Noosa Council Watch

An independent, unofficial record of Noosa Shire Council — what council decided, what they closed the doors on, and why it matters. About this site

Noosa Council meetings since 2014: papers, decisions and recordings, and from April 2023 the video cued to each item.

General Committee Meeting - 15 July 2019

Monday 15 July 2019 · General Committee Meeting · 24 decisions minuted

This meeting predates council's current meetings system, which begins in April 2023, so there is no agenda here with each item cued to the video. What follows is what the record holds: council's papers, the recording, and the decisions its minutes record.

Papers

Council keeps papers from before April 2023 on a separate archive page for each year, listed by meeting date. The files stay on council's site — why.

Recording

Decisions

Every decision the minutes record, in the order minuted. Where a division was called the names are on the contested votes register; otherwise the minutes say only whether it carried.

  1. Climate Emergency Declaration
  2. That Council note the report by the Director Environment and Sustainable Development, Carbon Reduction officer and Climate Change Adaptation Program Coordinator… motion Lost · 1–6

    That Council note the report by the Director Environment and Sustainable Development, Carbon Reduction officer and Climate Change Adaptation Program Coordinator to the Planning & Environment Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019, and A. Endorse the following statement: “Council accepts the latest science on climate change provided in the October 2018 report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, and acknowledges that the Noosa Shire is vulnerable to the impacts of climate change including heat waves, more intense storms and sea level rise all of which is likely to adversely affect the Noosa natural and human environment. Council therefore declares that we are in a ‘Climate Emergency” which requires urgent action by all levels of government”; and B. Write to State and Federal Members of Parliament representing the Noosa Shire region, advising of Council’s declaration and requesting they also act with urgency to address climate change through legislated programs and policy positions, to drive action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and to keep global temperatures to a maximum increase of 1.5 degrees Celsius. Amendment 1

    Moved by Tony Wellington, seconded by Jess Glasgow.

    for 1 — Ingrid Jackson
    against 6 — Tony Wellington, Frank Wilkie, Frank Pardon, Brian Stockwell, Joe Jurisevic, Jess Glasgow

    link to this decision · on the contested votes register

  3. Cr Stockwell moved a motion of dissent from the chairperson’s ruling. Cr Wellington seconded the motion of dissent. The Procedural motion of dissent was carried… procedural motion Carried

    Cr Stockwell moved a motion of dissent from the chairperson’s ruling. Cr Wellington seconded the motion of dissent. The Procedural motion of dissent was carried. Amendment 2 reverted to: A. Endorse the following statement: “Council accepts the latest science on climate change provided in the October 2018 report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, and acknowledges that the Noosa Shire is vulnerable to the impacts of climate change including heat waves, more intense storms and sea level rise all of which, unless global action is taken to reduce emissions, is likely to adversely affect the Noosa natural and human environment. Council therefore declares that we are in a ‘Climate Emergency” which requires urgent action by all levels of government”; and B. Write to the Prime Minister, the State Premier, State and Federal Opposition Leaders, and State and Federal Members of Parliament representing the Noosa Shire region, RECOMMENDATIONS ONLY – NOT THE FINAL DECISION OF COUNCIL GENERAL COMMITTEE MEETING 15 JULY 2019 advising of Council’s declaration and requesting they also act with urgency to address climate change through legislated programs and policy positions, to drive action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and to keep global temperatures to a maximum increase of 1.5 degrees Celsius.

