when I sat with the Tourism Noosa board, which was two years into my term or not quite, but I was surprised that that would take so long when we were in partnership with an organisation to try

01:40:00 and be on the... or gain an understanding as to where they were at and where we were at as a new council. I think the community expect us to... to be honest with them and honest about the fact that they are scrutinising more than ever where we spend money and so for me it's just bringing back some true honest conversation that has no bias or no already decision made and just really rip the band-aid off and say, you know, what is this? What do we want? And it just fit. To me, it's become so complex. From different opinions and we should just really go back to... I know that the Mayor is not impressed with my wording of evidence-based decision making but for me I think that speaks the truth and I think that's what the community are asking

01:41:00 for us. So I'll support the amendment because I do think it's not surprising to me that we're sitting here today with this in front of us. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Anyone else wish to talk to the motion? Councillor Wilson? Councillor Wilson: So this is just the... As I said before, the previous motion. This is... As the motion was lost, this is the outcome of that. I'm not getting any more... I'm not trying to add anything else in at this late stage. But it is leaving the door open, just saying in its current form. So it doesn't necessarily mean it's the end of our relationship with Torres & Moosa. It just means that we don't support the deed in its current form. There have been comments today, which I'm quite offended by, about councillors not doing their job or councillors wanting more information or councillors not understanding the consequences of their actions and I'm just going to... Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Councillor, I'm going to pull you up. That is not a close. That was regarding to the previous debate.

01:42:00 When you're closing, you're debating... Councillor Wilson: So I'm just saying I'm quite happy that I've done plenty of work on this motion or the previous motion, which resulted in this motion. I can do my job. I have done all my research. I've sought advice and I don't need to be pressured in the next three days about changing my vote. That's it. Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. I'll put the motion. Those in favour? That's Councillor Wilson, Wilkie, Phillips, Lorentson. And Finzel and Wegener. And against? Would be Councillor Stockwell. And I will apologise if in the last debate I did sound like I was admonishing. It wasn't my intent. My intent was to say that I think that if we didn't have a clear understanding, but I'll accept the trade concerns. So I will apologise.

01:43:00 Okay. We'll move on to the next item. We move on now, which the next session is a confidential session. We're going to deal with these items two separately. So we're going to, if I can have a motion just to go in for item one in confidential session, section nine, please. Councillor Lorentson: I'm happy to move that the meeting be closed to the public pursuant to section 254J3G of the local government regulations. Thank you. The next item of the contract is item 2292012 for the purpose of discussing a contract proposed to be made by Council in particular potential commercial negotiations in relation to the contracts for item 9.1 confidential contract award. Contract number CN26032, Noosa Aquatic Centre 50m Pool Water Treatment Plan filtration upgrade works. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Do I have a seconder? I'll second it.

9 CONFIDENTIAL SESSION

▶ 01:43:07

01:44:00 Councillor Wilkie. All in favour? I think they're down to all staff in the room now. So who was going to

9.1 CONFIDENTIAL - Contract Award - Contract No. CN26032 - Noosa Aquatic Centre 50M Pool Water Treatment Plant Filtration Upgrade Works

▶ 01:44:54

01:57:00 Speaker 1: vote? Okay, so welcome back. We're considering item 9.1 for a contract award for the Noosa Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Aquatic Centre 50 metre pool water treatment plant infiltration upgrade works. Do we have a mover for the, we're moving the staff recommendation, Councillor Phillips and I think I saw Councillor Finzeltan seconded. Do you wish to talk to the motion Councillor Phillips? Yes, thank you for the

01:58:00 Councillor Phillips: report. This is one of my favourite places in Noosa. I'll be a little bit sad for 12 weeks but I think the community should be really pleased to know that a much-loved Noosa, you know, place to take kids and lap swimmers and sport swimmers and the likes and all the other factors that the NAC, you know, the gym and everything. So I'm just very pleased to support our sport and active lifestyle in Noosa and I think that it should be celebrated with our community that we're making sure that we've got some really good equipment. Obviously filtration to me is something that would be pretty important at a pool so I'm glad to see and I may have dived under the kids pool the other day playing a game and I'm just really glad. There's going to be some new filtration systems. Thank you.

01:59:00 Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thanks. The CO has pointed out that as this was a confidential item it might be beneficial for the motion to be read out so I'll do that. Note the report by the Sport and Active Lifestyle Managers General Committee dated 13th April 2026 regarding the outcome of the tender process for Noosa's Aquatic Centre 50 metre full water treatment plant filtration upgrade works and award contract numbers CN26032 for Noosa Aquatic Centre 50 metre full water treatment filtration upgrade works to CMP Corporate Pty Ltd under a lump sum contract for a total contract value of $1,210,780.40 GST Inclusive and see delegate to the Chief Executive Officer to negotiate, finalise and execute and do all things necessary to administer and vary the contract on the contract. I do apologise to you, Councillor Phillips, because I only do this on behalf of Council. Is there anyone else who wishes to talk to the motion? No? Are you happy not to close, Councillor Phillips? Put the motion. Those in favour?