    Moved by Ingrid Jackson, seconded by Frank Pardon.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  4. That Council note the report by the Director Environment and Sustainable Development, Carbon Reduction officer and Climate Change Adaptation Program Coordinator… committee recommendation Carried

    That Council note the report by the Director Environment and Sustainable Development, Carbon Reduction officer and Climate Change Adaptation Program Coordinator to the Planning & Environment Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019, and A. Endorse the following statement: “Council accepts the latest science on climate change provided in the October 2018 report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, and acknowledges that the Noosa Shire is vulnerable to the impacts of climate change including heat waves, more intense storms and sea level rise all of which is likely to adversely affect the Noosa natural and human environment. Council therefore declares that we are in a ‘Climate Emergency” which requires urgent action by all levels of government”; and B. Write to the Prime Minister, the State Premier, State and Federal Opposition Leaders, and State and Federal Members of Parliament representing the Noosa Shire region, advising of Council’s declaration and requesting they also act with urgency to address climate change through legislated programs and policy positions, to drive action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and to keep global temperatures to a maximum increase of 1.5 degrees Celsius.

    Moved by Tony Wellington, seconded by Jess Glasgow.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  5. 152006.1999.3 Minor Change to Development Approval to Reconfigure a Lot (52 Lots & Park) at 191 Hollett Road, Noosaville
  6. That Council note the report by the Coordinator Planning to the Planning & Environment Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 regarding Application No. 152006.1999… committee recommendation Carried

    That Council note the report by the Coordinator Planning to the Planning & Environment Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 regarding Application No. 152006.1999.3 to make a minor change to an existing approval for Reconfiguring a Lot (Subdivision 1 Lot into 52 Lots plus Park) situated at 191 Hollett Rd, Noosaville and note that the applicant has lodged an appeal with the Planning & Environment Court given the application has not been decided within the period allowed under the Planning Act 2016.: A. Refuse the change for the reasons outlined in the Planning & Environment Committee Agenda dated 9 July 2019. B. Note the report is provided in accordance with Section 63(5) of the Planning Act 2016.

    Moved by Jess Glasgow, seconded by Frank Pardon.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  7. Coastal Hazards Mapping Refinement
  8. That Council note the report by the Program Coordinator Climate Change Adaptation to the Planning & Environment Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 and: A. e… motion Superseded

    That Council note the report by the Program Coordinator Climate Change Adaptation to the Planning & Environment Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 and: A. eEndorse the Coastal Hazards Mapping Refinement report provided in Attachment 1, including the methodologies contained therein, for the purposes of completing the coastal hazards adaptation plan, informing land use planning, and capital works planning, design and delivery.; and B. Note that any associated mapping outputs developed using these methodologies may be reviewed and updated periodically as required in response to new relevant information, legislative requirements or climate change projections in accordance with Council’s Climate Change Response Policy 2017.

    Moved by Brian Stockwell, seconded by Tony Wellington.

    The minutes record no vote on this motion: they go straight on to the amendment that followed, below.

    link to this decision

  9. That Item B be amended to read: B. Note that any associated mapping outputs developed using these methodologies may will be reviewed and updated periodically… amendment Carried

    That Item B be amended to read: B. Note that any associated mapping outputs developed using these methodologies may will be reviewed and updated periodically as required in response to new relevant information, legislative requirements or climate change projections in accordance with Council’s Climate Change Response Policy 2017.

    Moved by Ingrid Jackson, seconded by Frank Pardon.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  10. That Council note the report by the Program Coordinator Climate Change Adaptation to the Planning & Environment Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 and: A. En… committee recommendation Carried

    That Council note the report by the Program Coordinator Climate Change Adaptation to the Planning & Environment Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 and: A. Endorse the Coastal Hazards Mapping Refinement report provided in Attachment 1, including the methodologies contained therein, for the purposes of completing the coastal hazards adaptation plan, informing land use planning, and capital works planning, design and delivery; and B. Note that any associated mapping outputs developed using these methodologies will be reviewed and updated periodically as required in response to new relevant information, legislative requirements or climate change projections in accordance with Council’s Climate Change Response Policy 2017.

    Moved by Brian Stockwell, seconded by Tony Wellington.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  11. Events Policy - Public Consultation Outcomes and Amended Policy for Adoption
  12. That Council note the report by the Property Advisor to the Services & Organisation Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 and: A. Adopt the final Events Policy … motion Carried

    That Council note the report by the Property Advisor to the Services & Organisation Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 and: A. Adopt the final Events Policy included as Attachment 2, subject to it being amended to exclude wedding ceremonies; B. Authorise the CEO to make any required minor amendments to the Policy prior to publication; C. Note staff will now proceed to finalise event guidelines to support the policy; D. Request the CEO to investigate options for Council’s website to inform residents of all upcoming road closures; and E. Request the CEO to investigate options to undertake detailed community land management planning for the Hastings Street Precinct in accordance with the Land Act 1994 for future Council consideration.; E.F. Request the CEO to investigate options for an environmental management charge to apply to attendees of tourism events, corporate events and events run by for-profit organisations as foreshadowed in section j) of the policy; and F.G. Note the table of events shown on page 6 of the Services and Organisation Committee Agenda dated 9 July 2019 is incorrect and should read as follows: RECOMMENDATIONS ONLY – NOT THE FINAL DECISION OF COUNCIL GENERAL COMMITTEE MEETING 15 JULY 2019 Event Type 2016 2017 2018 Tourism 6 7 7 (e.g. Noosa Tri, Noosa Food & Wine and Festival of Surfing) Community 27 29 26 (e.g. nippers carnivals, surf  4 – Main Beach contests, ocean swims and charity  17– Main Beach West events)  4 – Noosa Woods  1 – Lions Park Corporate 20 16 18 (e.g. corporate dinners, team  5 – Main Beach West building and conference events)  12 – Noosa Woods  1 – Hastings St (Cup Day) Total: 53 52 51 Cr Glasgow left the meeting. Amendment 1

    Moved by Brian Stockwell, seconded by Jess Glasgow.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  13. That Council note the report by the Property Advisor to the Services & Organisation Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 and: A. Adopt the final Events Policy … committee recommendation Carried

    That Council note the report by the Property Advisor to the Services & Organisation Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 and: A. Adopt the final Events Policy included as Attachment 2, subject to it being amended to exclude wedding ceremonies; B. Authorise the CEO to make any required minor amendments to the Policy prior to publication; C. Note staff will now proceed to finalise event guidelines to support the policy; D. Request the CEO to investigate options for Council’s website to inform residents of all upcoming road closures; RECOMMENDATIONS ONLY – NOT THE FINAL DECISION OF COUNCIL GENERAL COMMITTEE MEETING 15 JULY 2019 E. Request the CEO to investigate options to undertake detailed community land management planning for the Hastings Street Precinct in accordance with the Land Act 1994 for future Council consideration; F. Request the CEO to investigate options for and feasibility of an environmental management charge to apply to attendees of tourism events, corporate events and events run by for-profit organisations as foreshadowed in section j) of the policy; and G. Note the table of events shown on page 6 of the Services and Organisation Committee Agenda dated 9 July 2019 is incorrect and should read as follows: Event Type 2016 2017 2018 Tourism 6 7 7 (e.g. Noosa Tri, Noosa Food & Wine and Festival of Surfing) Community 27 29 26 (e.g. nippers carnivals, surf  4 – Main Beach contests, ocean swims and charity  17– Main Beach West events)  4 – Noosa Woods  1 – Lions Park Corporate 20 16 18 (e.g. corporate dinners, team  5 – Main Beach West building and conference events)  12 – Noosa Woods  1 – Hastings St (Cup Day) Total: 53 52 51

    Moved by Brian Stockwell, seconded by Jess Glasgow.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  14. Expressions of Interest for Community Activation Level 1 of Peregian Beach Surf Club
  15. That Cr Stockwell be appointed as Acting Chairperson of the meeting for this item for the purpose of considering the conflict of interest declarations by Cr Wil… committee recommendation Contracts Carried

    That Cr Stockwell be appointed as Acting Chairperson of the meeting for this item for the purpose of considering the conflict of interest declarations by Cr Wilkie and Wellington.