02:00:00 Unanimous. Okay, so we move on to the next item which is a contract reward report for the Coroige Ignatium upgrade extension. And Councillor Phillips, you have a declaration. I do. No. Councillor Phillips: Okay. . With Chapter 5B of the Local Government Act 2009, I inform the meeting that I have a prescribed conflict of interest in relation to Item 9.2, Confidential Contract Award Report, Contract Number CN25048, Coroy Genasium Upgrade and Extension on this agenda, because I am working 10 hours per week as the General Manager and Coach of the Coroy Genasium Club. And as a result of my conflict of interest, I will now leave the meeting room while the matter is considered and voted upon. Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Let's wait for Councillor Hooke to leave the meeting room.

02:01:00 And Councillors, could I have a motion to move into Confidential Session, please? Councillor Finzel, I think, had her hand up first. And Councillor Wegener, we're happy that it's a standard wording, we don't need to read that out. All in favour? That's unanimous. We'll just wait for the... Speaker 1: Livestream to be turned up.

9.2 CONFIDENTIAL - CONTRACT AWARD REPORT – CONTRACT NO. CN25048 – COOROY GYMNASIUM UPGRADE AND EXTENSION

▶ 02:01:40

02:15:00 Thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: All right, so welcome back. We've only got the final item. Happy to move. And moved by Councillor Lorentson, seconded by Councillor Finzel. Councillor Lorentson, do you wish to talk to the motion? Councillor Lorentson: I'll read the motion firstly. But Council, I note the report by the project manager and graduate engineer to the general committee meeting dated 13 April 2026. The award contract number CN25048 for Cooroy Gymnastic Upgrade and Extension to Murphy Builders Queensland Pty Ltd. Under a lump sum design and construct contract for an estimated total contract value of $3,692,575.

02:16:00 $3,692,575.40 GST excluded as follows. One, the lump sum amount of $3,218,467.73. Two, the provision of additional scope for the removal of value management options for an amount of $251,607.67. Three, a provisional item sum amount of $251,607.67. Four, a provisional item sum amount of $222,500. And C, delegate authority to the CEO to negotiate, finalise, execute and do all the things necessary to administer and vary the contract on behalf of Council. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. Do you wish to now speak to that, Councillor Lorentson? Councillor Lorentson: Just to firstly acknowledge the report, graduate engineer and Jasper.

02:17:00 Just noting it was really important. It was really well done. And also to make note, the core gymnasium upgrade, it's the only gymnasium, competitive gymnasium facility we've got in the Shire. It's well used, well loved, and we have excellent staff there, including our own counsellor who works there as a coach. I'd also note, I think it's the first time, or first time in a long time, that they actually had gymnasts. It's the first time in a long time, that they actually had gymnasts attending state event down in Brisbane. Again, anything to do with sport and our community, bring it on. We need to be upgrading, extending and providing opportunities for all our sporting groups, membership and growing needs in the Shire for, to help keep our youth active and out of their, off their screens. Again, we cannot support enough of that.

02:18:00 We can't support enough as a council and also as a group of counsellors. So, thank you for the report in front of us. And, yep, happy to support. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Anyone else wish to speak to the motion? Councillor Finzel. Councillor Finzel: Yeah, just quickly. It's all been said. Thank you for the report. I'd like to also acknowledge the stakeholders and the ongoing community engagement that had the privilege to go along to that. And that was a quite extensive work and everyone did a great job. So, thank you. Everyone has been involved and providing a facility that, you know, is at that standard that we can find and train young people to a standard where, you know, perhaps we wouldn't find a few Olympians in the Shire. So, thank you. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Okay. Councillor Lorentson, you wish to close? No, thank you. I'll put the motion. Those in favour? That's unanimous. That brings us to the meeting closed.

02:19:00 But we should give the opportunity. Thank you. We should give the opportunity to Councillor Phillips if she's still in attendance to rejoin the meeting. So, we can close it. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Mayor Wilkie: Thank you. Councillor Lorentson: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Dennis. Deputy Mayor Stockwell: Thank you. You're welcome.

10 MEETING CLOSURE

▶ 02:31:03

Council's recording ends before this item. Where a meeting resolved to close its doors, that is what the end of the recording means — see what council discussed in private.

Elsewhere on this site

Every page here that links to this one, by section.