    Moved by Joe Jurisevic, seconded by Frank Pardon.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  16. That Councillors note the perceived conflict of interest declaration of Cr Wellington and resolve that this represents a perceived conflict of interest in this … committee recommendation Contracts Carried

    That Councillors note the perceived conflict of interest declaration of Cr Wellington and resolve that this represents a perceived conflict of interest in this matter and Cr Wellington may remain in the meeting room to participate in the debate and vote on this matter.

    Moved by Joe Jurisevic, seconded by Jess Glasgow.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  17. That Councillors note the perceived conflict of interest declaration of Cr Wilkie and resolve that this represents a perceived conflict of interest in this matt… committee recommendation Contracts Carried

    That Councillors note the perceived conflict of interest declaration of Cr Wilkie and resolve that this represents a perceived conflict of interest in this matter and Cr Wilkie may remain in the meeting room to participate in the debate and vote on this matter. Cr Wellington returned to the meeting.

    Moved by Jess Glasgow, seconded by Frank Pardon.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  18. That Council note the report by the Property Advisor to the Services & Organisation Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 regarding the recent Expression of Inter… motion Contracts Superseded

    That Council note the report by the Property Advisor to the Services & Organisation Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 regarding the recent Expression of Interest process undertaken for Level 1 of the Peregian Beach Surf Club and: RECOMMENDATIONS ONLY – NOT THE FINAL DECISION OF COUNCIL GENERAL COMMITTEE MEETING 15 JULY 2019 A. Agree not to offer a Trustee Permit for Level 1 of the building, as outlined in the Expression of Interest process; B. Offer a 3-year Trustee Permit to Surf Lifesaving Queensland Sunshine Coast Branch over Lot 165 MCH5180 (the whole building and surrounds) for surf lifesaving purposes at Peregian Beach, subject to the Permittee:  Providing annual reporting of key performance indicators and progress toward establishment of a new Peregian Beach Surf Club entity, as outlined in the submitted Strategic Plan;  Facilitating community access and use of the Level 1 building space where such usage does not compromise surf lifesaving activities, as outlined in the submitted Strategic Plan;  Agreeing that opportunities for ratepayer financial support are by application through its community grants program and no commitment is provided by Council for direct ratepayer capital investment identified in the submitted Strategic Plan; and  Agreeing that building maintenance by Council is at Council’s discretion subject to its independent assessment and asset maintenance planning; C. Authorise the CEO to enter into a 3-year Trustee Permit, as generally outlined above; and D. Agree to negotiate a long-term Trustee Lease over Lot 165 MCH5180 for the new Peregian Beach Surf Club entity, subject to satisfactory performance and progress under the Trustee Permit with any future long-term Trustee Lease to explicitly prohibit the installation and operation of gambling machines or gambling facility.

    Moved by Brian Stockwell, seconded by Frank Pardon.

    The minutes record no vote on this motion: they go straight on to the amendment that followed, below.

    link to this decision

  19. Amend the third dot point under B to read:  Agreeing that opportunities for ratepayer financial support are by application through its community grants pro… amendment Contracts Carried

    Amend the third dot point under B to read:  Agreeing that opportunities for ratepayer financial support are by application through its community grants program or through other normal Council processes and no commitment is provided by Council within the terms of the offered permit for direct ratepayer capital investment identified in the submitted Strategic Plan; and

    Moved by Ingrid Jackson, seconded by Frank Wilkie.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  20. That Council note the report by the Property Advisor to the Services & Organisation Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 regarding the recent Expression of Inter… committee recommendation Contracts Carried

    That Council note the report by the Property Advisor to the Services & Organisation Committee Meeting dated 9 July 2019 regarding the recent Expression of Interest process undertaken for Level 1 of the Peregian Beach Surf Club and: A. Agree not to offer a Trustee Permit for Level 1 of the building, as outlined in the Expression of Interest process; B. Offer a 3-year Trustee Permit to Surf Lifesaving Queensland Sunshine Coast Branch over Lot 165 MCH5180 (the whole building and surrounds) for surf lifesaving purposes at Peregian Beach, subject to the Permittee: RECOMMENDATIONS ONLY – NOT THE FINAL DECISION OF COUNCIL GENERAL COMMITTEE MEETING 15 JULY 2019  Providing annual reporting of key performance indicators and progress toward establishment of a new Peregian Beach Surf Club entity, as outlined in the submitted Strategic Plan;  Facilitating community access and use of the Level 1 building space where such usage does not compromise surf lifesaving activities, as outlined in the submitted Strategic Plan;  Agreeing that opportunities for ratepayer financial support are by application through its community grants program or through other normal Council processes and no commitment is provided by Council within the terms of the offered permit for direct ratepayer capital investment identified in the submitted Strategic Plan; and  Agreeing that building maintenance by Council is at Council’s discretion subject to its independent assessment and asset maintenance planning; C. Authorise the CEO to enter into a 3-year Trustee Permit, as generally outlined above; and D. Agree to negotiate a long-term Trustee Lease over Lot 165 MCH5180 for the new Peregian Beach Surf Club entity, subject to satisfactory performance and progress under the Trustee Permit with any future long-term Trustee Lease to explicitly prohibit the installation and operation of gambling machines or gambling facility.

    Moved by Brian Stockwell, seconded by Frank Pardon.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  21. Move: Cr Stockwell That the meeting be adjourned at 2.35pm, to reconvene at 3.00pm. committee recommendation Carried

    Move: Cr Stockwell That the meeting be adjourned at 2.35pm, to reconvene at 3.00pm.

    Seconded by Ingrid Jackson.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  22. Lgaq Annual Conference Proposed Motion – Utility Relocation Costs
  23. That item 6 be deferred to the Ordinary Meeting dated 18 July 2019 to allow staff to provide further information. That Council note the report by the Project Ma… committee recommendation Carried

    That item 6 be deferred to the Ordinary Meeting dated 18 July 2019 to allow staff to provide further information. That Council note the report by the Project Manager to the General Committee Meeting dated 15 July 2019 and approve the submission of the following motion to the Local Government Association Queensland 2019 Annual Conference for consideration and debate: That the Local Government Association of Queensland lobby the State Government and public utility infrastructure owners for the development of a more equitable cost sharing protocol for the relocation or replacement of their infrastructure arising from local government works related to the remaining life of the asset and any capacity upgrade generated by the relocation or replacement works.

    Moved by Joe Jurisevic, seconded by Jess Glasgow.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  24. Lgaq Annual Conference Proposed Co-sponsored Motion – Support
  25. That Council note the report by the Chief Executive Officer to the General Committee Meeting dated 15 July 2019 and co-sponsor, with Cherbourg Aboriginal Shire … committee recommendation Carried

    That Council note the report by the Chief Executive Officer to the General Committee Meeting dated 15 July 2019 and co-sponsor, with Cherbourg Aboriginal Shire Council, the following motion to the Local Government Association Queensland annual conference for consideration and debate: “That the Local Government Association of Queensland recognises the Uluru Statement from the Heart and: 1. Hears and supports the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples’ call for the establishment of a First Nation’s Voice to be enshrined in the Constitution and for a referendum on this matter; 2. Looks forward to working with our constituents, other levels of governments and all Australians to take this next step towards reconciliation; and 3. Requests that the Australian Local Government Association consider expressing similar support for the Uluru Statement from the Heart.”

    Moved by Brian Stockwell, seconded by Frank Wilkie.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  26. Alliance and Funding Agreement Between Noosa Council and the Nature Conservancy
  27. That Council note the report by the Director, Environment & Sustainable Development Department to the General Committee Meeting dated 15 July 2019 and: A. Ap… committee recommendation Grants & funding Carried

    That Council note the report by the Director, Environment & Sustainable Development Department to the General Committee Meeting dated 15 July 2019 and: A. Approve the Alliance and Funding Agreement with The Nature Conservancy provided as Attachment 1 to the report; and B. Authorise the CEO to make minor amendments to finalise the document and to sign and execute the Alliance and Funding Agreement with The Nature Conservancy.

    Moved by Jess Glasgow, seconded by Frank Pardon.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  28. Appointment of External Member to Council’s Audit and Risk Committee
  29. That Council note the report by the Chief Executive Officer to the General Committee Meeting dated 15 July 2019 in relation to the upcoming vacancy for an exter… committee recommendation Carried

    That Council note the report by the Chief Executive Officer to the General Committee Meeting dated 15 July 2019 in relation to the upcoming vacancy for an external member on Council’s Audit and Risk Committee and: A. Thank Cameron Jaggers for his outstanding contribution to the Audit and Risk Committee in his capacity as an external member of that committee for the past five years; and B. Appoint Tim Cronin as an external member of the Audit Committee for a term of two years.

    Moved by Tony Wellington, seconded by Joe Jurisevic.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  30. Financial Performance Report – June 2019 Interim Position
  31. That Council note the report by the Manager Financial Services to the General Committee Meeting dated 15 July 2019 providing results of the interim 2018/19 full… committee recommendation Budget & finance Carried

    That Council note the report by the Manager Financial Services to the General Committee Meeting dated 15 July 2019 providing results of the interim 2018/19 full year financial performance against budget.

    Moved by Frank Wilkie, seconded by Joe Jurisevic.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  32. That the meeting be closed to the public pursuant to section 275(1) (f) and (g) of the Local Government Regulation 2012 for the purpose of discussing Item 11 - … committee recommendation Carried

    That the meeting be closed to the public pursuant to section 275(1) (f) and (g) of the Local Government Regulation 2012 for the purpose of discussing Item 11 - Confidential: Not for Public Release - REC17/0011 Planning & Environment Court Appeal No. D30 Of 2018 - Negotiated Decision Notice & Infrastructure Charges Notice for Reconfiguring a Lot At 29 & 35A Tait St & 30 Eagle Dve, Tewantin.

    Moved by Tony Wellington, seconded by Frank Pardon.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  33. That the meeting be re-opened to the public. committee recommendation Carried

    That the meeting be re-opened to the public.

    Moved by Tony Wellington, seconded by Jess Glasgow.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

  34. Confidential: Not for Public Release - REC17/0011 Planning & Environment Court Appeal No. D30 of 2018 - Negotiated Decision Notice
  35. That Council note the report by the Manager Development Assessment to the General Committee Meeting dated 15 July 2019 regarding Planning & Environment Court Ap… committee recommendation Court cases Closed doors Development Carried

    That Council note the report by the Manager Development Assessment to the General Committee Meeting dated 15 July 2019 regarding Planning & Environment Court Appeal D30 of 2018 and agree to settle the appeal generally in accordance with the following: A. Delete conditions 7 & 22 B. Amend conditions 13 & 20 as follows: 13. An arborist’s report is to be submitted for approval as part of the operational works application. The purpose of the arborist’s report is to identify the native vegetation to be retained on site, whist recognising the need for vegetation clearing to occur in order to carry out the development. The vegetation to be retained must be clear of proposed services, not present a nuisance to neighbouring properties and be generally suitable for the proposed location. 20. A residential driveway must be constructed for lots 7, 8, 17, 20 and 21. The works must be undertaken in accordance with an Operational Works approval. C. Amend the Infrastructure Charges Notice issued for the approved development providing an offset of $150,000 against the infrastructure charges payable.

    Moved by Frank Pardon, seconded by Joe Jurisevic.

    Carried. The minutes do not name who voted which way, which they only had to when a division was called.

    link to this decision

Source

Elsewhere on this site

Every page here that links to this one, by section.